U.S. Magistrate Judge Amy Reynolds Hay, an accomplished trial lawyer who mentored a generation of young attorneys, died Friday at UPMC Shadyside after a nine-month battle with lung cancer. She was 61 and lived in Squirrel Hill.
Judge Hay had continued working from home since being diagnosed in February. Tests showed she was in remission and the judge planned to return to her Downtown office on Nov. 1.
Blond and blue-eyed, Judge Hay cut a stylish figure in suits and coats she sewed out of fabric purchased on periodic trips to Italy.
"You would have thought they came from a New York designer. I never knew anyone who could do as many things as well as Amy did them," said U.S. District Court Judge Donetta Ambrose. "She was a brilliant judge. She was an amazing seamstress, a cook, a baker. Her work with the Inns of Court was remarkable."
In 1992, with fellow attorney Karen Schichman Crawford, Judge Hay started the first Pittsburgh chapter of the American Inns of Court.
An English tradition brought to America in 1980 by U.S. Supreme Court Chief Justice Warren Burger, inns of court are forums where experienced attorneys and judges make presentations and hold discussions, passing on their knowledge and professionalism to new lawyers. The chapter meets in federal judges' courtrooms or at the Common Plea, a Downtown restaurant.
"There would not be an inn without Amy," said Denise Bigley, administrator of the inn's Pittsburgh chapter, adding that the judge wrote the organization's history and typed its directory.
A partner in the San Diego office of Duane Morris, Ms. Crawford said three other inn chapters were founded here later.
"Being with Amy made you want to be a better friend and made you want to be a better lawyer because she inspired everyone around her by her capabilities and dedication," Ms. Crawford said. "If Amy said she was going to do something, it was done with perfection."
U.S. District Judge Nora Barry Fischer said there is a groundswell among inn members to rename the Pittsburgh inn the Amy Reynolds Hay chapter.
Each year, the Pittsburgh inn held a joint meeting with the University of Pittsburgh inn and the judge's husband, Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Lester Nauhaus, presided over a game of legal Jeopardy with as many as 100 participants, Judge Fischer said.
Judge Nauhaus spoke on the day his wife was sworn in as a U.S. magistrate judge in 2003.
"You have never heard more passionate words in public from a man about his wife. I don't think there was a woman in the audience who had a dry eye," said Judge Fischer.
For 14 years, Judge Hay taught trial tactics at Pitt with Assistant U.S. Attorney Stephen R. Kaufman, who said she offered constructive criticism to students without undermining their confidence.
The daughter of a country doctor, Judge Hay grew up in Somerset and graduated from Somerset High School in 1967.
After earning a bachelor's degree from Pitt in 1971, she taught Spanish for several years at Mount Aloysius College in Cresson, Cambria County. In the late 1970s, she moved to New York and worked in the Garment District at a sweater company.
She started law school in 1979, earned a law degree from Pitt in 1982 and met her husband while working as an intern at the Allegheny County public defender's office.
From 1982 to 1984, she tried cases in the U.S. Department of Justice's Criminal Section of the Civil Rights Division in Washington, D.C.
In 1984, she joined the U.S. attorney's office in Pittsburgh and tried complex medical malpractice cases in the civil division. She served as chief of the civil division from 1989 to 2003, supervising a staff of 10 lawyers. In 2003, she was appointed to the bench.
Besides her husband, Judge Hay is survived by a sister, Tina Hay of State College, Centre County; two brothers, Chris of Somerset, Somerset County, Jeff of Golden, Colo.; and two stepchildren, Jonathan Nauhaus of Squirrel Hill and Sara Nauhaus Birnbaum of St. Albans, Vt.
Funeral services will be held Tuesday at Trinity Evangelical Lutheran Church, 918 Tayman Ave., Somerset. A 10 a.m. visitation at the church will be followed by an 11 a.m. service. A memorial service will be held in the U.S. District Courthouse next month at a date to be determined.
Memorial donations may be made to Hillman Cancer Center, 5115 Centre Ave., Pittsburgh 15232.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.