President Donald Trump has said that Harley-Davidson Inc. customers are “very angry” about the plan to shift some motorcycle production out of the U.S. to avoid European Union tariffs imposed in response to Mr. Trump’s protectionist measures against the EU.
He’s not completely wrong.
But Hog enthusiasts are like the rest of America: divided. How they feel about what the company’s doing may depend on their politics. And many don’t fit the Harley stereotype.
“It’s frustrating because most people have a one-dimensional view of Harley-Davidson riders,” said Anne Pendleton Phillips, who runs a gardening business in Providence, Rhode Island. She voted for Hillary Clinton in 2016, has owned a Softail Deluxe for 13 years and described herself as a liberal.
Her view is that Harley had no choice but to decide to ramp up production in non-U.S. plants to get around the EU tariffs that could cost the company as much as $100 million a year. “My love for HD won’t change,” she said.
The president is of a different mind, blasting Harley on Twitter -- “I’ve done so much for you, and then this” -- and declaring, “We won’t forget, and neither will your customers.” Mr. Trump praised the company during a White House visit in February 2017 as “a true American icon.”
Harley doesn’t sell any motorcycles in the U.S. that are built overseas, and the company said that is not going to change. It has long produced bikes in foreign countries for other markets. The planned production shift is about products destined for EU markets to avoid 31 percent tariffs on those made in America: They could boost the cost of the average U.S.-made bike shipped to the EU by $2,200.
Some aficionados are angry anyway. “I don’t know what Harley’s thinking,” said Gary Nickoloff, 65, director of the Harley Owners Group chapter in Shiawassee, Michigan, and a Democrat who voted for Mr. Trump. He’s a General Motors retiree who said he will only purchase vehicles built by United Auto Workers union members.
“I feel loyal to Harley. It’s always been an American company,” he said. “If they move work out of the United States, I’m going to feel a lot differently about them, and I’m sure the other members here will likely feel the same.”
There’s plenty of overlap between the company’s customer base and Mr. Trump’s political base. People in both tend to be older, white, rural men, and research from Strategic Vision suggests that for each Democrat who owns a Harley, there are four Republicans. But then comes the divide.
“Trump has no business dictating where products are made,” said Charles Foulke, 58, a semi-retired mechanical contractor from Arlington, Virginia, who owns a 2009 Low Rider. “Harley-Davidson management are no dummies and it should be up to them to decide. All Trump is going to do is drive up costs.”
That’s probably not the main point, according to Al Pupo, 74, a retired electrical contractor in Pocono Lake, Pennsylvania, who has had eight Harleys since 1960, his latest a Sportster 1200 Custom. Buying American-made took on importance to him when he came back from Vietnam.
“After that, you hated anything that was not of this land,” he said. “Even your underwear you pick up you find out its made in Vietnam, of all places, Pakistan, Bangladesh. Not too many things are made in America any more.”
So now? “Everybody’s jumping on Trump and all this crap. Everybody’s panicking and running,” Mr. Pupo said. “I think they’re wrong.”
Marc Skildum is an avid supporter of Mr. Trump who raises alpacas in Dousman, Wisconsin, and rides Electra Glide Ultra Classics with his wife, Stacey. But he doesn’t share the president’s outrage that Harley-Davidson is moving work overseas to get around Mr. Trump’s brewing global trade war.
“It’s business,” said Mr. Skildum, 48, visiting the company’s museum near downtown Milwaukee. “If they can expand overseas and save money, you do it. Trump himself would do it, I feel.”
Jeff Polak, a 54-year-old from Milwaukee who rides a 2013 Harley FLTRU Road Glide, doesn’t blame the president’s tariffs for Harley’s decision to set up more manufacturing operations abroad.
“I think Harley has been planning this for years,” he said. The tariffs presented the company with an easy way to explain the move, he reasoned.
Bob Franz didn’t vote for Mr. Trump, sitting out the election entirely, and doesn’t support his tariffs. You’d be hard-pressed to find a more avid Harley supporter. In his younger days, he rarely met weather not suitable for riding a Harley. One day, it was 40 degrees below zero. He drove to work in his native Milwaukee on his three-wheeled motorcycle, wearing insulated layers beneath and above his black leather riding jacket. The bike’s engine kept his legs toasty. It was comfortable, he said. Now 76, he still puts about 100 miles a week on his 2002 Road King but takes winters off.
Like many in the city where Harley-Davidson got its start, Mr. Franz not only rides the company’s motorcycles but also worked there, as a mechanic for a decade in the 1960s. The pending move to overseas manufacturing can’t be avoided because of the tariffs, he said.
“I don’t think they have any other choice,” Mr. Franz said. But it won’t work in the long term, he said. He pointed to the company’s sale in 1969 to American Machine and Foundry (AMF). AMF moved some manufacturing overseas, he said, which only created problems because factory hands weren’t used to making Harleys. Quality suffered, the company’s finances went south and a group of 12 investors that included Willie G. Davidson, grandson of company co-founder William A. Davidson, bought the company back in 1981.
“You start sending stuff overseas, and nothing works,” Mr. Franz said. “History repeats itself. I’ve seen it happen. In a couple of years it will all be back in Milwaukee.”
On that point, Ms. Skildum, a strong Trump supporter like her husband, agrees.
“Made in America,” she said, raising her hands in a celebratory pose. “Buy American. Support your country. Support your neighbor who needs a job.”
The Washington Post contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.