NEW YORK — A federal judge on Thursday ordered the release of some sealed court records from a 2015 lawsuit against Ghislaine Maxwell, who is now facing charges that she trafficked girls as young as 14 for her former boyfriend Jeffrey Epstein, the late financier and convicted sex offender.

U.S. District Judge Loretta Preska ruled during a hearing with lawyers for both Ms. Maxwell and Virginia Giuffre, who sued Ms. Maxwell for defamation in 2015 after the British socialite said she was lying about having been lured as a teen into sexual abuse by Epstein.

It’s not immediately clear when the records might be released. Maxwell attorney Laura Menninger said she would appeal the ruling, raising the possibility the new documents would not be unsealed within a week, as Judge Preska ordered. If no appeal is granted, though, the documents would begin hitting the docket on July 30.

Judge Preska ruled that the public interest in the matter outweighed Ms. Maxwell’s claims that the documents — including depositions of central players in the Epstein saga — would prove embarrassing or interfere with ongoing legal matters.

Advertise with us

Ms. Maxwell’s opposition to the unsealing effort, filed by the Miami Herald after it published a series of articles on Epstein titled “Perversion of Justice,” had long preceded her arrest on July 2 at a secluded New Hampshire mansion on allegations that she helped shepherd women and underage girls to Epstein for sexual abuse. She has pleaded not guilty but was denied bail in a July 14 hearing.

The documents ordered unsealed by Judge Preska are from the process of discovery, where lawyers from each side can ask detailed questions of each other’s witnesses ahead of a trial. Specifically, they were motions already decided on by a judge who first heard the civil lawsuit from Epstein victims against Ms. Maxwell.

Lawyers for Ms. Maxwell had argued that unsealing the documents could prejudice witnesses or victims in other outstanding cases. Judge Preska was not buying it.

“It should be clear ... the court finds that the countervailing interests identified failed to rebut the presumption of public access to the motions,” she said. “Accordingly, those papers shall be unsealed.”

The judge said some material, including names of most nonparties in the case, would be redacted, and that some documents, like medical records, would remain sealed.

Advertise with us

Ms. Menninger had said in June that one portion of her deposition shouldn’t be made public because it included “intrusive questioning” about Ms. Maxwell’s sex life that the socialite had answered based on her expectation of confidentiality.

Ms. Maxwell’s sworn testimony in the Giuffre case that she had no knowledge of Epstein’s abuse of underage girls was the basis for two perjury charges that accompanied the sex-trafficking charges in the July 2 indictment that Manhattan federal prosecutors unsealed against her.

Ms. Giuffre alleges Epstein abused her when she was 17 and that Ms. Maxwell recruited her when Ms. Giuffre was a spa assistant at Mar-A-Lago Club, owned by now-President Donald Trump.

Through her publicist, Ms. Giuffre said she had no immediate comment.

A federal appeals court in New York last August unsealed 40 of the 613 pages of Ms. Maxwell’s testimony and other evidence that Ms. Giuffre’s lawyers collected in the case. One day after the court’s ruling, Epstein died of an apparent suicide in the Manhattan jail where he was awaiting trial on sex-trafficking charges.

Advertise with us

In testimony that was previously made public, Ms. Maxwell claimed Ms. Guiffre was indeed 17 when she hired her as a massage therapist for Epstein at his Palm Beach estate, but she denied knowledge of any sexual abuse of underage girls or of having witnessed any abuse.

“You can be a professional masseuse at 17 in Florida, so as far as I am aware, a professional masseuse showed up for a massage,” Ms. Maxwell testified. “There is nothing inappropriate or incorrect about that.”

The judge overseeing Ms. Maxwell’s criminal case rejected on Thursday her request to impose a gag order preventing prosecutors, federal agents and lawyers for the alleged victims from discussing the case.

U.S. District Court Judge Alison Nathan said she didn’t think that was necessary at the moment “to protect the Defendant’s right to a fair trial by an impartial jury.”

But Judge Nathan warned lawyers and witnesses that she “wouldn’t hesitate to take appropriate action” if she determined they violated court rules barring them from making comments about the the evidence outside of court.

Advertise with us

The prosecution of Ms. Maxwell, 58, in the Southern District of New York is being closely watched since the alleged madam rubbed shoulders with Hollywood A-listers, Britain’s Prince Andrew and famous politicians, including former President Bill Clinton and Mr. Trump.

Mr. Trump made headlines earlier this week by using a coronavirus news conference to say that he wished Ms. Maxwell “well” in her legal troubles.

The outcome of the civil case will be of interest to prominent lawyer Alan Dershowitz, as Ms. Giuffre has said Ms. Maxwell recruited her to have sex with Epstein and other men, including Mr. Dershowitz, who has denied the allegation.

Mr. Dershowitz — who represented Epstein on legal matters and was also a friend of the multimillionaire — and Ms. Giuffre are suing each other for defamation.

Mr. Dershowitz had urged the unsealing at least some of the documents, saying they would establish his truthfulness.

Bloomberg and the New York Daily News contributed.