The Supreme Court said late Thursday night that Alabama could not execute a death row inmate without the man’s pastor by his side and indicated that other states must find a way to honor final requests for a spiritual adviser in the death chamber.
The court’s order came an hour before Alabama’s self-imposed deadline of executing Willie B. Smith III, convicted of a 1991 robbery and murder. A lower court had put the execution on hold, and Alabama asked the Supreme Court to step in.
But the request divided the court’s conservative majority. For the first time since she joined the court in October, Justice Amy Coney Barrett sided with her liberal colleagues in a capital punishment case, saying federal law requires states to accommodate prisoners like Smith.
Justice Barrett joined an opinion by Justice Elena Kagan that said a federal law protecting the religious rights of prisoners set a high bar Alabama did not meet.
“Alabama has not carried its burden of showing that the exclusion of all clergy members from the execution chamber is necessary to ensure prison security,” Justice Kagan wrote. “So the state cannot now execute Smith without his pastor present, to ease what Smith calls the ‘transition between the worlds of the living and the dead.’”
Justice Kagan’s opinion was also joined by fellow liberal Justices Stephen G. Breyer and Sonia Sotomayor. Either conservative Justices Samuel Alito or Neil Gorsuch — or both — must have agreed with the outcome to make up a majority.
Justice Clarence Thomas said he would have allowed the execution to proceed.
Justice Brett Kavanaugh and Chief Justice John Roberts said they would have as well, because Alabama’s ban is nondiscriminatory and, in Justice Kavanaugh’s words, “serves the state’s compelling interests in ensuring the safety, security and solemnity of the execution room.”
But he added that the rest of the court did not agree, and other death-penalty states should take heed.
States wanting to avoid months or years of litigation, Justice Kavanaugh wrote, “should figure out a way to allow spiritual advisors into the execution room, as other States and the Federal Government have done.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.