While Kerry Lewis was studying law, he made the mistake of complaining about the required reading. His friend Frank E. Reilly simply said, "I could do that." When Mr. Lewis put $50 on the claim that Mr. Reilly could not, in fact, do that, so began Mr. Reilly's 30-year career as a criminal defense attorney.
"He said, 'OK, the 50 bucks are on,'" said Mr. Lewis. "Then he whizzed right through law school." That bet was more than fortuitous. Eventually, it led to the longtime legal partnership Mr. Lewis and Mr. Reilly formed in the mid-90s, Lewis, Lewis & Reilly. It also was Mr. Reilly in a nutshell: cool, collected and never one to shirk a challenge.
Mr. Reilly, 64, died at UPMC Montefiore last week after a long battle with cancer of the palate. He is remembered by his friends and family as a true gentleman; the kind of man who "loved his dog so much he would go home at lunchtime to make sure the dog was fed," said fellow defense attorney Bruce Carsia.
While he was quick and dry of wit, Helen Lynch, a criminal court administrator, said she never once heard Mr. Reilly crack a vulgar joke. His younger brother, William Reilly of Crafton, recalled that Mr. Reilly was always dressed to the nines, a "very dapper man who always had his shoes shined."
"If you would open the pages of GQ, you would see Frank Reilly," said Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey Manning. It was this combination of finesse and kindness, confidence and quietude, that defined Mr. Reilly.
Mr. Reilly was born and raised in Pittsburgh. He went to seminary at St. Charles College in Maryland, where he graduated in 1962, followed by St. Vincent's College in Latrobe. But by 1968, Mr. Reilly no longer wanted to be a priest, according to his brother. Instead, he began to teach at Bishop Boyle High School in Homestead.
"He had a gift," said Mr. Lewis. There, the kids affectionately called him "Mr. Rile." Kids who "weren't really students of any type" were more than happy to listen to Mr. Rile, said Mr. Lewis. "He could really reach out to people at any level and make them feel at ease."
After receiving his law degree from Duquesne University in 1973, Mr. Reilly worked in the public defender's office, where he began to build his reputation as an exceptionally kind and respectful attorney. "Frank's ability to succeed in a courtroom was his ability to 'out-nice' his opponents," said Judge Manning.
In addition to his brother, Mr. Reilly is survived by his companion, Janis Surman of Morningside.
A service was held Saturday at Schepner-McDermott Funeral Home.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.