Kenneth S. McCarty Jr., a board-certified pathologist who sued Magee-Womens Hospital and the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center in 2004 over allegations of poor quality control in its laboratories, died of neuroendocrine cancer Friday at his Fox Chapel home. He was 62.
Dr. McCarty's wife, otolaryngologist Berrylin Ferguson, said an agreement in the suit had been reached in the past few days after years of legal filings and depositions. In recent days, as Dr. McCarty lay dying, "He said, 'I never gave up. I never gave up,' " Dr. Ferguson recalled. "I do respect that he stood up to them."
Dr. McCarty filed his suit in February 2004, a few months after fellow pathologist Susan Silver filed her own suit, alleging that Magee had falsified hundreds of thousands of Pap smear reports and practiced poor quality control. The accusations prompted the state health department to launch an investigation.
Nearly two years later, state health officials cited Magee-Womens for allowing unauthorized staff to sign Pap smear reports and for not maintaining quality assessment records, but did not fine or otherwise sanction the hospital.
A primary issue for the two pathologists was that someone was affixing their electronic signatures to reports neither of them had reviewed. In one instance, they said, a newly diagnosed breast cancer should have been detected a year earlier. And, according to Dr. McCarty's suit, when they reported their findings, hospital officials tried to cover up the mistake and persuade him to suppress the information.
He said the hospital later removed his pathology equipment, dropped him from routine diagnostic rotations while "expressly suggesting that he leave Magee."
Dr. McCarty, who had a tenured appointment to the School of Medicine, retained his appointment -- Dr. Silver did not -- but he lost his position with the physician practice group. Dr. Ferguson said he continued to see some patients for free. He also remained chief editorial adviser for Pitt Med magazine, the official publication for the Pitt School of Medicine.
Nathan Hershey, an emeritus professor of health law at Pitt, said he informally counseled Dr. McCarty during his six-plus year legal battle with UPMC. "It had to do with the quality of the laboratory work," Dr. Hershey said. "They (UPMC) were trying to do it as inexpensively and quickly as possible, and he was standing on a principle. And when people stand on principle, they can get in serious trouble."
Dr. Hershey said Dr. McCarty had quiet support from many fellow faculty members, but not in an open or organized way. "The very fact that Ken got hit was a sign that other people might get hit, too."
The UPMC lawsuit was not the first time Dr. McCarty had made a public stand against what he saw as sub-standard care. Shortly before he left Duke University in 1993 to accept a tenured position at Pitt, he spoke out against a cancer test used at Duke that he said could result in patients being misdiagnosed.
Dr. McCarty was born in New York City, but grew up in Durham, N.C., where he graduated from high school at age 15, earned his college degree from Duke at 18 and completed medical school, also at Duke, at age 21. He was board certified in both internal medicine and pathology.
Dr. McCarthy is survived by his wife and their five children, Scott of Jacksonville, Fla.; Justin of Tampa, Fla.; Berryhill of Fox Chapel; Winston of Syracuse, N.Y.; and Merriweather of Beverly, Mass.
A service will be held at the Ferguson family plot in De Soto, Ga., on Saturday. A memorial service is planned Nov. 27 at 11 a.m. at Fox Chapel Presbyterian Church, with a reception to follow.
The family asks that memorial donations be made "to the organization of your choice investigating rare diseases or the ethical care of patients."


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.