Judge Raymond L. Scheib, regarded as a fair and hard-working judge during an estimable career in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, died yesterday morning of a heart attack at the Family Hospice at St. Clair Hospital in Mt. Lebanon. He was 91.
Judge Scheib served on the bench for 20 years and was credited with erasing a massive backlog of statutory appeals cases. As a senior judge, he donated his services during state funding shortages that halted judicial paychecks.
An East Liberty native, Judge Scheib attended Central Catholic High School and the University of Pittsburgh, which he attended from 1933 to 1940 and received bachelor's and law degrees. Upon leaving Pitt, he started his law practice.
During World War II, he was a member of the Army Air Forces, rising to the rank of staff sergeant while serving at Selman Field in Monroe, La. But he never went overseas.
"He wrecked his trainer plane," said his son, Ray Scheib Jr., "so they gave him a desk."
Upon getting out of the service, Judge Scheib served with the Pennsylvania Labor Relations Board, specializing as an arbitrator from 1964 to 1977.
"He was a peacemaker," his son said. "Both sides came away feeling like they got a fair shake and they won."
He went on to serve as chairman of the Labor Relations Board, a role he held when, on Nov. 18, 1976, he was appointed to a vacancy on Common Pleas Court by Gov. Milton J. Shapp.
"He didn't become a judge until I was older," Mr. Scheib said. "When I was growing up, he was a lawyer, a politician and an arbitrator."
The politics were distinctly Democratic. His son recalled being raised in a home where pictures of Adlai Stevenson, Harry S. Truman and John F. Kennedy were proudly displayed.
"He was Democratic chairman in Mt. Lebanon, he used to say, when they met in a phone booth."
Retired Commonwealth Court Judge Emil E. Narick, who served in the City-County Building during the same decades as Judge Scheib, said, "We were on the same track, almost parallel."
The two were elected to Common Pleas Court in November 1977. Listed on the same ballot with six other judicial candidates, Judge Scheib was the top vote-getter with 295,984 votes. Judge Narick was close behind.
"He was very conscientious, very hard-working," said Judge Narick, who years later moved on to Commonwealth Court.
On Common Pleas Court, Judge Scheib oversaw appeals of Motor Vehicle Code violations and minor violations of the state Criminal Code, such as shoplifting, disorderly conduct and trespassing. In a 1992 review, Judge John L. Musmanno praised Judge Scheib's "resolute determination and dedication."
But Judge Scheib's last years on the bench were marred by a federal investigation into reports that cases were being fixed in his court.
The investigation became public in July 1993, when FBI agents served a series of search warrants that turned up a stenographer's notebook detailing cases and how they were to be resolved.
In 1996, former Whitehall District Justice Jules Melograne, his brother, Nunzio Melograne, who was Judge Scheib's tipstaff, and court supervisor Walter "Bobo" Cross were convicted of fixing 472 cases. Jules Melograne and Mr. Cross were sentenced to 27 months each in prison. Nunzio Melograne died in 1998 before serving any prison time.
Only the main players were prosecuted and sent to jail, but FBI wiretaps and Nunzio Melograne's secret notebook exposed a broad network of judges, magistrates, lawmakers, court officers and police pulling strings to fix tickets. Indeed, part of the defense argument was that the cases were minor and that "everyone does it."
Assistant U.S. Attorney Leo M. Dillon said at the time that Judge Scheib was not prosecuted because there was no evidence he knew that police officers were being instructed to leave early, forcing some cases to be dismissed. Likewise, there was nothing showing that the judge knew other defendants were being found guilty because of vendettas.
Still, Judge Scheib did not come away unscathed.
"This was a conspiracy by these defendants to prejudice the judge," Mr. Dillon said at the time. "Either he was a co-conspirator or he was a fool who was misled by these defendants."
In February 1996, the state Supreme Court ended Judge Scheib's judicial career when his certification as a senior judge was not renewed.
Ray Scheib Jr., of Murrysville, said his father never talked about the federal investigation and its results.
"I think he felt he was not doing anything wrong. He was just looking out for the little guy or whoever he thought was in the right," he said. "He did try to re-establish his career as an arbitrator after that all occurred, but I don't think anything ever came of it.
"Once you're tainted like that, it's pretty tough to come back."
Still, he said, his father was proud of his career and held his head high as he enjoyed his retirement in Mt. Lebanon. The two would have lunch together on Saturdays.
"We used to run into people and they'd give him a big hello, even after he was retired," he said. "It was very nice."
In addition to his son, survivors include his wife, Catherine H. O'Toole Scheib, of Upper St. Clair; sons Jim O'Toole of Mt. Lebanon, Lawrence J. O'Toole of Pittsburgh and Timothy T. O'Toole of London; and daughters Mary Anne Scheib Hatfield of Dublin, Ireland, Marta Marie Scheib Hathaway of London and Mary Ann O'Toole Sanders of Lakewood, Ohio.
Arrangements, by John A. Freyvogel Sons Funeral Home, 4900 Centre Ave., Shadyside, were incomplete. Burial will be at Queen of Heaven Cemetery, Peters.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.