Three new polls converge in finding a Democratic Senate race too close to call, but one with recent momentum having favored the challenger.

Sen. Arlen Specter was ahead in a Quinnipiac University survey; his rival, Rep. Joe Sestak, had a narrow lead in Franklin and Marshall College's poll, but the difference, in both cases, was within the polls' margins of error. In the latest tracking poll from Muhlenberg College, the Democrats were tied. While their methodologies and sample sizes varied, in all three Mr. Sestak had erased the substantial polling lead the incumbent had enjoyed until the final weeks of their primary battle.

The three surveys, all released Wednesday, also had a rough consensus on the Democratic race for governor, with Allegheny County Executive Dan Onorato holding a substantial lead over three closely bunched rivals, although the contest's undecided vote remained high.

The new Franklin and Marshall and Quinnipiac surveys also suggested that the top of the Republican ballot would generate little suspense next Tuesday. Rep. Pat Toomey held big leads over Johnstown activist Peg Luksik in the GOP Senate race, and Attorney General Tom Corbett remained well ahead of his gubernatorial rival, Rep. Sam Rohrer.

Advertise with us

Mr. Specter, the five-term incumbent, led Mr. Sestak 44 percent to 42 percent in the Quinnipiac survey; just over a month ago, his margin was 53 percent to 32 percent. The Franklin & Marshall poll found another too-close-to-call margin of 38 percent to 36 percent among those most likely to vote. Among all registered Democrats in the F&M survey, however, Mr. Specter led 38 percent to 29 percent. But even with that group, Mr. Sestak's support had jumped up since the last F&M poll, in March, when the incumbent led 32 percent to 12 percent. In the latest installment of the Muhlenberg tracking poll, the Democrats were tied at 45 percent.

The findings come after the Sestak campaign began airing a commercial using Mr. Specter's own words to raise questions about his year-old switch from Republican to Democrat. In recent weeks, Mr. Sestak has been the target of a series of Specter attacks on his voting record, and the circumstances surrounding his departure from the Navy. The polls, however, found little apparent damage from those salvoes.

Appearing in Pittsburgh Tuesday night, Mr. Specter said the narrowing in the polls was understandable given his opponent's recent heavy advertising. He predicted that a "dynamite television ad" showcasing his support from President Barack Obama and a barrage of robo-calls recorded for him by the president would counter Mr. Sestak's surge. The president appeared at a fundraiser for Mr. Specter last September, but will not be doing any campaigning for him in the campaign's closing stretch.

Mr. Specter and supporters such as Gov. Ed Rendell and T.J. Rooney, the state Democratic chairman, have argued that Mr. Specter would be a stronger general election candidate against Mr. Toomey, the likely GOP nominee. The Franklin & Marshall results don't support that contention. While Mr. Toomey ran ahead of both in March, the latest survey showed virtual dead heats against either one.

In the Democratic race for governor, Mr. Onorato had big leads in all three surveys, although persistently high proportions of undecided voters accompanied his advantage. In the Quinnipiac survey, Mr. Onorato had 38 percent, followed by Auditor General Jack Wagner, 11 percent, state Sen. Anthony Williams, 10 percent, and Montgomery County Commissioner Joe Hoeffel, 10 percent. Mr. Williams is the only rival who has approached the level of television advertising fielded by the Onorato campaign, but his numbers showed relatively little movement compared to another Quinnipiac survey in the first week of May, and seven of 10 Democrats still said they didn't know enough about him to express either a favorable or an unfavorable opinion of him.

Advertise with us

In the F&M sample, Mr. Onorato led with 27 percent, with his competitors in a virtual tie for second: Mr. Wagner, 5 percent, Mr. Williams, 5 percent, and Mr. Hoeffel, 4 percent. A whopping 57 percent of the Democrats remained undecided in the poll.

On the Republican side, Mr. Corbett had 23 percent, Mr. Rohrer, 5 percent, and the overwhelming balance of GOP voters were undecided. In the Quinnipiac survey, Mr. Corbett led Mr. Rohrer, 57 percent to 14 percent, with 28 percent undecided.

The Democratic side of the Quinnipiac survey included interviews with 945 Democrats, with a margin of error of plus or minus 3.2 percentage points. For the GOP sample of 995, the margin of error was 3.1 percent. The Quinnipiac researchers draw their polling sample from lists of registered voters, focusing on people who have voted in recent elections.

The F&M poll bases its interviews on random digit dialing for phone exchanges across the state. It included 891 registered voters, 404 Democrats, 321 Republicans and 117 independents. The margin of error for Democrats in that survey was 4.9 percent; for Republicans, 5.5 percent. For the smaller group of Democrats considered most likely to vote, the error margin is 7.9 percent.

The Muhlenberg survey included interviews with 401 Democrats considered likely to vote in the primary, with a margin of error of 5 percent. Like the Quinnipiac survey, its sample is drawn from a list of registered Democrats.