After eight years of battling federal authorities in Pittsburgh over his video poker operation, John F. "Duffy" Conley stood before U.S. District Judge Donald J. Lee for sentencing in 1995.
When Mr. Conley's attorney challenged Judge Lee's assertion that his client had flagrantly violated terms of his bond, the jurist responded: "I didn't fall off the turnip truck yesterday. Don't insult my intelligence."
While such a response would be innocuous for many judges, it amounted to a virtually unprecedented angry outburst for Judge Lee, who was viewed by all who knew him professionally and personally as even-tempered, respectful and good-humored.
"He had the best judicial demeanor," said Mickey Lydon, his former law clerk for nearly a decade. "I only saw him lose his temper once or twice. He was much more inclined to handle things with humor and good nature to get his point across.
"There may be a few other judges with a similar demeanor but none with a better one."
Judge Lee, 83, of Friendship Village of South Hills in Upper St. Clair, formerly of Bethel Park, died Thursday -- St. Patrick's Day -- which was one of his favorite days to celebrate his Irish heritage.
Judge Lee's judicial career began in 1984 when then-Gov. Dick Thornburgh appointed him to a vacancy on the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas. He returned to private practice, but in 1988 he was reappointed to the Allegheny County bench by Gov. Robert Casey.
Following the appointment, he was elected to a full 10-year term in November 1989. Three days later, on November 9, 1989, President George H.W. Bush nominated him for a vacancy on the federal bench here. He was confirmed by the U.S. Senate on March 9, 1990, and served as a federal court jurist until his retirement in January 2004.
In addition to two trials for Mr. Conley, other high profile federal court cases over which he presided included those of 43 members of the Larimer Avenue Wilkinsburg (LAW) street gang who were indicted in November 1996 by a federal grand jury on charges of racketeering and drug trafficking.
Regardless if the plaintiff was a gang member in a criminal case or a corporation's chief financial officer in a civil suit, Judge Lee treated each with respect and dignity, Mr. Lydon said.
"He was a gentleman and an all-around just down-to-earth guy," Mr. Lydon said. "He never played the federal judge card."
Christopher T. Lee of Upper St. Clair, one of Judge Lee's seven children, agreed.
"He felt that even a criminal defendant accused of a heinous crime should still be treated with dignity when they were in his courtroom," said Mr. Lee, who like two of his brothers, Craig M. Lee of Upper St. Clair and Kevin W. Lee of Scott, is a lawyer.
Another of Judge Lee's sons, Donald J. Lee Jr. of New York City, noted his father was a conservative Republican in his private life but a moderate on the court.
"It was kind of inconsistent with his personal views but in court he had a wider canvas. For example, he was not a fan of federal sentencing guidelines. He felt people make mistakes and if this was the first time, the judge should have some [latitude] in sentencing."
He noted his father had "a pretty outrageous sense of humor." For example, when the teenage Lee boys would try his patience, Judge Lee would suggest they look into joining the Marines. He even went so far as to drive them to the Marine recruiting station Downtown.
"It was a not-so-subtle message," Donald Lee said with a laugh.
A producer of such films as "Julie and Julia," among others, Donald Lee joked that since he was unlike his three brothers who followed in their father's footsteps and became lawyers, "the joke was that for him to become a federal judge I had to leave town and go to New York ... so his judicial career could flourish."
A Shadyside native, Judge Lee graduated from Central Catholic High School in 1945 and enlisted in the Navy, serving from 1945 to 1947. He was discharged upon the death of his father and enrolled at the University of Pittsburgh under the G.I. bill. He graduated from Pitt and attended night school at Duquesne University School of Law, where he graduated first in his class in 1954.
He began his law career as a clerk to the U.S. District Judge Rabe Marsh and as a fledgling lawyer with George Meyer and Associates. Judge Lee formed the law firm of Dougherty, Larrimer, and Lee with John Dougherty and James Larrimer in 1958 and served as a councilman and solicitor for Green Tree.
He remained a partner until his judicial appointment in 1984. He also served as a special Assistant Attorney General for the State of Pennsylvania from 1963 to 1974.
Judge Lee enjoyed jogging, fishing in Connoquenessing Creek, cross-country skiing, hiking, sailing, reading, and being with his large family. He was preceded in death by his wife of 57 years, Ann Craig Lee.
Judge Lee he is survived by two other sons, Timothy C. Lee of Brooklyn, N.Y., and David P. Lee of Derry, N.H.; a daughter, Mary Beth Pfarner of Robinson; 15 grandchildren, including Sean Lee, the Upper St. Clair and Penn State University football standout who now plays for the Dallas Cowboys; and one great-granddaughter.
Friends will be received at Beinhauer's, 2828 Washington Road, McMurray, today from 7 to 9 p.m. and Sunday from 2 to 4 and 7 to 9 p.m. A Mass will be celebrated Monday at 10:30 a.m. at St. Louise de Marillac Church, Upper St. Clair. Entombment will be in Queen of Heaven Cemetery, Peters.
The family suggests memorial donations to Camp Kon-O-Kwee/Spencer, c/o YMCA of Greater Pittsburgh, 126 Nagel Road, Fombell, Pa. 16123.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.