John P. Flaherty’s ultimate ambition was to be a dedicated, faithful advocate for justice.

A retired member of the state Supreme Court who served in the role of chief justice for five years, Justice Flaherty relished his role in preserving the dignity of the court and guaranteeing fairness for all.

“I always knew I was working with somebody with a great sense of integrity and a love of the law, who felt strongly about what it takes to ensure there is trust and confidence in the judicial system. That was a huge, huge concern to him,” said Tom Darr, chief administrator of the Supreme Court.

Justice Flaherty, 87, died Wednesday at his home in Indiana Township after a five-year battle with Alzheimer's disease.

Advertise with us

A Squirrel Hill native, Justice Flaherty was the captain of the swim team at Allderdice High School, from which he graduated in 1949.

He earned a bachelor of arts degree from Duquesne University in 1953 before enlisting in the Army, serving as a first lieutenant at Fort Sill in Oklahoma and Fort Knox in Kentucky.

In 1958, Justice Flaherty graduated from the University of Pittsburgh School of Law and opened a private practice in Mt. Lebanon.

During the same time, he worked as a lecturer for pre-law students at Carnegie Mellon University and served as chief counsel for the Pennsylvania Milk Marketing Board.

In 1973, Justice Flaherty, a Democrat, was elected to Allegheny County Common Pleas Court and became no stranger to controversy.

Advertise with us

In 1978, he ordered the closing of the all-black Baxter Middle School, ruling that it was illegally segregated. In another ruling, later overturned on appeal, then-Judge Flaherty ordered the removal of fluoride from public drinking water in 26 communities, based on concerns over its safety.

During his last 15 months on Common Pleas Court, he served as administrative judge of the civil division.

After securing nominations from both parties for a seat on the state Supreme Court in the 1979 primary election, Justice Flaherty was appointed to fill a six-month interim seat on the high court. Later that year, he won a full 10-year term and twice won retention votes before his mandatory retirement in 2001, when he turned 70.

Justice Flaherty became chief justice of the high court in 1996, during one of the most tumultuous times in its history.

Just two years before, former Justice Rolf Larsen was impeached and removed from office after being convicted of criminal conspiracy; squabbles and infighting among the other members of the high court made headlines on an almost daily basis.

Advertise with us

Justice Flaherty’s tenure marked a time of healing for the court, Mr. Darr said, as he stepped into the role of mediator and encouraged his colleagues to speak with one voice.

“Coming out of the Larsen impeachment, Chief Justice Flaherty was very concerned that the public’s trust should be sustained in the aftermath,” he said. “He wanted to restore respect for the judicial system.”

It was Justice Flaherty’s policy to avoid campaigning or seeking endorsements during retention elections.

“I don’t think it’s seemly for a sitting judge to be in the political process,” Justice Flaherty said in an October 1989 story in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.

Even after he retired, the former justice returned to Harrisburg to officiate at ceremonies, Mr. Darr remembered.

Advertise with us

“He really took a huge delight in swearing in the new lawyers,” Mr. Darr said. “He really was one of those folks who believed in the legal process and wanted to sustain it at its best.”

Justice Flaherty was honored with several awards and the title of Chief Justice of Pennsylvania Emeritus upon his retirement, and he continued working with the court in establishing continuing education programs for members of the legal profession.

Mr. Darr said he would never forget Justice Flaherty’s booming voice -- one that didn’t necessarily match his stature.

“I remember being bowled over that he had such amazing power in his voice,” he said. “He would use his voice much like a preacher to emphasize points.”

In 1985, Justice Flaherty met Linet M. Sobeski on the elevator of his office building.

Advertise with us

“He saw my name tag was Sobeski and him being the history buff he was, he knew about King John Sobieski and how he saved Europe,” she said. “He walked me to my truck and that was that. The very next day at work, I received James Michener’s ‘Poland.”’

When she stopped by his office to thank him, the judge wasted no time in securing a date with her and the couple -- who married in December 1987 -- have celebrated every March 19 since as “Elevator Day.”

Justice Flaherty also felt a deep connection to his ancestral home of Ireland and frequently visited the Emerald Isle, where he helped to promote economic and cultural initiatives.

“He had a lot of friends over there,” his wife said. “He was very involved with the Irish-American Partnership in his later days.”

“He used to offer Irish witticisms -- often in Gaelic -- with an intense smile and a twinkle in his eyes,” Mr. Darr said.

Advertise with us

His wife said she would miss her husband’s “bow ties and his beautiful blue eyes.”

“We had a deep love for each other,” she said. “Til the day he died he showed it. One of the last things he said to me was how much he loved me.”

Along with his wife, Justice Flaherty is survived by sons Michael Flaherty, of Farmington, Clarion County, Thomas Flaherty, of Bethel Park, Devon Flaherty, of Indiana Township, and Garrick Sobeski, of Butler; daughters Kathleen Hall, of Farmington, Clarion County, Daragh Flaherty, of Aspinwall, Taya Flaherty, of Clermont-Ferrand, France, and Revere Bittner, of York; and 10 grandchildren.

He was preceded in death by a son, John P. Flaherty, and a brother, Lewis Flaherty.

The funeral was Friday. In lieu of flowers, memorials are suggested to the Alzheimer's Association, 1100 Liberty Ave., Suite E-210, Pittsburgh, PA 15222.

Advertise with us

Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.