Whether caused by a lone wolf or an intimate partner, gun violence is expensive.
As was made painfully evident following the mass shooting event in Las Vegas, the most visible costs are the premature deaths of victims, whether they are the intended target or innocent bystanders. Added to these costs are funerals for the dead, medical and rehabilitation services for the injured, and the investigations, legal fees and incarceration of the perpetrators. No less significant are the future losses associated with insurance payouts, lost earnings of the victims and the pain and suffering experienced by those who make it out alive.
Researchers have come up with several ways to measure the economic burden of gun violence. Calculating these costs is an inexact science: It is virtually impossible to put a price on the emotional agony of losing a loved one. Even so, specialists routinely count the costs of gun violence because juries frequently award damages for wrongful injury and death.
Not surprisingly, different methods yield different estimates.
An assessment undertaken by the Washington-based Urban Institute of the economic impacts of injuries due to firearm assault in the US determined the costs to be roughly $630 million in 2010. This does not sound like much. But keep in mind that this study adopted a narrow approach to costing gun violence, accounting only for the costs of medical services devoted to treating nonfatal injury. Meanwhile, another study applied a more expansive method incorporating medical and rehabilitation bills, insurance payouts and the costs of incarceration due to gun crimes. Not surprisingly, the estimated cost of gun violence in the US skyrocketed to $229 billion a year.
Owing to the comparatively higher costs of treating victims and more elaborate insurance systems, the financial tally of gun violence is higher in developed countries than outside of them. For example, applying a methodology created by the World Health Organization, one estimate determined that the direct medical costs of treating gun injuries in Brazil amounted to just $88 million a year. The researchers found that because bullets shatter bone and shred tissue, gun injuries were up to three times more expensive to treat than knife injuries. To be sure, the study significantly undercounts the overall economic burden of gun violence.
When the indirect costs of Brazil's gun violence are accounted for, then the economic burden grows one hundredfold. More than 42,000 Brazilians died of gun violence in 2012. That's far above the US yearly average of 12,000. If one includes the number of days the injured spent in hospital, the time victims are away from work, and the years of productive life lost to death and disability, then the costs careen upward. Recall that gun-related injuries are especially concentrated in the young and most productive segments of Brazilian society. One decade-old study found that gun violence in Brazil accounts for as much as $10 billion a year, or 0.5 percent of annual GDP. Again, this figure surely underestimates the total costs.
Gun violence represents a tax on all Brazilian citizens — and a costly one. Quite apart from deaths and injuries, it contributes to brain drain, undermines public services, discourages investment and decreases property values.
Yet the costs are underappreciated in Brazil, one of the world's top firearms producers. As a small group of Brazilian politicians known as the "bullet caucus" considers expanding access to firearms for all manner of public officials, they would do well to recall that gun ownership is a privilege, not a right. And this privilege, as evidence shows, will neither reduce the gun violence nor make communities safer. What it does, however, is trample on the most sacrosanct right of all — the right to life.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.