It was considered a long-shot gambling case, but Harold Gondelman figured the odds were in his favor.
Harold Gondelman
The veteran defense lawyer agreed to represent a small-time gambler who refused to comply with a federal law that required him and other professional gamblers to register with the Internal Revenue Service, buy a $50 betting stamp each year and pay a 10 percent excise tax on each bet handled.
His client didn't do it because it would tip off law enforcement authorities that he was breaking state laws against bookmaking. When he was arrested, he paid federal fines and court costs for not filing with the IRS.
Mr. Gondelman sued the federal government to recover the fines his client had paid after the U.S. Supreme Court declared the law unconstitutional because it compelled bookmakers to incriminate themselves. It became a class-action case when other bookies asked to be included.
Other attorneys didn't think Mr. Gondelman had a chance of beating the IRS.
But he did. A federal judge ordered the government to pay $441,000 to more than 400 gamblers in Western Pennsylvania who had been convicted and fined between 1955 and 1968.
It was one of many high profile cases the athletic, multi-talented attorney won in a legal career that spanned more than 50 years.
Mr. Gondelman, the son of an immigrant Russian tailor who graduated from the University of Pittsburgh and its law school, died Thursday at a nursing home in Oakland. He had Parkinson's disease.
He was 84, an age he said he might live to be in a lawsuit he filed to challenge a provision in the state constitution that requires judges to retire at 70.
In 1988, he wanted to run for a full 10-year term as a Common Pleas Court judge. He cited mortality tables that said a man 65 years old -- his age at the time -- had a life expectancy of 18.63 more years. He also pointed out he stayed in shape by playing golf and tennis. But the state Supreme Court upheld the age restriction.
He prided himself on winning more cases than he lost, especially when he represented high profile clients.
Among the latter was Lawrence J. Maloney, an assistant superintendent of police for the city of Pittsburgh. He was accused of failing to report $230,873 in additional income from 1958 through 1963, and failing to pay $111,543 in taxes on that money.
Although he pleaded not guilty to the charges, numbers racketeers testified he demanded and received bribes from them to protect their gambling operations. They said that if they didn't pay up, they'd get a visit from "Maloney's Marauders," a group of door-smashing police officers who raided gambling operations.
In his cross-examination of the racketeers, Mr. Gondelman portrayed them as untrustworthy individuals who admitted they had committed perjury in previous trials. Mr. Gondelman then called a number of character witnesses to the stand, including state Supreme Court Justices Michael A. Musmanno and Henry X. O'Brien.
The jury of eight men and four women found Mr. Maloney not guilty of all the charges.
"He did a lot of daring things in that case," said Gerry Gondelman, Mr. Gondelman's wife of 58 years. "He enjoyed cross-examining [then Mayor David L.] Lawrence during that trial. Being an attorney was Harold's identity. He relished every minute of it."
Mrs. Gondelman met her future husband on a bus from Oakland to Squirrel Hill. She had a seat and offered to hold his law books. He had recently returned from the South Pacific, where he served as a lieutenant in an Army military police unit, and was going to law school.
"He was a rock," his wife said. "He was always someone you could depend on. If he said he would do something, he did it. He gave me a marvelous life."
Larry Gondelman of Washington, D.C., the oldest of the couple's four children, said there were two things that meant "all the world" to his father -- "his family and the law."
He said his father's devotion to the law so impressed him that he also became an attorney.
"My father was my hero," he said.
Common Pleas Court Judges Larry Kaplan and Gene Strassburger fondly remembered Harold Gondelman as an insightful member of a daily luncheon group that included other judges and lawyers.
Judge Strassburger said Mr. Gondelman's successful trial tactic of calling judges as character witnesses during the Maloney trial had a short life span. The state Supreme Court passed a rule that requires judges to get its permission before agreeing to be character witnesses.
In addition to his wife and son, Mr. Gondelman is survived by another son, Rick, of Falls Church, Va., also an attorney; two daughters, Kathy Orkin of Squirrel Hill and Nancy Behrend of Denver, Colo.; and six grandchildren.
Services will be held at 11 a.m. today at Rodef Shalom Temple, 4905 Fifth Ave. in Oakland. Visitation will be one hour before the service. Burial will be in West View Cemetery of Rodef Shalom Congregation.
Memorial contributions may be made to the Jewish Community Center, 5738 Forbes Ave., Pittsburgh 15217 or the American Parkinson's Disease Association, 420 E. North Ave., Suite 500, Pittsburgh 15212.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.