SAN JOSE, Calif. — For too much of his singular American life, Muhammad Ali was essentially silent, the final irony for a kid out of Louisville who turned the culture on its head as The Lip, The Mouth, and, of course, The Greatest, if he did say so himself.
Mr. Ali, who died Friday at 74, was the rare personage for whom the term larger that life was invented, but the sadness that must accompany his passing is exacerbated by his long absence from the public square. Debilitated by Parkinson’s and a hyper-accumulation of punches, Ali could not help us much here in the 21st Century, an era that could sorely use a stiff rhetorical dose of his electric wisdom, sociological and otherwise.
While it’s a pity this country’s youngest generation missed his eye-popping athleticism, his manic commentary, his irrepressible showmanship, we’re are all robbed of his unequaled joyousness.
“I was in Louisville to cover his fight with Willi Besmanoff; he was still Cassius Clay then,” the great former Pittsburgh Press columnist Roy McHugh said from his Mt. Washington apartment Saturday. “I called his hotel room and [trainer] Angelo Dundee answered and said, ‘C’mon up; you can meet the fighter.’ I got up to the room and there was no fighter. I said, ‘Where’s the fighter?’ Dundee said, ‘The kid’s so shy, when I told him a reporter was coming up, he ran out of the room and went home.’
“So I sat down on the bed, and Ali came rolling out from under it, jumped to his feet, and started shadow boxing. That’s how I met him.”
McHugh covered some of Mr. Ali’s greatest fights, his second with Sonny Liston, his first against Joe Frazier at Madison Square Garden, but even while barred from boxing for his refusal to register for the draft, Mr. Ali commanded national attention.
Read More
“He spoke at Duquesne during that period,” Mr. McHugh said. “He came as a crusader for racial equality. In that speech he gave a long list of examples of racial inequity. He said, ‘Everything white is good, and everything black is bad. Santa Claus is a big fat white man. Angel food cake is white, but devil’s food cake is dark brown. If you buy an ice cream cone with one scoop of chocolate and one scoop of vanilla, they put the white scoop on top.’ He had the students roaring with laughter, several hundred of them that day.”
Ascendant and inextricable from the decade that brought both the Civil Rights Act and the Voting Rights Act, commentary like that still made Ali a polarizing figure. He was Exhibit A for racists and radicals alike, but the culture would soon come to appreciate a certain street sense in him that pierced the political fog of the period, particularly on Vietnam.
“He understood what the politicians didn’t,” Mr. McHugh said, “that the war didn’t make sense. He didn’t have any political understanding, didn’t know anything about domino theory or the stated reasons for the war, but he had common sense.”
Were he still writing in this, the week before his 101st birthday, Mr. McHugh would posit that Muhammad Ali’s defining quality was charisma, and that he likely had more of it than any athlete, perhaps ever.
It did not hurt, of course, that Mr. Ali happened to be carrying around an unprecedented combination of boxing skills, a grand master’s understanding of ring strategy, and a flair for promotion that would make a carnival barker blush.
“Why am I saying all this?!” he once barked incredulously at the broadcaster Howard Cosell. “Why I am saying all this?! C’mon Howard, the Garden is sold out!”
A student of the wrestling sensation Gorgeous George, Mr. Ali saw the marketing potential for boxing were it to retrofit the good guy-bad guy theatrics of pro wrestling. He was always the good guy, of course, but some good men took a terrible verbal beating from him before they even got to the ring. Mr. Frazier, who fought spectacularly against Mr. Ali three times, got called a "gorilla" and an "Uncle Tom" and never forgave Mr. Ali for casting him as the white man's champion before their first fight. It was no coincidence they each earned an unprecedented $2.5 million.
For the considerable portion of the nation repulsed by Mr. Ali’s grandiosity and his decision to join the Nation of Islam (then called the “Black Muslims”), there might never have been a more electrifying moment than the crack of thunder that was Mr. Frazier’s left hook and sending him to the canvas on the night of March 8, 1971.
“Ali’s white shoes were up in the air,” Mr. McHugh remembered from ringside. “Their crimson tassles flying in all directions.”
Mr. Ali would recover to speak with reporters later that night. He would beat Mr. Frazier again in 1973 and 1975, and he would win the heavyweight title again in 1974 and again in 1978. While we tend to overstate many things in sports and in modern American culture, Ali was a phenomenon that simply could not be overstated, whether by himself or anyone else.
By saying “I am the Greatest,” Mr. Ali did much more than convulse the very notion and redraw the boundaries of common humility, he inspired countless millions the world who wondered whether they could say it, whether they could be it.
That’s what made him larger than life, and there’s really not much death can do about it.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.