The Rev. Susan Nelson, a feminist theologian who was a popular professor at Pittsburgh Theological Seminary for 22 years before becoming dean of a seminary in California, died Thursday of a brain tumor at her home in Squirrel Hill. She was 63.
"She was a brilliant woman, very dynamic, who encouraged other women," said the Rev. Libby Hewett, a former student who became a friend.
"She encouraged them to think outside the box, use their creativity and find their own voice."
Born in Monongahela, she was raised Baptist in Nyack, N.Y., and graduated from the University of Rochester. She returned to Pittsburgh as a homemaker and mother when her first husband enrolled at Pittsburgh Theological Seminary. Intrigued, she earned her own master of divinity degree in 1979. She was seven months pregnant when she began doctoral studies at what is now Claremont Graduate University in Claremont, Calif.
"She was a busy woman, a wife and mother who was pioneering a new area in terms of ... feminist theology and women in ministry and women in academia," said the Rev. Kathy Black, vice-dean for academic programs at Claremont School of Theology.
Back then, even women in liberal traditions suffered hostility and weren't taken seriously when they pursued theology, she said.
"She was very much on her own with her passion for thinking theologically and wondering about God and the big questions of life. She couldn't not do it."
Her own church didn't ordain women, so in 1984 she became a minister in what is now the Presbyterian Church (USA). That same year she was hired at Pittsburgh Theological Seminary, where she ultimately held a chair in theology and culture.
Her doctoral thesis became the book "Beyond Servanthood: Christianity and the Liberation of Women." She argued against the view that pride was the seminal sin, saying that was not true for women. Women, she contended, were too self-effacing and sinned in hiding themselves and their gifts. She believed that Christian liberation for women was less a call to service than to freedom in which they could exercise the abilities that God gave them.
When Rev. Hewett first took her classes in the late 1980s, she was afraid to answer questions aloud in class. "But she always encouraged me. She would tell me, 'It's in there, Libby. You can get in touch with your own knowledge.' "
Rev. Nelson's theological interest in sin led her to study the Holocaust. She sought ways for Christians, Jews and Muslims to work together for justice.
Her first marriage had ended in divorce. During a 1990 sabbatical she was a visiting lecturer at San Francisco Seminary, where she met the Rev. David Lutz, a pastoral counselor from Seattle who was pursuing his doctorate. They married in 1991.
That commenced the happiest years of her life, said her daughter, Kathryn Edelman of Swisshelm Park. They managed a blended family with grace, and she delighted in designing the flower garden at their home. Her courses remained among the most popular at Pittsburgh Theological Seminary, even as the school moved to her theological right.
She was in the minority, but never marginal, said the Rev. Barry Jackson, the dean of faculty.
"She wasn't an outlier. She was right at the center of what was going on at the seminary," and was chosen for important jobs such as heading the self-study for accreditation in 2002, he said.
"She was respected even by those who didn't share her views."
In 2006 she became academic dean of Claremont School of Theology, a liberal United Methodist school in major transition. She had a key role in reshaping it as an interfaith seminary.
"She was instrumental in building bridges with the Jewish community and the Islamic community, and in helping the school and the faculty envision how we can be both a school that trains Christian ministers and a school that works with those from other faith traditions to train clergy of all religions to work together in the 21st century," Rev. Black said.
She was in Chicago for a meeting on election night 2008 and heard President-elect Barack Obama give his acceptance speech. When she returned to her hotel she had trouble speaking. Doctors soon discovered an aggressive brain tumor.
She had surgery and was back in her office as she underwent radiation and chemotherapy. At a chapel service for new students in 2009 she preached about her cancer, and the questions that it forced her to face about trusting God amid trouble and uncertainty.
"She was very open about her brain cancer, and with helping the students wrestle with some of those questions," Rev. Black said.
On May 14 she suffered a seizure that ended her ability to work. In July she and her husband moved to Squirrel Hill to be near her children.
She is survived by her husband, David Lutz of Squirrel Hill and Claremont, Calif.; two daughters, Kathryn Edelman of Swisshelm Park and Christina Phillips of Millersville, Md.; a son, James Dunfee of Philadelphia; a stepson, David Lutz, and stepdaughter, Gretchen Fues, both of Seattle; two sisters, Priscilla Nelson of New Jersey and Becky McGovern of Tarrytown, N.Y.; a brother, Randy Nelson of Connecticut; and four grandchildren.
A memorial service will be held Nov. 13 at 3 p.m. in Sixth Presbyterian Church, Squirrel Hill.
Correction/Clarification: (Published November 9, 2010) Saturday's obituary for the Rev. Susan Nelson gave the incorrect year for her ordination and hiring at Pittsburgh Theological Seminary. Both occurred in 1984.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.