Few customers at the Walmart in Cranberry would have guessed that friendly cashier Mary Alfonsi spent several decades as a tough-as-nails, hair-pulling, crowd-inciting villainess.

But that was Ms. Alfonsi's reputation as "Donna Christiantello," one of the most notable female professional wrestlers in the eastern U.S. from the early 1960s to 1991. (Her alias sometimes was spelled Christantello.) During those years, she also helped train many of the younger women wrestlers who went on to lengthy careers in the sport.

A former North Sider who never finished high school, she left waitressing for a career of bumps and bruises during years of travel to venues ranging from small-town school gymnasiums to the Civic Arena and Madison Square Garden.

"Evil in the ring, an angel outside the ring" was how she was described by Shawn Blanchard, a pro wrestler from Lawrenceville who befriended her in recent years.

Advertise with us

Ms. Alfonsi, who struggled with asthma and breathing problems, was found dead of natural causes Thursday in the Franklin Park residence she shared with her brother, Tom. She was 69.

She was about 20 years old when a girlfriend coaxed her to accompany her to a wrestling event in Pittsburgh whose organizers were trying to recruit future female wrestlers. Ms. Alfonsi initially resisted, then once there, found herself more intrigued than her friend.

She went off to train in Columbia, S.C., under "The Fabulous Moolah," a wrestler named Lillian Ellison who was widely known for developing many of the pro female wrestlers of the era. Ms. Alfonsi became a longtime friend and associate to Moolah, whose matches, like those of many other women, were arranged by Ms. Ellison over a wide geographic span.

Ms. Alfonsi and other women would carpool on grinding jaunts that involved matches almost every night for a couple of weeks, sometimes two a day, while flitting from motel to motel.

A 5-foot-8 hellion, she and tag team partner Toni Rose won national titles and traveled as far as Australia, Japan and Hong Kong for bouts, usually part of a card that included more famous male wrestlers. The outcome of the events was predetermined, but Ms. Rose said the physical performances leading to the end were demanding and often improvised along the way.

Advertise with us

"We weren't divas," said Ms. Rose, of Columbia, S.C., who retired earlier than Ms. Alfonsi, who wrestled into her late 40s. "We were supposed to look nice, but we also were rough and tough."

She said Ms. Alfonsi thrived in the role of villain, which was far more fun for the wrestlers, who would fire up the crowd.

"We would pull hair, pick at the fans, cheat any way we could," Ms. Rose said. "She was not that way in real life. She was a very nice person."

Ms. Alfonsi's brother, six years younger, had no real explanation for how his sister ended up with the life she led. He didn't recall much tussling on her part when young or much physical activity at all, although she always was well-coordinated.

"I think she enjoyed the entertainment portion of it," Tom Alfonsi said, recalling seeing her in a match in Australia during a break from his war duty in Vietnam. "You're in the spotlight, and I think that's attractive in itself."

Advertise with us

While avoiding major injuries, Ms. Alfonsi was competitive and durable enough to end up inducted into the Professional Wrestling Hall of Fame, located in Amsterdam, N.Y., in 2009 and the Keystone State Wrestling Alliance Hall of Fame in 2010.

During 20 years of retirement, she spent time back in restaurant work, caring for an ill mother and in accounting and cashier work for Walmart. Although Ms. Alfonsi kept in touch with people in wrestling and attended occasional matches, she wasn't one to talk with strangers about her past exploits, unless they commented on her sparkling Hall of Fame ring.

To most of her department store customers, she was just a warm and friendly cashier. Little did they know.

In addition to her brother, she is survived by a son, James "Jack" Alfonsi of Washington, Mo., and a sister, Theresa Alfonsi of Brighton Heights.

Arrangements were by the Sperling Funeral Home, McCandless.