NORRISTOWN, Pa. — A jury of seven men and five women began deliberating Bill Cosby’s fate in his sexual-assault retrial Wednesday.
“You’re going to do justice in the case of Commonwealth v. William H. Cosby,” Judge Steven T. O’Neill told the jurors after instructing them on the charges against the entertainer.
At the same time, Mr. Cosby’s lawyers came under heavy criticism for what some called a blatant attempt to “victim-shame” the parade of women who have leveled accusations against the 80-year-old comedian.
In the first big celebrity trial of the #MeToo era, Judge O’Neill sent the jurors to a deliberation room just after 11 a.m. to determine whether Mr. Cosby is guilty of drugging and molesting Andrea Constand in 2004 at his Cheltenham home. Mr. Cosby says his encounter with the former Temple University women’s basketball executive was consensual.
By the time they had worked for eight hours, the jury had asked several questions of the judge.
The first, less than two hours into deliberations: “What is the legal definition of consent?”
Judge O’Neill told the jurors that he could not answer that question and that they must “decide what that means to them” if it is not defined in the written charges against Mr. Cosby.
Later, jurors asked to rehear the full testimony of Marguerite Jackson, the defense team’s star witness, who testified at trial that Ms. Constand told her she planned to fabricate sexual-assault allegations against a celebrity to make money. Prosecutors had sought to discredit Ms. Jackson by suggesting she had changed her statements over time; jurors also asked to review the statements Ms. Jackson gave to private investigators, but Judge O’Neill told them they could not.
Jurors also asked to listen again to Mr. Cosby’s own words in a deposition from Ms. Constand’s civil lawsuit against him, in which he described the encounter with Ms. Constand and spoke about obtaining Quaaludes with the intention of giving them to women he hoped to seduce. A detective had read the deposition testimony at trial.
The jurors, selected from Montgomery County, have been sequestered since the start of the trial. They heard 12 days of arguments and testimony from more than two dozen witnesses — including Ms. Constand and five other women who say that Mr. Cosby drugged and sexually assaulted them.
In closing arguments Tuesday, Mr. Cosby’s lawyers attacked his accusers as home-wreckers seeking fame, and portrayed Ms. Constand as a con artist who plotted to fabricate allegations against Mr. Cosby to make money.
Defense attorney Kathleen Bliss questioned the “personal morality” of one accuser and called another, model Janice Dickinson, a “failed starlet” and “aged-out model” who “sounds as though she slept with every man on the planet.”
And she slammed the #MeToo movement itself, calling Mr. Cosby its victim and likening it to a witch hunt or a lynching.
Prosecutors said that such attacks are a reason why victims often do not report sex crimes, and described Mr. Cosby as a predator who made a habit of using his fame to gain women’s trust before drugging and molesting them.
Ms. Bliss “is the exact reason why women don’t report these crimes,” said Cosby prosecutor Kristen Feden.
“They’re playing on the same old myths that have been protecting perpetrators for centuries,” said Kristen Houser of the National Sexual Violence Resource Center. She said the defense’s closing argument was filled with “rampant and ingrained” misconceptions about sexual assault and victim behavior.
“It was not only an attack on these six accusers,” Ms. Houser said, “it was a verbal slap to survivors all across this country.”
Gloria Allred, the lawyer for three of the women who testified, blasted the defense closing as “victim-shaming and victim-blaming” and said Mr. Cosby’s lawyers had smeared her clients in a win-at-all-costs effort at an acquittal.
Wednesday marked the second time in less than a year that Mr. Cosby’s case has been placed in the hands of a jury; a panel from Allegheny County spent 52 hours deliberating last June before declaring it was deadlocked. After the case ended in mistrial, one juror said he was convinced of Mr. Cosby’s guilt, and another said that he did not believe Ms. Constand’s testimony.
Judge O’Neill instructed jurors Wednesday that they must not consider the first trial or its outcome — which Mr. Cosby’s lawyers had mentioned in their closing arguments.
“You may have heard questions or reference to a prior trial in this case,” he said. “Any reference or mention is simply not evidence in this case, and you may not consider it as such in your deliberations.”
Ms. Constand, who was in the courtroom for prosecutors’ closing arguments Tuesday afternoon, tweeted a photo Wednesday morning of a statue of “Lady Justice” — a woman holding a scale.
Later, she tweeted a video of herself skydiving: She said she went Tuesday to iFLY, an indoor facility in nearby King of Prussia.
Mr. Cosby, 80, leaned back in his chair as Judge O’Neill spent more than an hour reading instructions to the jury Wednesday morning. He took a nap in the courthouse as the jury deliberated Wednesday afternoon, according to his publicist Andrew Wyatt.
Mr. Cosby is charged with three counts of aggravated indecent assault.
“I’m not going to tell you how to conduct your deliberations,” Judge O’Neill told jurors before sending them to deliberate. “If you have reached a verdict, then you would knock on the door and let us know that you’ve reached a verdict.”
The Associated Press contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.