Canceling “Roseanne” after just two months throws a wrench into ABC’s plan to turn the network around by reaching out to conservative viewers.
The Walt Disney Co.-owned broadcaster dropped the show, the most-viewed new program on television, after series star Roseanne Barr described former Obama administration adviser Valerie Jarrett as the offspring of the Muslim Brotherhood and “Planet of the Apes.” Ms. Jarrett is black and is not a follower of Islam. Ms. Barr, 65, apologized and said she would stop posting on Twitter, but by then her remark had gone viral.
ABC Entertainment president Channing Dungey, the first African-American to lead a major broadcast network, canceled the show after conferring with Disney Media Networks co-chairman Ben Sherwood on Tuesday morning and discussing it with Disney CEO Bob Iger. Advertisers, often a powerful voice in such decisions, didn’t yet have a chance to weigh in.
“There was only one thing to do here,” Mr. Iger said on Twitter shortly after the announcement. “And that was the right thing.”
“Roseanne,” a revival of the long-running hit from the 1990s, drew almost 19 million viewers a week. It was part of a broader strategy at ABC, which included bringing back “American Idol,” to climb out of the cellar by targeting more male, lower-income and middle-American viewers in the wake of now-President Donald Trump’s election. Under Paul Lee, the previous entertainment president, ABC focused on women and minorities -- with shows such as the political drama “Scandal” and the comedy “Black-ish.” When Ms. Dungey took over in February 2016, ABC was still last with the viewers who advertisers target.
Ms. Barr had the ability to speak to working-class viewers in a way that they were not hearing in sitcoms and dramas, where writers are more likely to come from Ivy League universities than the hinterlands.
“The woman still has an authentic voice that America responds to,” said a veteran network TV executive who worked with her in the 1990s and who spoke on the condition of anonymity. “Roseanne understood the working class, struggling for money, things are always tough. … The end at the main title with the big cackle laugh is the key to the show. Things are rotten but we still laugh about it.”
But was ABC’s gamble worth the risk to its reputation?
“We hear ‘Disney’ and we think kids movies and things that everyone just kind of loves,” said Carmenita Higginbotham, a professor at the University of Virginia who is one of the country’s leading Disney scholars. “And the company likes riding the middle, because that’s where the money is,” she said. “But now they’re taking all these public hits - they’re going from the middle to riding the edges - and it’s just startling to watch.”
Opinion writer Roxane Gay wrote in The New York Times Wednesday that ABC did the right in canceling “Roseanne.” ‘‘But before it did the right thing, it did the wrong thing,” she wrote.
“Everyone involved made a decision to support the show despite its co-creator’s racism,” Ms. Gay wrote. “They decided that their career ambitions, or desire to return to network television, or financial interests would best be served by looking the other way. It was only when Ms. Barr became an immediate liability that everyone involved finally looked at her racism and dealt with it directly.”
Ms. Barr posted an apology to Ms. Jarrett, calling the offending tweet insensitive and tasteless. “I am truly sorry -- my whole life has been about fighting racism,” Ms. Barr wrote.
On “Roseanne,” Ms. Barr’s character, a Trump supporter, sometimes argued with her onscreen sister, played by Laurie Metcalf, who expressed liberal views. It was an instant hit with the audience Ms. Dungey hoped to attract.
Conservative commentators, such as Fox News’ Sean Hannity and Laura Ingraham, praised the show after its March debut. Mr. Trump called Ms. Barr to congratulate her and talked up the program at a rally in Ohio.
ABC finished the season that ended this month in third place in prime time among the coveted 18- to 49-year-old viewers. In year-over-year performance, the network lost just 2.4 percent of its audience -- a pretty good year in the age of cord cutting and streaming.
Disney will take a financial hit as a result of the cancellation. For next season, ABC committed to 13 shows with potential ad revenue of as much as $60 million, according to Kantar Media. Reruns would have brought in more. Advertisers paid an average of $167,000 for a 30-second spot on “Roseanne” in April, according to Standard Media Index. That was about 54 percent above the average cost of a sitcom ad on the major networks. About 200 people worked on the show.
Other businesses joined Disney in distancing themselves from Ms. Barr. Viacom’s Paramount Network, TV Land and CMT pulled their reruns of the original “Roseanne.” The talent agency ICM Partners, meanwhile, dropped Ms. Barr as a client.
Burbank, California-based Disney has found itself the target of conservative critics in the past. A+E Networks, which the company half-owns, briefly suspended Phil Robertson, a star of the hit “Duck Dynasty,” when he made crude comments about gay people in an interview. After conservative groups started online petitions and mailed rubber ducks to the company, the suspension ended in a little more than a week.
Disney’s ESPN sports network was criticized by Mr. Trump and other conservatives after “SportsCenter” co-host Jemele Hill called the president a “white supremacist” on Twitter. The network ultimately suspended Ms. Hill before relegating her to an ESPN-related website.
The incidents highlight how tripwires are inevitable in a culture of constant content and social media anger. They also point to a problem faced by Disney, which wants to be the main source of content for the 21st century while also avoiding the era’s pitfalls, company analysts say.
“Disney’s walking a tightrope here,” said Lloyd Greif, a Los Angeles-based investment banker who follows the company closely. “Choosing sides - Democrat or Republican - is a lose-lose since we’re talking about alienating potentially half of the viewership.”
Some critics said the issue that played out with “Roseanne” illustrates that the show should never have been green-lighted in the first place given Ms. Barr’s past comments.
Questionable actions date back to a cringe-worthy, crotch-grabbing rendition of the national anthem in 1990; a claim, later recanted, that she was an incest survivor; and the 2009 picture reprinted on the Daily News. Her social media past includes a racist tweet about former national security adviser Susan Rice and support for conspiracy theories like “pizzagate.” On the same night as her Jarrett tweet, she posted a false claim about Chelsea Clinton that Ms. Clinton refuted.
While no prominent conservatives are defending Ms. Barr, some have turned their sights on ABC.
On Fox News Tuesday, Herman Cain, a former Republican presidential candidate who is also African-American, said he found Ms. Barr’s comment “despicable,” but questioned ABC’s motives for killing the show so abruptly. Broadcast network coverage of Mr. Trump has been mostly negative, he said.
“Because her show defended some of the conservative principles and conservative results,” Mr. Cain said. “I just suspect personally that this gave them a very visible excuse to cancel the show.”
Many of the conservative viewers who flocked to “Roseanne” may consider the show’s cancellation a betrayal, according to Eric Schiffer, chairman of Reputation Management Consultants, a Los Angeles-based consulting firm.
“It backfired,” Mr. Schiffer said. “Conservatives are going to view this as an ambush by the liberal media.”
The Washington Post, The Associated Press and Los Angeles Times contributed.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.