E. Joyce Metzler, of Mount Washington, always enjoyed baking cookies for her relatives and co-workers, but she didn't believe in small batches. When she mailed packages to her grandchildren in college, she would send 14 dozen cookies to make sure there were enough to share with friends.
When she retired from her secretarial job at age 66, she started a home-based business called Cookies By My Gram, which she operated until about two years ago. Mrs. Metzler, 85, died Wednesday at St. Clair Hospital from renal disease.
"She used to say she'd been baking cookies since she was 10 years old, but she gave them away" for most of her life, said her daughter, Joyce Metzler McChesney, of Bethel Park. "Even though she worked full time, she always baked cookies for us."
Her co-workers at Heyl & Patterson Engineering in Green Tree, where she worked for 30 years, were also regularly gifted with cookies. When Mrs. Metzler retired, people asked her to bake for them. Relatives printed up business cards with "Cookies By My Gram," and she was in business, with 25 to 35 regular customers.
"One year at Christmas time she made 1,500 pounds of light and dark fudge in addition to her cookies," Mrs. McChesney said. "She'd make over 100 dozen lady locks at Christmas."
Other favorite cookies included chocolate chip, almond drop, pizzelles, miniature nut rolls, apricot squares, anise twist as well as devil's food cake with sea foam frosting made from scratch for the birthdays of friends and relatives.
"When my daughter, Meghan got married in San Diego in 2002, Mom said, 'You're from Pittsburgh and you're going to have a cookie table,'" Mrs. McChesney said. "The people in California had never heard of a cookie table, but they loved it."
For Meghan and Jamie Gilroy's wedding, Mrs. Metzler baked 50 dozen cookies.
Ms. Gilroy's brother, Kevin McChesney, a teacher in Ohio, said his co-workers and principals always looked forward to packages of cookies from his grandmother. Two years ago, relatives made copies of 12 of her favorite recipes and made nine homemade keepsake cookbooks for children, grandchildren, nieces and nephews.
A graduate of St. Mary of the Mount High School, she was active in the alumni association and was a past officer. Her Catholic faith was important to her, and she shared it with her grandchildren in a special way.
Several times a year "she would take me and my sister to a 2 a.m. Mass at a church" by what is now the Mellon Arena, Mr. McChesney said. "When we were as young as 5 and 7 she would take us, with no fear of venturing Downtown with two young children. Then she would take us to breakfast at Eat 'n Park."
Survivors, in addition to her daughter, granddaughter and grandson, include a sister, Clara Orr Schillinger, of the North Side; three grandchildren; and three great-grandchildren.
A Mass will be celebrated at 11 a.m. today in St. Mary of the Mount Church.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.