In official discourse, there clearly are words to avoid, including the seven that George Carlin outlined in his classic comedy routine about words you cannot say on television.
But controversy is brewing over the Trump Administration’s reported advisory to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention against using words or terms commonly used to describe health issues and policies. They include: entitlement, science-based, evidence-based, transgender, fetus, diversity and vulnerable.
The Washington Post also has reported that Obamacare must be used instead of Affordable Care Act, with “sexual risk avoidance” to replace “sex education.”
The issue goes on to suggest that the Office of Management and Budget and the Health and Human Services — the two agencies where the word ban may have originated — would not look favorably on any budgetary request that included those words.
“We were all surprised that these would be words that should be omitted from correspondence with budget documents and the reason is no small irony. Many of those same words and concepts are woven into our Mission, Visions & Values statement,” said Donald Burke, dean of the University of Pittsburgh Graduate School of Public Health.
The Pitt mission statement includes such terms as “diversity,” “health equity,” and “application of the best scientific evidence,” that Dr. Burke described as “core public-health values.”
“I don’t want to get into political analysis,” he said. “But these are words that emphasize what we do here every day at our Center for LGBT [Lesbian Gay Bisexual Transgender] Health Research, our work on babies affected by the Zika virus in the fetal stage, and our work with the health of vulnerable populations on a regular basis. In our mission, visions and values, everything we do is captured in these words.”
In the wake of the controversy, CDC Director Brenda Fitzgerald said “there are no banned, prohibited or forbidden words at the CDC — period.”
The confusion, she said, arose from a staff-level discussion at a routine meeting about how to present CDC’s budget. “It was never intended as overall guidance for how we describe and conduct CDC’s work,” she said.
In a prepared statement, she said the CDC “remains committed to our public health mission as a science- and evidence-based institution, providing for the common defense of the country against health threats. Science is and will remain the foundation of our work.
“CDC has a long-standing history of making public health and budget decisions that are based on the best available science and data that benefits all Americans — and we will continue to do so,” Dr. Fitzgerald stated.
Matt Lloyd, HHS spokesman also said in a statement that “HHS and its agencies have not banned, prohibited or forbidden employees from using certain words.”
“Recent media reports appear to be based on confusion that arose when employees misconstrued guidelines provided during routine discussions on the annual budget process,” his statement said. “It was clearly stated to those involved in the discussions that the science should always drive the narrative. Any suggestion otherwise is simply not true.”
Laura Magana, president and CEO of the Association of Schools and Programs of Public Health, of which Pitt Public Health is a member, had a different view. It’s “CDC censorship,” she said, according to news reports, in statements to the Office of Management and Budget Director Mick Mulvaney — an office thought to be a source of the word ban.
She also sent responses to the House and Senate Appropriations Committee seeking an investigation into what it describes as censorship and calling for Mr. Mulvaney to “immediately and publicly withdraw this censorship order regardless of where or how it originated.”
“Further, we ask you to explain to the American people what steps you are taking to ensure that such censorship will not occur in the future,” Dr. Magana said in her correspondence.
Dr. Burke said news about the advisory involving the seven terms “has engendered a fair amount of discussion” at Pitt Public Health. The seven words will continue being used in day-to-day communications but the question remains about what terminology to use when dealing with federal agencies.
“It’s relatively early but I’m just struck that, when I read those words, how amazing the overlap is with our mission, vision and values,” he said.
David Templeton: dtempleton@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1578. Twitter: @templetoons.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.