Dr. E. David Cherup may have chosen to become a family practitioner rather than a medical specialist, but that didn't prevent him from having a specialty: It was the way he connected with his patients.
"He was the epitome of the caring, old-fashioned family doctor," said Karen Williams, a patient of his from Upper St. Clair. "When you visited him, you felt like you were visiting a relative. He would ask how you were doing, but he also would ask how everyone else was doing."
Dr. Cherup, who began his medical career making house calls in the South Hills, died of a stroke Tuesday at Sunrise Assisted Living. He was 88.
One of seven children born to a coal miner and his wife in Nemacolin, Greene County, Dr. Cherup was a star athlete in football, basketball and track at East Bethlehem High School. The only one in his family to pursue higher education, he attended Waynesburg College until he was drafted during World War II. His daughter, Dr. Lori Cherup, said he served as a naval aviator officer, flying missions from aircraft carriers in the North Atlantic.
After the war, Dr. Cherup enrolled in Washington & Jefferson College's pre-med program and in 1949 married his wife, Naomi Rankin, a nurse. Dr. Cherup earned his medical degree at the University of Pittsburgh in 1951 and set up a family practice in Bethel Park with his brothers-in-law, Dr. James Rankin and Dr. Glenn Rankin. The office of Cherup & Rankin became one of the largest practices in the area.
"He did his residency at Shadyside Hospital and decided to become a family doctor," said his daughter, a plastic surgeon living in Upper St. Clair. "He always kind of rued the fact that he hadn't gone on to a specialty or something more with higher pay. But my dad was a go-getter, and he couldn't wait to start his practice."
The field of medicine was much different then, before X-rays, CT scans and MRI machines were available.
Ms. Williams said she naturally doesn't recall the first time she met Dr. Cherup because he delivered her 55 years ago at St. Clair Hospital, of which he was a founding member.
"He gave me my vaccinations, he stitched my leg when I cut it, he was there for all those rites of passage," Ms. Williams said. "And he made house calls. When my sister and I were sick, I remember him coming to the house with his little black bag.
"He was a very special man. What he did would now take five specialists. And he was so kind. I remember being afraid to sit on Santa Claus's lap at the Woolworth's or in the South Hills Village Mall, hiding behind my parents. But I was never afraid to go see Dr. Cherup."
"Back then, he was the patient's first line of consultation," his daughter said. "He was an excellent diagnostician. People would come into the office and complain of something, and he was right all the time.
"I don't know where that came from. I think it was mainly talking to people and experience. Nowadays, they do all these tests.
"When I started practice, 35 years later, people would say to me 'He's such a gentleman, there's nobody like him. He sits and listens and has such a gentle manner.' "
Ever passionate about Pittsburgh sports, Dr. Cherup counted former Steelers coaches Buddy Parker and Chuck Noll among his patients. He retired in 1990, after 38 years of practicing medicine.
Survivors include his wife in Upper St. Clair; a sister, Mary Beth Zibrida of Fredericktown, Washington County; another daughter, Lisa Cherup of Annandale, Va.; a son, David Cherup of Upper St. Clair; and nine grandchildren.
Visitation will be 1 to 4 and 6 to 9 p.m. Sunday and Monday at Beinhauer Mortuary, Peters. A Mass will be celebrated at 10 a.m. Tuesday at St. Thomas More Church in Bethel Park.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.