When Harry S. Binakonsky in 1979 left the Brentwood medical practice he co-founded to become medical director of what was the Pittsburgh region’s first health maintenance organization, his former co-owners weren’t happy.

“He did not have the support of his partners to leave,” said his daughter, Judy Weitzman. “But he was ready for that challenge.”

Even though some then thought that HMOs were socialist organizations, to Mr. Binakonsky, helping to run an HMO for a man who had been a lifelong progressive – he advocated for medical use of marijuana as early as the 1960s – was “life-affirming to him,” she said.

The HMO was called Penn Group Medical Associates. It would grow from just an idea that Dr. Binakonsky and others hatched in the mid-1970s into a medical plan with access to 100 physicians and specialists in seven regional offices by the late 1990s, before changes in health care led it to split into two separate organizations, one the health care side, the other an insurance company.

Advertise with us

“Binny” – as his friends called him – “afforded us the opportunity to think creatively and implement practices to improve health care,” said Richard Weinberg, one of the many young doctors Dr. Binakonsky recruited to the HMO. “It was what most of us think of as the best time in our careers.”

Though Penn Group no longer exists – some of its health centers are still around and the insurance company was later sold to Coventry – former employees believe its influence continues to be felt.

“It would be hard to exaggerate the impact it had on health professionals all over the city,” said Robert Kraftowitz, another physician who Dr. Binankonsky recruited to Penn Group, in 1983.

Judy Richards, who started at Penn Group as a nurse and rose to vice president of health operations, said: “Those of us on the inside have always felt that we forced Highmark to really look at managed care because even though they thought it would go away, it never did. A lot of that was because of Dr. Binakonsky.”

Dr. Binakonsky, 91, died Tuesday at his home in Whitehall after struggling with several illnesses in recent years.

Advertise with us

The idea behind HMOs, generally, was to solve the ongoing quandary of “how do you provide high quality care in an effective and efficient fashion,” said Dr. Weinberg, who was recruited to Pittsburgh from Minnesota by Dr. Binakonsky in 1983. “We really wanted to come up with a model that was thoughtful.”

To do that, HMOs had people pay a set, annual premium to get access to a contained group of doctors, from primary care to specialists, radiologists, and every other medical need, that was affordable and sought to do as much preventive care as possible.

“The HMO was set up to oppose the fee-for-service model and incentivize quality care,” Dr. Weinberg said. “It is similar to how the Affordable Care Act was set up.”

A big part of it was that Dr. Binakonsky let the incoming doctors know that getting rich was not the goal for them – and he led by example.

“We came in on a salary and collaborated closely with the administration,” Dr. Weinberg said. “Binny was not out to make a fortune or grab as much as he could.”

Advertise with us

And it worked for more than two decades until 1997 when – in the biggest blow - the HMO’s largest patient group, the University of Pittsburgh employees, ended their contract to become insured by the newly created UPMC Health Plan. Pitt’s decision devastated Dr. Binakonsky.

“He did not go into detailed discussions about it because it was so shocking to him that that was what happened,” Ms. Weitzman said. “But it really took a lot of wind out of his sails.”

Harry Samuel Binakonsky was born Jan. 28, 1926, in Jeannette to Minnie and Joseph Binakonsky, who ran a small grocery there. They originally named him Samuel Harry, only to have their son later change it around as an adult because “everyone always called him Harry,” Ms. Weitzman said.

In 1943 he enlisted in the Navy, where he was identified as a possible doctor and put into the V-12 program that sought to quickly school future doctors.

The program sent him to Princeton University, where, in a quirk of wonderful fate, one night in January, 1944, he and a friend, Stanley Levy, ended up at a Seder Passover dinner sitting near Albert Einstein as a fellow guest.

Advertise with us

“It was magnificent,” Dr. Levy, who also became a physician, said about that night with his friend and Einstein. “It was one of the highlights of my life, and Binny’s.”

While he was a medical student at the University of Pittsburgh in 1946, he went out on a blind date with his roommates’s girlfriend’s friend, Jeannie.

“She told a joke that made him laugh that night and he never went out with anyone else,” his daughter said.

Even though he warned her that “medicine was his first love,” they wed in 1948 and were married for 55 years until she died in 2003.

After serving in the Korean War, he returned home in 1955 and set up his private medical practice in Brentwood. It was successful in no small part because he worked 16-hour days, often six days a week.

Advertise with us

“My dad worked hard, and he’d come home at 9 o’clock at night when we were already in bed,” Ms. Weitzman said. “But he’d make sure to come up and talk with us. And when he did spend time with us, he was 100 percent with us.”

After he retired following the breakup of Penn Group, “it was my mom’s time,” Ms. Weitzman said, and though Dr. Binakonsky continued to work part-time for much of the next decade, they traveled more, spending three months a year in Florida, and he played tennis and golf, and tended his garden.

“It was a real retirement,” his daughter said.

For years after he stopped treating patients, his patients would ask about him, said Dr. Kraftowitz.

That was no surprise to his longtime friend, Dr. Levy.

Advertise with us

“What can I tell you?” Dr. Levy said. “He was mensch. He was just a real mensch.”

Dr. Binakonsky also was preceded in death by a son, David; in addition to his daughter, he is survived by seven grandchildren. Services have been held. The family suggests donations to the Sara Jean and Harry S. Binakonsky Palliative Care Fund at Magee-Womens Hospital, 300 Halket St., Pittsburgh, PA 15213.

Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill