The NFL said it has no plans to discipline players over this weekend’s protests, defying President Donald Trump’s declarations that athletes who stayed in the locker room or took a knee during the national anthem should be fired or suspended. “Our players have a right to express themselves,” NFL Executive Vice President Joe Lockhart told reporters Monday.
The NFL would have a tough time punishing the players even if it wanted to. Unlike most private-sector employees, who can be fired at will, NFL players are protected by contracts that circumscribe when disciplinary measures can be imposed.
“Unless you kick somebody out because of union activity, race, sex, religion -- the employer can dismiss you at any time for any reason,” said William Gould IV, who chaired the National Labor Relations Board under Bill Clinton and has taught sports law at Stanford University.
Companies have terminated employees for running for a seat on the local county commission; having a John Kerry bumper sticker on their car; or volunteering for the AIDS Foundation. The First Amendment free speech protection applies only to government actions, leaving private companies broad discretion to retaliate against workers for their activities, affiliations, or comments inside or outside the workplace.
In his tweet on Sunday, Trump wrote, “If NFL fans refuse to go to games until players stop disrespecting our Flag & Country, you will see change take place fast. Fire or suspend!”
The latest protest gesture came Monday night when the Dallas Cowboys, with owner Jerry Jones, kneeled just before “The Star-Spangled Banner,” then stood with arms locked along with the Cardinals.
Collective bargaining agreements, including in professional sports, generally restrict companies to punishing employees for “just” or “reasonable” cause. (That doesn’t stop teams from declining to employ a potential worker in the first place, as has happened to former San Francisco 49ers quarterback Colin Kaepernick, who started the the practice of kneeling as a protest against police brutality and mistreatment of black Americans.)
Some experts said the idea of firing workers for their political views conjured up memories of the McCarthy-era loyalty norms.
“The economic sanctions that made McCarthyism such an effective measure of political repression were based just about 100 percent on the process of having somebody be identified as a political dissenter by a government institution and then fired by a private employer,” said retired Yeshiva University historian Ellen Schrecker. “The American way of political repression is really much more firing people than throwing them into prison or assassinating people.”
If owners wanted to crack down on unionized athletes protesting during the national anthem, they would need to show some concrete way it was hurting them, said Brad Livingston, a partner at law firm Seyfarth Shaw.
“The employer would argue that it weakens the brand, it weakens the franchise in some way,” said Livingston, who chairs the firm’s labor relations practice group. But he said he doubted that arbitrators would sanction firing a player for kneeling or locking arms during a national anthem.
Teams don’t currently mandate that players stand during the national anthem, said Gould, and union contracts restrict their ability to unilaterally create new rules while a contract’s in place.
Union contracts don’t give players unlimited license to say whatever they want, but arbitrators who resolve contractual disputes tend to show some deference to free speech rights, according to Gould. In a high-profile 2000 ruling, an arbitrator halved (to two weeks of regular season) the length of Major League Baseball’s suspension of relief pitcher John Rocker for derogatory comments to Sports Illustrated about gay people, foreigners, and non-whites.
Federal law provides some limited restrictions on companies’ ability to silence employees’ speech, like the ban on retaliating against workers for filing Civil Rights Act complaints. The 1935 National Labor Relations Act protects private sector employees’ right to take collective action “for mutual aid and protection,” something the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 1978 included distribution of a union newsletter that addressed policy issues like minimum wage and “right to work” laws.
Another recourse for private sector employees exists in state employment law, where some legislatures have gone further than Congress in reigning in management prerogatives. Several states restrict companies from firing employees for things they do outside of work, or more narrowly for involvement in electoral politics.
“We’re talking about to what extent employees are able to maintain their constitutional rights in all spheres of their life,” said James Bhandary-Alexander, a visiting lecturer at Yale Law School who has brought cases under a Connecticut law that restricts companies from firing workers for exercising of First Amendment rights. “How important are our constitutional rights if an employer can fire us for exercising them?”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.