Sister Mary Paul Hickey embraced the unfamiliar. To borrow from the modern nomenclature — she leaned in.
Her life as a Pittsburgh Sister of Mercy for the past 80 years was anything but expected. “SMP” — as she was called by her former students — drove a car, didn’t wear the traditional habit and became a Facebook personality at the age of 94.
“She was never afraid to jump right into the unknown,” remembered her brother, Thomas Hickey of Mt. Lebanon.
Sister Mary Paul, 97, died Wednesday of complications from leukemia at the Convent of Mercy in Oakland.
The founder of The Campus School of Carlow University, Sister Mary Paul also served as chair of the university’s education department and made it possible for a generation of women to attend college and pursue careers in education through her Cadets program at Carlow.
Born Mary Helen Hickey in McKeesport, Sister Mary Paul aspired from a very young age to become a nun.
“I’ve been a teacher all my life,” she said in a Carlow Journal story marking her retirement in 2006. “I’m the oldest of five, and, when we would play school, I was always the teacher. And not just a teacher, but I was always a Sister-Teacher. I would drape a white handkerchief across my head to use as a veil.”
Sister Mary Paul joined the Sisters of Mercy in 1939 and took her final vows five years later.
She earned a bachelor’s degree in education from what is now Carlow University in 1951 and went on to graduate with a master’s degree in education from Duquesne University in 1955.
But it was her time at Fordham University in New York City, where she received a doctorate degree in education in 1962, that really shaped much of Sister Mary Paul’s future.
It was at Fordham where Sister Mary Paul was introduced to the concept of the campus school — a laboratory where student teachers could learn teaching techniques firsthand while providing a unique education to students.
“I was so impressed,” Sister Mary Paul said in a 2011 Carlow Journal story about the many campus schools she visited in New York as a doctoral student. “It was an eye-opener. All these grade-school kids were doing higher-level activities — like having chess tournaments — and this was back in 1962!”
Sister Mary Paul brought back what she learned at Fordham and founded The Campus School at Carlow in September 1963.
“The goal was to provide opportunities for college students preparing for elementary school teaching to observe and participate in excellent teaching and enthusiastic learning,” recalled Sister Mary Paul in the 2006 interview for the Carlow Journal. “The Campus School has grown beyond anything I could have imagined.”
The original kindergarten to sixth-grade school has since expanded to include an Early Learning Center, a traditional and Montessori preschool, pre-K, kindergarten and Montessori kindergarten, and grades 1-8 on the university’s campus.
The school now serves as a national model for laboratory schools, said Suzanne K. Mellon, university president, thanks to Sister Mary Paul’s perseverance and innovation.
“Her deep commitment to children and their education, our alumni and Carlow University were a constant throughout her life,” Ms. Mellon said.
Sister Mary Paul served as executive director of the school from 1963 until 1980, when she left to become executive director of St. Peter Home for Children in Memphis, Tenn.
She returned to Carlow eight years later to oversee the Carlow Children’s Center and resumed as director of The Campus School in 1995, where she remained until her retirement.
Sister Mary Paul also taught education students at Carlow as a lecturer and professor and she introduced a Cadet program for Catholic school teachers that would change lives.
The Cadet program was an accelerated bachelor’s degree in which students began classes a week after high school graduation and continued taking courses year-round for two years. They spent their junior and senior years as student teachers at their home diocese, which funded their education, along with a matching scholarship from Carlow.
Growing up in Lawrenceville, the prospects for higher education were bleak for Janice Cygnarowicz Lisiak in 1967.
“I would not have been able to go to college,” said Ms. Cygnarowicz Lisiak, of Middleton, Mass. “It just would not have been feasible.”
When she met Sister Mary Paul in an interview, she felt an instant bond.
“We hit it off immediately and she offered me the scholarship,” said Ms. Cygnarowicz Lisiak, who went on to teach at the school for three more years after she graduated.
Sarah Posti, a third-grade teacher and language arts chair at The Campus School, said she was unsure whether she would be able to get a job at the school because she wasn’t Catholic.
“She hired me 23 years ago,” said Ms. Posti, of Burgettstown, Washington County. “She welcomed me with open arms — it didn’t matter that I wasn’t Catholic.”
After her mentor retired, Ms. Posti often brought her students to visit Sister Mary Paul at the convent for holidays and special occasions.
“She loved to see the kids. And she always let you know even though she retired she would always be there for you,” Ms. Posti said. “She was so dedicated to children, to the school and to service.”
Former cadet Bernadette Burger Skoczylas said Sister Mary Paul changed the trajectory of her life.
“I didn’t have the option to go to college in 1965,” said Ms. Burger Skoczylas, of Harrison City. “I was first generation in my family. A lot of us were. It was a big leap for us. Our lives would have been totally different.”
Ms. Burger Skoczylas stayed in contact with Sister Mary Paul over the years, traveling with her to New Mexico to see another former student in 2014.
Ms. Burger Skoczylas also made a tribute page for Sister Mary Paul on Facebook, which became a favorite hangout for the nun, who joined the social media site after a knee replacement three years ago.
“When she was recovering from the surgery, we got her an iPad,” Mr. Hickey said. “And she just really took to it. She started playing international Scrabble on the internet and became really active on Facebook.”
His sister loved to travel with Mr. Hickey and his five children to Ireland, on cruises and especially during their annual treks to the Outer Banks in North Carolina, he said.
“She was very much a part of our family,” he said.
Even after retirement Sister Mary Paul kept active, founding and directing The Campus School’s Alumni Relations office. She was recognized with an honorary Ph.D. in 2010 by Carlow and was named the university’s Woman of Spirit in 1998.
She had other talents too, her friends remembered, including once raising funds by selling second-hand jewelry donated by her friends from the trunk of her car.
And, there was the “Sister Mary Paul Effect,” Ms. Posti recalled, in which the skies would miraculously clear and bad weather would vanish anytime The Campus School had planned an outdoor event or picnic.
“She had a way of changing the weather,” she said. “We even joked about it at her own funeral because the snow and ice mixture that was supposed to fall on Saturday never did. It was all rain.”
Sister Mary Paul was preceded in death by her brothers, the Rev. John P. Hickey and Paul S. Hickey, and her sister, Loretta Nee.
In lieu of flowers, donations may be made to the Sisters of Mercy, 3333 Fifth Ave., Pittsburgh, PA 15213, or to The Campus School of Carlow University, 3333 Fifth Ave., Pittsburgh, PA 15213.
Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.