Roland G. Shute fought bravely for his country, even though it wrongly deported his entire family due to poverty when he was 12 years old. He spent the rest of his life trying to find out how that injustice occurred, and died without an answer on Oct. 2 at UPMC Presbyterian.

He was 89. The cause of death was respiratory failure, said his son, Howard Shute.

Mr. Shute, a painting contractor who lived in Ross, was the oldest son of George and Edith Shute, British citizens who emigrated to the U.S. in 1919. George Shute took courses in farming and livestock breeding and went to work at a state-owned farm near Providence, R.I. He left that post to manage a private farm, but lost the job in the Great Depression.

Their 10 children were U.S. citizens by birth, but the parents, after 15 years in the U.S., had not been naturalized.

Advertise with us

"The Children's Welfare people came along and suggested I was not able to look after my family properly, and the youngsters were taken into a home until I could find work. They were in the institution 90 days," George Shute told the Daily Mirror, a British newspaper, upon arrival in England.

A woman from the welfare bureau told them the children would have to be adopted by the state and the parents would never see them again -- unless they agreed to having the whole family deported back to England. The state would pay for the passage.

"I was terrified," Mrs. Shute told the paper. The couple agreed to leave in order to hold onto their children.

"It was only later I found out that the judge refused to allow the state to take over the children, because he said they were properly looked after and it was no fault of mine that I was out of work," George Shute told the paper. "The whole thing was a trick to make me leave America. That is what I am sore about."

The British press pounced on the story. The common refrain: "This is what America does to its poor."

Advertise with us

The family arrived in England in December 1933, and took up residence in Coventry. Four more children were born.

Roland Shute, the oldest son, absorbed his father's outrage about the deportation. Nevertheless, after the U.S. joined the fight in World War II, Roland Shute went to the U.S. Embassy in London and volunteered for the Army. It was May 1942; the family believes he was the first American soldier to enlist from outside the country.

"He wanted to prove that he was worthy of being an American," said his son.

Mr. Shute served as a rifleman with the 34th Infantry Division, 168th Regiment, B Company. He fought for three years in North Africa, Sicily and Anzio, and was awarded the Bronze Star for heroism. His fellow soldiers called him "Sgt. Limey" because of his English background.

"Coventry was bombed to the ground during the war," said his son. "There was nothing left, so he and his wife decided to start fresh and come back to the U.S."

Advertise with us

Most of the Shutes moved to California after the war, although the four who were born in England stayed there. Roland Shute and his wife were headed to the west coast as well, but when they stopped in Pittsburgh, they liked it and decided to stay.

He became a painting contractor, first in Ben Avon, then the North Side, and finally Ross.

"He spent his whole life trying to find out why they were deported," said Howard Shute. "He researched it for 40 years but there was no record of it anywhere. I don't know if somebody destroyed the records trying to cover it up.

"He called congressmen, senators, state and federal governments. Nobody knew anything. Everyone passed the buck.

"He always wondered why a country as big as this would throw his family out. He served honorably, his war record was impeccable, but that irked him to the day he died."

Advertise with us

In addition to his son Howard of Penn Hills, he is survived by another son, Brandon of New Brighton; a daughter, Janice McClane of McCandless; nine grandchildren; and eight great-grandchildren. He is also survived by two siblings in England and eight in California.

Interment with military honors will be Tuesday at 1 p.m. in the National Cemetery of the Alleghenies, 1158 Morgan Road, Cecil. McCabe Brothers is handling the arrangements. Donations may be made to any veterans organization.