A liberal Pennsylvania advocacy group says the office of Attorney General Tom Corbett communicated with a consultant for the Republican State Leadership Committee before he decided to join a lawsuit challenging the landmark health care reform package signed into law in March.
Those communications, according to Keystone Progress, lend credence to the accusation that the lawsuit was politically motivated, even though Mr. Corbett, a Republican candidate for governor, and the 13 other Republican attorneys general who joined the lawsuit said that the suit was about policy, not politics.
The suit "seeks to protect the citizens of Pennsylvania whose rights will be violated when the health care reform legislation [is] signed into law by President Obama," Mr. Corbett said at the time.
On Thursday, a spokesman for Mr. Corbett's office, Kevin Harley, said "the reason the attorney general joined the lawsuit was that the [part of the law] that requires citizens to purchase health care is unconstitutional, and in violation of the commerce clause" of the Constitution.
Keystone Progress distributed a small batch of e-mails on Thursday -- communiques among attorney general staff members across the country, as well as Ben Cannatti, the former political director of the RSLC, which was a major contributor to Mr. Corbett's attorney general re-election campaign.
Also CC'd on those e-mails were two employees in Mr. Corbett's office, though none of those employees actually issued any e-mails of their own.
In the e-mails, Mr. Cannatti and others are corresponding back and forth about the impending lawsuit, how many states would be involved, and the deadline for signing the original complaint.
Mr. Cannatti, owner of Caleb Consulting, has been on retainer with the RSLC since 2005, "advising the committee on political and issue operations, press and message development [and] policy," his website says.
Mr. Corbett did not hide the fact that he was discussing legal strategies with attorneys general from other states, and the e-mails reflected that. But Keystone Progress says the communications with the RSLC, a national political fundraising group, show that the suit had demonstrable political origins.
The e-mails were initially distributed last week by a sister organization, One Wisconsin Now, part of the liberal Progress Now network. Those e-mails were obtained under Wisconsin's Right-To-Know laws; Keystone Progress hasn't had similar luck in trying to obtain health-care-reform-related e-mails from Mr. Corbett's office, according to Keystone's executive director, Michael Morrill.
"This is not privileged communication. This is strategizing about publicity," he said, and the e-mails should be made publicly available.
Pennsylvania Democrats, who said from day one that the lawsuit was politically motivated, say the new e-mails reinforce that.
"It's been pretty clear since he filed the lawsuit that this is [a political] effort in order to aid his own gubernatorial campaign," said Patrick McKenna, spokesman for the Pennsylvania Democratic Party. "If he wants to clear the air, he should release all correspondence related to this."
Mr. Harley, spokesman for the attorney general's office, said that "we followed Pennsylvania's law. Wisconsin has a different right-to-know law than we do."


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.