A “rare legal talent” who created and later led the litigation branch in one of the world’s largest law firms, James “Jim” Restivo Jr. was also a pivotal figure in settling historic asbestos claims that spanned nearly five decades.
Mr. Restivo was a longtime partner at Reed Smith and helped to grow the Downtown-based firm, which now includes more than two dozen offices worldwide and 1,500-plus lawyers.
“Jim was a giant in our firm and a big part of the foundation on which today’s global Reed Smith has been built,” said Gregory B. Jordan, the firm’s former global managing partner. “In addition to being a top lawyer he also mentored scores of us on how to be lawyers and leaders, including me.”
Mr. Restivo, 73, of Peters, died Saturday of complications from lung cancer.
A commercial litigator who specialized in complex insurance disputes, Mr. Restivo counted among his clients Mellon Bank Corp. and the University of Pittsburgh.
He also represented Pittsburgh Corning Corp. and other asbestos producers in thousands of lawsuits and served as one of the chief negotiators and founders of the former Asbestos Claims Facility, designed in 1985 to provide an alternative to the courtroom by evaluating and settling a backlog of asbestos-related claims.
Though the Legal Times newspaper characterized the facility as “the boldest attempt ever” in resolving complicated litigation, Mr. Restivo — true to his oft-understated personality — humbly acknowledged it as “quite an achievement,” when asked about it by The Pittsburgh Press in 1984.
What Mr. Restivo didn’t say was that he’d spent 17 months negotiating agreements between asbestos manufacturers and their insurance companies over liability and other disputes that involved a staggering number of lawsuits. Corning alone accounted for more than 400,000 claims.
“Jim was a rare legal talent that you see only once in a generation. When he walked up to a podium, everyone stopped and listened,” said Traci Rea, partner at Reed Smith and mentee of Mr. Restivo. “He was an incredible teacher, mentor and friend. He was perfectly unique and authentic and will never be forgotten by the many whose lives he touched.”
Mr. Restivo grew up in Johnstown and graduated with a bachelor’s degree in history from the University of Pennsylvania in 1968. He went on to Georgetown University Law Center, where he served as editor of the Georgetown Law Review and graduated first in his class in 1971.
“He was one of the first people in his family to go to university,” said his son James Scott Restivo, of South Fayette. “He grew up in a very working-class family. His father was a home-builder, and what my dad achieved went far beyond any expectation he had growing up.”
Mr. Restivo met nursing student Gail Hackenburg while he was a student at Penn and the two married in 1970.
He was hired by Reed Smith in June 1971 and became a partner in 1977.
From 1988 to 1997, he served as head of the litigation department — firmwide — and as a member of the firm’s executive committee.
As a result of his work with the asbestos cases, Mr. Restivo established an insurance recovery practice within the firm and represented Corning during its bankruptcy proceedings.
He recently retired to work as a consultant, representing some of his longtime clients, and as a lecturer.
Mr. Restivo grew close to many of his colleagues after more than four decades with the same firm.
“Jim was respected and loved by his colleagues and known far and wide, not just for his legal acumen, but also for his keen sense of humor, which endeared him to everyone with whom he came into contact,” said Sandy Thomas, Reed Smith global managing partner.
“I do believe he really loved the law,” his son said. “He found love, passion and dedication in the law, and I think he really enjoyed the people he worked with and the challenging cases and the individuals he got to mentor over the years. That was really important to him.”
Mr. Restivo was also a longtime volunteer, fundraising coordinator and board member at Rebuilding Together Pittsburgh, a nonprofit group that helps low-income homeowners make needed repairs and upgrades.
“He was really passionate about Rebuilding Pittsburgh,” his son said. “I remember our family would take part every year in projects. He did the hard work as long as he was physically able and spearheaded their annual fundraisers.”
Along with many professional accolades, Mr. Restivo was recognized in 2007 as a “Community Champion” by the Jefferson Awards for his work with the nonprofit. He was also named a “Champion of Justice” by the Diocese of Pittsburgh Catholic Charities for his work with that organization.
But such recognitions meant little to his father, the younger Mr. Restivo said.
“He never talked about any of the awards he won,” he said. “He didn’t do it for the recognition. He did it simply because it brought him joy and passion. He was doing it because in his heart he knew it was right and he wanted to contribute.”
No matter his work demands, Mr. Restivo always set aside time for family vacations and events and he especially loved being a grandfather, his son said.
“He didn’t have hobbies — there were no weekends golfing — he was fully committed and dedicated to his family,” his son said. “And the day he became a grandfather really, really changed his life.”
Any time that Mr. Restivo lost with his own children growing up was made up for with his eight grandchildren, who fondly referred to him as “Bubba,” a nickname established by his baby granddaughter who had trouble pronouncing “Pa Pa.”
“We started calling him ‘Bubba’ and even his co-workers called him ‘Bubba,’” his son said. “It just stuck.”
One of his son’s fondest memories was a family trip to Niagara Falls, when he and his siblings convinced their dad to take a side trip to Toronto to see “The Phantom of the Opera,” he recalled.
“I remember that he only had so much cash on him and we literally had to pull together dollars and nickels and dimes to buy tickets,” he said. “He just wanted to show us a good time and it’s things like that that I remember. It was him optimizing time with his family to the best of his ability.”
Along with his son, wife and grandchildren, Mr. Restivo is survived by his children Chris Restivo, Andrea Deutschendorf and Jason Restivo, all of South Fayette, and his siblings Richard Restivo, of North Fayette, and Rita Rippin, of Butler.
Family and friends are welcome at Beinhauers, 2828 Washington Road, in Peters, on Friday from 2-8 p.m. A Mass of Christian Burial will be celebrated Saturday at 10 a.m. in Our Lady of Grace Church, 310 Kane Blvd., Pittsburgh, PA 15243. Everyone please meet at the church.
Private interment in Queen of Heaven Cemetery.
Memorial contributions are suggested to the American Cancer Society at donate3.cancer.org.
Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.