David Ward Murphy, a former Common Pleas Court judge and Pennsylvania Super Lawyer whose mediation skills settled scores of cases and saved thousands of emotionally fragile litigants the wrenching stress of a trial, died at his Mount Washington home on Wednesday. He was 63.
Mr. Murphy, a man who worked his way through college as a laborer, was known for his sense of humor, his practical jokes and his heart.
"He wanted to make a difference," said Brennan Hart, of Fox Chapel, an attorney who befriended Mr. Murphy when the two were in law school 33 years ago. "He felt there were few cases that couldn't be settled and saw mediation as a way to help people cope with tragedies."
In 1990, Mr. Murphy was nominated to serve as a judge in the civil division of Common Pleas Court and served until January 1992.
In his tenure on the bench and through more than 5,000 cases, his work was rated exceptional as he handled with sensitivity and aplomb some of the toughest cases stemming from public disasters.
He was noted for his work in resolving cases involving families dealing with property damage; health and personal injury and business losses.
One memorable case stemmed from a Formula One raceboat crash at the 1988 Three Rivers Regatta. A 7-year-old boy died from injuries suffered when a powerboat veered out of control and crashed into a crowd. More than 20 were injured.
For more than a week, Mr. Murphy sat with the parties conciliating a settlement. He was empathetic toward plaintiffs and defendants respected his opinions. It was unusual for a judge to show such compassion, but Mr. Murphy, friends said, wanted the plaintiffs and the defendants to come together and be healed.
"His goal," said Mr. Hart, "was to bring a sense of peace to families that were involved."
In 1997, now back in private practice, Mr. Murphy and two employment lawyers founded JUSTUS Employment Law Mediation Group. The three tried to find ways for both sides of a table to settle disputes without going to court.
The mediation could often be done in a single day and is one of the best things going, Mr. Murphy once wrote in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
"Why? Because [people] feel invested in the settlement; they have 'worked it out' themselves. Nobody 'won,' but nobody 'lost' either; it is a resolution that everyone can live with."
Mr. Murphy gained a national reputation for his high-profile work. He was involved in mediation after the crash of USAir Flight 427; and has mediated personal injury cases for millions of dollars in more than eight states. He developed a conciliation program that became a national model for the Federal Aviation Administration.
A lifelong resident of Mount Washington, he was the son of Ruth and James Ward Murphy, a civil engineer for the city, and a man devoted to neighborhood sports.
On most weekends, he traveled to Erie to sail on the lake in his boat, Judge Knot. Many believe Mr. Murphy's desire to make a difference was adopted from his father.
He majored in psychology and English at St. Vincent College, from which he graduated in 1964.
A former member of Local 1038 of the International Laborers Union, he worked his way through college as a construction laborer.
Before and during law school at Duquesne University, where he was president of the Student Bar Association, he worked in sales and marketing for a razor company and a pharmaceutical company. He finished Duquesne in 1973, and a year later became an assistant attorney general in 1974 and was assigned to PennDOT.
He was appointed to the Board of Viewers in 1982 by Allegheny County's Board of Judges and again in 1988 and 1990.
His skills as a conciliator were polished in 1987 when then Judge Ralph J. Cappy, administrative head of the Civil Division, asked him and his colleagues to tackle a backlog of more than 1,200 tax assessment appeals.
The board virtually eliminated the backlog and Mr. Murphy settled 98 percent of the appeals he presided over.
Mr. Murphy is survived by his wife, Heather Ferrone Murphy; a son, Sean Murphy and a daughter, Kelly Murphy, both of Boston.
There is no visitation. A memorial service is scheduled for Nov. 3 at William Slater II Funeral Service, 1650 Greentree Road, Scott.
Correction/Clarification: (Published Oct. 28, 2006) David Ward Murphy served on Allegheny County Common Pleas Court from December 1990 to January 1992. The length of his tenure as a judge was incorrect in this obituary as originally published Oct. 22, 2006.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.