Verizon Wireless has joined other cell phone carriers recently in requiring $9.99 data plans for mobile devices that work fine without them, saying it saves users from hitting the wrong button and racking up accidental Web charges.
But the $9.99 solution has been hit with a multimillion-dollar problem: Verizon Wireless announced Sunday that it will reimburse fees of $2 to $6 to the 15 million customers who did hit the wrong button and inadvertently surfed the Web.
Customers may find the relief short-lived as telecommunications firms are increasingly moving toward packaging phones with online data plans -- and the monthly fees that come with them.
Once just the $30 per month bane of savvy smart phone users, data plans have become cheaper, more prevalent and more mandated as cell phone carriers struggle to fund networks that keep up with an insatiable demand for better coverage and faster speeds.
Verizon had been under scrutiny by the Federal Communications Commission for the inadvertent charges, which affect customers who did not have Web access built into their contract. The charge of $1.99 per megabyte occurs when a customer hits a button -- often by mistake -- that connects the mobile device to the Web.
The data charges will be credited on October or November phone bills or mailed to customers who have since left the company. Analysts say the total charges could cost Verizon up to $90 million.
The FCC said Monday it still planned to look into the charges, which have been part of an agency investigation for the past 10 months. "For millions of Americans it's a day late and a $1.99 short," said Michele Ellison, chief of the FCC enforcement bureau.
Before the announcement, Verizon Wireless and other cell phone carriers had introduced new -- and, in some cases, required -- data plans that protect against surprise charges by charging customers up front.
"You want to make sure that you are covered with a plan -- or you could end up getting sticker shock," said Verizon spokeswoman Laura Merritt. "By getting a plan with a device, you're avoiding the per-megabyte charge" of $1.99.
The nation's other major carrier, AT&T, declined comment on the case.
The introduction of lower-cost data plans of about $10 per month have most affected customers who see themselves somewhere between a Puritan and a tech guru, said Steven McKay, manager of the Wireless Zone in Ross.
In between the basic cell phone models and the souped-up smart phones are middle-of-the-road devices that boast a nice but not too nice camera, touchscreen display and flat keyboard, he said. And a required data plan.
In protecting their customers from surprise charges, the companies also may be protecting themselves.
As data-hungry cell phones continue to boom in popularity, cell phone carriers need new sources of revenue to fund bigger and stronger networks to handle the load, said Rob Frieden, a Penn State University professor of telecommunications who once mistakenly accessed the Internet while texting in the dark.
There's an obvious tension with mandating data plans in order to fund a stronger network: Once the network is built, there will be more customers there to slow it down.
"The next generation is the promised land of much faster speeds," he said. To deter a select few from slowing the whole network down, carriers have begun moving toward a metered model that shuns a flat data rate and instead charges based on how much data an individual uses in a month.
"A heavy user could easily start paying $75 to $100 per month," he said.
As for the millions of dollars that Verizon Wireless owes, Dr. Frieden said not to worry about the nation's largest carrier.
"It'll be an ever-so-slight dent" on revenue, he said. "But the figure does include fairly significant lawyer fees."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.