WASHINGTON – Kevin McCarthy quickly and methodically climbed each rung of the power ladder in succession from chief deputy whip, to whip to majority leader of the U.S. House.

Whether the five-term California Republican reaches the top rung largely depends on colleagues in the fractious Republican caucus who on Thursday will pick their nominee to replace the resigning speaker, John Boehner, of Ohio.

Mr. McCarthy’s misstep in a televised interview might give an edge to the brasher and less experienced Jason Chaffetz of Utah, who says he can unify the Republican conference and deliver the GOP message more forcefully.

Rep. Daniel Webster could wind up the compromise candidate. Mr. Webster, who is only in his third term, is relatively unknown in the halls of Congress, but has experience as speaker of the Florida House.

Advertise with us

Democrats are squarely behind Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi of California as their nominee,  but that choice almost certainly will not survive a vote of the full House, where the GOP holds its biggest majority in decades.

That full House vote had been scheduled for Thursday, but Mr. Boehner changed his mind saying that after talking with colleagues he will postpone that until Oct. 29, his last day as both speaker and Western Ohio’s representative to Congress.

“This new process will ensure House Republicans have a strong, unified team to lead our conference and focus on the American people’s priorities,” Mr. Boehner said in announcing the schedule change.

Pennsylvania Reps. Keith Rothfus, R-Sewickly, and Scott Perry, R-York, were among the members who had complained that the decision should not be rushed.

Mr. Boehner’s resignation comes at a time when his caucus is increasingly fractured, with some of the most conservative members planning the first ouster of a sitting speaker in more than a century. Tea Party members were concerned the speaker wasn’t fighting hard enough for their interests.

Advertise with us

The discontent came to a head last month during budget negotiations during which party ideologues were fighting to defund Planned Parenthood even at the risk shutting down the government for lack of spending authority. Their arguments reached a fever pitch after videos surfaced showing Planned Parenthood executives discussing how they harvest tissue from aborted fetuses for scientific research.

Conservatives want a more forceful voice to represent them, but they may not find that in Mr. McCarthy, a moderate with a similar leadership style to Mr. Boehner’s. And his viability as a speaker nominee became even more tenuous last week after he implied that a special investigation into the 2012 attacks in Libya is politically motivated.

“Everybody thought Hilllary Clinton was unbeatable, right? But we put together a Benghazi special committee, a select committee. What are her numbers today? Her numbers are dropping. Why? Because she’s untrustable. But no one would have known any of that had happened had we not fought and made that happen,” Mr. McCarthy told Fox News.

The comments drew blowback from both sides of the aisle, including from Mr. Chaffetz, who told MSNBC that it was a “terrible mistake” for Mr. McCarthy to characterize the investigation that way. “He was wrong,” said Mr. Chaffetz, who went on to say he would do a better job representing the caucus’s message in the media.

“We need a speaker who speaks and actually articulates our message,” said Mr. Chaffetz.

Advertise with us

Political scientists say Mr. McCarthy created a problem for himself at a time when he can least afford it.

“Lives were lost in Benghazi, and this is one of the longest running investigations in Congressional history. This is a serious thing that he’s made into a political thing,” said David O’Connell, assistant professor of political science at Dickinson College in Carlisle, Pa.

“McCarthy has really wounded himself, and people will look at him and see those liabilities,” he said.

The delay in the vote could give Mr. McCarthy enough time to shore up support after his Benghazi gaffe, but even if he survives the conference vote he could face trouble on the floor. He needs 127 votes from the 246 Republicans in the conference, but on the floor he needs 218. The same conservatives who pushed Mr. Boehner out could stand in Mr. McCarthy’s way.

“A lot of people think he’s already too closely aligned with Boehner,” Mr. O’Connell said.

Advertise with us

In a statement signed by 11 of its 13 members, the Pennsylvania Republican delegation said it will support Mr. McCarthy.

“There is no more important time for our nation’s future than the present, and it is vital that House Republicans come together to make Washington work again. The Pennsylvania delegation believes that Kevin McCarthy is the right person to lead our conference and the House,” reads the statement issued last week.

Mr. Rothfus and Mr. Perry did not sign, saying they wanted more time to evaluate the candidates, receive feedback from constituents and make a thoughtful decision.

It could several ballots to choose a nominee, but Republicans won’t want the process to be too drawn out.

“They realize that if they don’t settle on a speaker it’s just going to further tear apart the Republican party and that would just help Democrats retain the White House, so I think they will fairly quickly rally around one candidate or another,” said political scientist Dennis Plane of Juniata College in Huntingdon, Pa. “I don’t think they want to come out looking like the party that can’t get things accomplished.”

Advertise with us

Even after the fractured caucus settles on a nominee it’s unlikely all Republican members will coalesce around their candidate on the House floor during the Oct. 29 vote.

“I expect there will be some defections. The question will be how many,” Mr. Plane said. “If Kevin McCarthy wins but with even more defections than Boehner [who had 25 during his 2014 re-election] then watch out: We’re in for a rocky ride.”

CORRECTION, posted Jan. 24, 2019: A previous version of this story misstated Nancy Pelosi as majority leader.

Washington Bureau Chief Tracie Mauriello: tmauriello@post-gazette.com; 703-996-9292 or on Twitter @pgPoliTweets.