Wynn Kenyon, whose ordination by Pittsburgh Presbytery was rejected by the national church in 1974 because he wouldn't ordain women, died Monday after suffering a heart attack at the university where he had been a beloved philosophy professor for 31 years.

While his case fractured his denomination, he was never bitter, said Mr. Kenyon's sister, Mary Kenyon of Jackson, Miss.

"He never looked back in regret in any way," she said. "He believed it meant that God was leading him in another direction. Belhaven University was where he needed to be, and he probably impacted more people there than if he had gone into ministry."

He was the third of 11 children born to a United Presbyterian pastor who ran a summer recreation program in Middlesex for inner-city youths. Three other sons became pastors. But Mr. Kenyon became the center of a storm that drove all of them from the denomination they were raised in.

Advertise with us

Mr. Kenyon, who belonged to a forerunner of what is now the Presbyterian Church (USA), was an honors graduate of Pittsburgh Theological Seminary. In his ordination trial he was questioned about women and said that because he believed the Bible forbade women to hold authority in the church he could not participate in an ordination ritual. But he said he would work with ordained women and wouldn't stop his own congregation from ordaining a female elder.

Pittsburgh Presbytery voted 147-133 to ordain him, but that decision was appealed to the highest court in the denomination. It ruled that "refusal to ordain women on the basis of their sex is contrary to the [church] constitution."

Coupled with a decision allowing a Maryland presbytery to install a minister who didn't believe in the divinity of Jesus, at least eight churches and some prominent theologians in Pittsburgh and Beaver-Butler presbyteries left for the new Presbyterian Church in America.

The case still reverberates, said Charles Partee, emeritus professor of church history at Pittsburgh Theological Seminary. It marked a shift from creeds to constitution for defining the church's beliefs, he said.

"You didn't have to believe everything in the creed. Of course, the constitution cannot be scrupled. It must be obeyed," he said.

Advertise with us

Conservatives later used the tactic against liberals to exclude partnered gay clergy, he said. "Those battles continue, and it splits the church."

But Mr. Kenyon remained in his original denomination for more than a decade after it rejected him. He still worked for a university affiliated with the Presbyterian Church (USA).

He married his sweetheart, Ginny, and earned a doctorate from the University of Miami in Florida. He then joined the faculty of Belhaven University in Jackson, Miss. In 1999 he had a key role in developing the school's signature Worldview Curriculum, which seeks to integrate a Christian perspective across all disciplines in the humanities. He was named Teacher of the Year many times and in 2003 was named "Humanities Teacher of the Year" by the Mississippi Humanities Council.

"He was a one-of-a-kind faculty member, extraordinary in his investment in students, his intellect and his passion for the truth," said Roger Parrott, the president of Belhaven.

He was devoted to his family, making breakfast each day for his wife. They home-schooled their three children, Ms. Kenyon said.

Advertise with us

He had left his original denomination when his congregation moved to the Presbyterian Church in America. Seven years ago he helped to start Redeemer Church, an intentionally multiracial congregation.

"He firmly believed that heaven is no respecter of color, and that churches shouldn't be, either," Ms. Kenyon said.

"He was a philosopher and an intellectual, but he didn't live in an ivory tower. He lived his theology," said the Rev. Michael Campbell, pastor of Redeemer.

Last Wednesday a student found him unconscious in the Belhaven gym, where he had been working out. On Monday the family discontinued life support.

In addition to his wife, Ginny, and sister Mary, he is survived by his mother, Mary, of Ligonier; daughter, Amy O'Donnell of Brandon, Miss.; sons Stephen of Malvern, Chester County, and Michael, stationed in Japan; sisters Marion Sukanovich of Lower Burrell, Ginger Hahn of Asheville, N.C., and Gwen Kenyon of Ligonier; and brothers, Oz of Saxonburg, Hank of Miami, David of Ligonier, John of Columbia, S.C., Bill of Durham, N.C., and Keith of Valencia.

The funeral will be Saturday at 2 p.m. in the Belhaven Center for the Arts, Jackson, Miss.