Terrance P. "Terry" O'Leary was a wry, old-school Pittsburgh police detective who hated theories and loved solving crimes the old-fashioned way -- by hitting the streets.
Once, when confronted with younger detectives who were theorizing about a homicide case based on an autopsy report, Mr. O'Leary took them to task.
"He says, 'Hey, I don't care if we're looking for a left-handed midget. We can't sit in this office and find him. Let's get out in the street.' And that was his philosophy: Let's get out and talk to people," recalled Allegheny County Sheriff William P. Mullen, an old chum and former squadmate of Mr. O'Leary's.
Accompanied by his "friends" Smith and Wesson -- a standing joke the detective would crack -- Mr. O'Leary investigated more than 700 killings in his 14-year career as a homicide detective.
Before that, he worked narcotics for 14 years and developed an enviable Rolodex of informants. When he transferred to homicide, he would start getting calls shortly after a killing.
"If there was a homicide the phones would ring off the hook with people wanting to talk to Terry," recalled Sgt. George DeVault, who was a detective in the night felony squad in the early 1990s.
Mr. O'Leary, whose last assignment was chief of detectives for District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr., died early yesterday at Allegheny General Hospital.
He was 68 and lived in Brookline. Mr. O'Leary had been in declining health because of diabetes, pulmonary hypertension and rheumatoid arthritis.
His widow, Renie, said she did not know the cause of death.
The son of a railroad worker who emigrated from Ireland, Mr. O'Leary and his six siblings grew up in the city's Bluff area on Vickroy Street, the site today of Duquesne University.
As a lad he was nicknamed "Red" because of his hair. He attended Central Catholic High School and met his future wife on the trolley car as they commuted to their respective schools. They married in 1962.
After graduation, Mr. O'Leary spent two years in the Army, earned an associate's degree from what is now the Community College of Allegheny County, and then went to work in the mill.
When he got laid off, he took the test for the police academy and then followed his older brother, Danny, onto the force in September 1965, the beginning of a 33-year career.
Mr. O'Leary worked in uniform in the Hill District and moved into narcotics in the 1970s, investigating many heroin cases. That experience served him well in homicide.
"What he got very good at was the narcotics homicides and the vice homicides, and that's what they were lacking in, someone who had worked the streets recently and had the informants and the contacts," Sheriff Mullen said.
Retired Sgt. John J. O'Connor said Mr. O'Leary had intuitive gifts as an investigator and could "read" crime scenes and suspects.
"If you wanted a crime solved, you called Terry," Mr. O'Connor said. "He had so many contacts throughout the city. You just needed to get him and a telephone together and he'd start making calls."
Mr. O'Leary's colleagues said he was tough. But he could also handle situations quietly. Retired Cmdr. Ronald B. Freeman recalled how Mr. O'Leary calmly talked an unstable man with a gun into surrendering at the emergency room of the old St. Francis Central Hospital.
"He slowly walked over and chit-chatted with the guy. The guy started crying, gave him his gun and it was over. It was amazing," Mr. Freeman said.
Over the years, Mr. O'Leary carved out a reputation as the equivalent of a locker-room leader, someone without the rank but with all the respect.
"Over the years any time anybody needed any advice or an answer, whether it was a new guy or the brass in a difficult circumstance or question, everybody went to O'Leary," said Common Pleas Court Judge Edward J. Borkowski, who was Mr. Zappala's top homicide prosecutor for many years. "He helped me without fanfare and with a great deal of humility."
Mr. O'Leary also helped out his informants who allowed him crack so many cases. He once got an informant out of jail to attend his mother's funeral -- for which Mr. O'Leary and his partner were pallbearers.
Mrs. O'Leary said one informant once sent the couple a wedding anniversary card. Another called about 18 months ago in the middle of the night to thank Mr. O'Leary for advising him to move to another city.
Adversaries also thought highly of Mr. O'Leary, including veteran defense attorney William Difenderfer, who often sparred with the hard-nosed detective over the years -- including on his first death-penalty trial.
"His police work was outstanding," Mr. Difenderfer said. "A guy you don't want to be against in court but a guy you would love to be your neighbor."
Mr. O'Leary eventually found himself as the senior homicide detective in Pittsburgh and acted accordingly, mentoring the next generation.
"When I came into the squad initially back in the early 1990s, he was like the pillar of the squad. He was the go-to guy," said Detective Joseph Meyers, who is now himself one of the old guard. "We learned how to talk to people, we learned how to investigate homicides with shoe leather."
Mr. O'Leary retired in August 1998. He went right to work for Mr. Zappala, who selected him from about a dozen candidates.
"We took on a lot more responsibilities very quickly, but I was comfortable we could do that because I had a guy like Terry running the office," Mr. Zappala said.
Mr. O'Leary retired in March 2008. Friends privately said there was a falling out between him and Mr. Zappala, but Mr. O'Leary kept the details to himself.
Mr. Zappala -- for whom Mr. O'Leary once appeared in a campaign commercial -- said he was "never dissatisfied" with his former top cop.
"We had done everything we had set out to do on the violent crime, drugs, that kind of thing. We were moving into other areas. I think it's fair to say we sat down, we thought about this and we moved into other areas," Mr. Zappala said.
Mr. O'Leary was proud of his Irish heritage. He established the Greater Pittsburgh Police Emerald Society and informally aided the Ireland Institute of Pittsburgh, which his sibling, the late Sister Michele O'Leary, co-founded.
In addition to his wife, Mr. O'Leary is survived by his sister, Kathleen, of Mt. Lebanon; son T.J. of Pittsburgh; and daughter Christine O'Leary-Alleruzzo of Philadelphia.
Visitation will be tomorrow and Thursday from 1 to 5 and 7 to 9 p.m. at William Slater II Funeral Service in Scott, where a Fraternal Order of Police service will be held at 7:30 p.m. Thursday. A Mass will be celebrated Friday at 10:30 a.m. in the Church of the Resurrection in Brookline. Mr. O'Leary will be buried in the National Cemetery of the Alleghenies.
Memorial donations in his name may be made to the Pittsburgh Fallen Heroes Fund, c/o William Slater II Funeral Service, 1650 Greentree Road, Pittsburgh, PA 15220.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.