WASHINGTON -- The National Security Agency has pushed repeatedly over the past year to expand its role in protecting private-sector computer networks from cyberattacks but has been rebuffed by the White House, largely because of privacy concerns, according to administration officials and internal documents.

The most contentious issue was a legislative proposal last year to require hundreds of companies that provide critical services such as electricity generation to allow their Internet traffic to be continuously scanned, using computer threat data provided by the spy agency. The companies would have been expected to turn over evidence of potential cyberattacks to the government.

NSA officials portrayed these measures as unobtrusive ways to protect the nation's vital infrastructure from what they say are increasingly dire threats of devastating cyberattacks.

But the White House and Justice Department argued that the proposal would permit unprecedented government monitoring of routine civilian Internet activity, according to documents and officials familiar with the debate. They spoke on condition of anonymity to describe administration deliberations; internal documents reviewed by The Washington Post backed these descriptions.

Advertise with us

White House officials cautioned the NSA that President Barack Obama has opposed cybersecurity measures that weakened personal privacy protections. They also warned the spy agency chief, Gen. Keith Alexander, to restrain his public comments after speeches in which he argued that more expansive legal authority was necessary to defend the nation against cyberattacks, according to several officials.

The debate, which is surfacing as Congress considers landmark cyber legislation, turns on what means are necessary and appropriate to protect vital private-sector systems from attack by China, Russia or other potential adversaries. Even some criminal gangs and hackers, such as the self-styled activist group Anonymous, increasingly may acquire the tools to mount major assaults on the nation's computer systems, U.S. officials say.

NSA officials acknowledged that they have warned about such threats but say they have not sought to establish policy. "As a major source of the nation's technical expertise on cyber and cybersecurity, we have a responsibility to ensure our leaders are informed and aware of what is happening in the cyber realm," agency spokeswoman Judith Emmel said. "We also work diligently to team with other agencies, industry and academia to find solutions to protecting our nation's critical infrastructure."

The proposal was intended to supplement an administration legislative package, unveiled last May, which NSA officials felt did not go far enough in protecting critical industries such as nuclear power, administration officials said. The proposal was offered by the Defense Department, which includes the NSA, and the Homeland Security Department.

The proposal drew on a Pentagon pilot program launched last year in which Internet service providers used NSA's threat data library to scan e-mails and other computer traffic to and from the nation's top defense contractors.

Advertise with us

The agency saw that program as a model to expand its role to protect other significant cyberattack targets. The proposed legislation would have made participation in mandatory for designated industries that didn't reach certain security benchmarks after a year, officials said.

The reason, NSA officials said in internal administration discussions, is that the private firms have not shown they are capable of defeating the rapidly evolving universe of cyberthreats.

"In order to stop it, you have to see it in real time, and you have to have those authorities," Gen. Alexander, also the U.S. military Cyber Command chief, said last month at New York's Fordham University. "Those are the conditions that we have put on the table. Now, how and what the administration and Congress choose, that will be a policy issue."

The NSA proposal, called Tranche 2, sparked fierce debate within the administration. It would have required an estimated 300 to 500 firms with a role in critical infrastructure systems to let their Internet carrier or some other private company scan their computer networks for malicious software, using government threat data. The Homeland Security Department would have designated participating companies.

NSA officials say this process would have been automated, preventing intrusion into the personal privacy of ordinary users. Only when scanning identified a potential threat would analysts be involved, to assess what the software identified and use it to craft better tools to stop such threats, the agency said.

Advertise with us

But the White House and other agencies, including the departments of Justice and Commerce, said the proposal left open the possibility that the large Internet carriers themselves could be designated critical entities. This, they said, could have allowed scanning of virtually all Internet traffic for cyberthreats on behalf of the government, opening a newly extensive window into American behavior online.

At a White House meeting last August, Tranche 2 was killed, said officials with knowledge of the debate. In January, NSA officials expressed concern when the White House blocked draft legislation by a Senate Intelligence Committee staffer enabling any government agency to monitor private computer networks for cyberthreats and take measures to counter those threats, according to administration officials and documents that include draft legislation and internal communications discussing it.

A revised version, part of the cyber legislation introduced in Congress this month, allowed only private-sector entities to monitor networks and operate the countermeasures.