It was billed as "a kitchen table discussion" with U.S. Senate candidate Peg Luksik -- although it actually was in the clubhouse of Hytyre Farms, an upscale housing development in West Deer.

No matter: In this statewide campaign, her fourth since 1990, Ms. Luksik is running once again as a self-described housewife from Johnstown, the sensible, frugal, common-sense candidate who, she tells her audience, "has actually read the health care bill," and who is tapping into voter anger against Washington.

"You can ask me any question you want except how much I weigh," added the diminutive, white-haired woman clad in gray slacks, heels and a loose plaid blouse -- earning chuckles from a group of about 15 senior citizens (most of them men, most of them self-described conservatives).

She then proceeded with her basic stump speech, delivered at warp speed and littered with statistics, conservative theory and arcana about legislative severability clauses and the federal tax code.

Advertise with us

Still, if Ms. Luksik is still running as a housewife, it is most certainly the 3.0 version, given that the former teacher and mother of six also happens to have her own management consultant firm; use the Internet to conduct weekly "tele" town hall meetings (by phone, "with 50,000 close friends listening in," she says), raise funds and organize volunteers; and manage Johnstown Republican Bill Russell's congressional campaign to succeed the late John Murtha.

This time, Ms. Luksik is challenging Pat Toomey in next month's Republican primary, instead of running as a third-party candidate, as she did in two previous elections. That independent streak annoyed GOP party leaders in the past and may be one reason why she's been all but ignored by them this time -- even though she got in the Senate race first, back in January 2009.

That was when Arlen Specter was still a Republican -- but before he caught GOP flak for providing the crucial vote for the Democrat's stimulus package, and Mr. Toomey, who had ruled out a Specter challenge, suddenly changed his mind and got in too.

Certainly, the multitasking of Ms. Luksik's conservative message, honed over years of grass-roots campaigning, went over big with Wednesday night's group: anti-abortion, anti-government waste, anti-tax -- and pro-repeal of the recently passed health care law.

There's only one problem: Mr. Toomey is all of those things too, and he has way more money ($4 million so far, compared with her $605,000), more name recognition and the Republican Party's endorsement.

Advertise with us

A former congressman and former head of a Washington anti-spending group The Club for Growth, Mr. Toomey almost beat Mr. Specter in the 2004 Republican primary, and this year, pollsters have been mostly busy measuring his appeal against Mr. Specter's while all but ignoring Ms. Luksik. While a recent Franklin and Marshall College poll included her, last week's Quinnipiac Survey did not.

Still, Ms. Luksik soldiers on.

"I'm the Pennsylvania candidate," Ms. Luksik said. "There are three Washington insiders running for the Senate -- Arlen Specter, [U.S. Rep.] Joe Sestak, Pat Toomey -- and me. And the people are responding," she added, noting that she's received more than 25,000 individual donations averaging less than $25.

While Robert Gleason, chair of the state Republican Party, did not respond to requests for an interview about Ms. Luksik, Jerry Bowyer, a Pittsburgh-based conservative activist, insisted that the state party establishment "can't stand her."

"Peg Luksik doesn't play by the rules, and the Republican method has always been: You stand in line, you wait your turn, and she doesn't do that. So she isn't getting any of that Republican money that helps you win."

Advertise with us

While Ms. Luksik has made many appearances before angry voters at tea party rallies ("They're lovely people, plumbers, grandparents, who tell me, 'I'm so mad I have to be here' "), she acknowledged that potent but fragmented movement hadn't coalesced behind her candidacy. Because they don't have much of a structure, she argues, no one candidate is necessarily benefiting from their support.

Still, tea partiers are mostly mad about the economy, not social issues, and this is a woman who made her political name on the strength of her anti-abortion bona fides (she's against all abortion, no exceptions; Mr. Toomey, who now opposes abortion, ran as a pro-choice candidate in his first congressional campaign).

In the early 1980s, Ms. Luksik founded Mom's House, which provided day care and support for young women with unplanned pregnancies. She saw it as a practical alternative to abortion and a way to help them stay out of the welfare cycle as single parents. While her concept would serve as a national model, she parted company with the Pittsburgh branches of Mom's House a decade ago over a disagreement, she says, about taking government money. They later closed.

Abortion was a single issue that put her on the political map in 1990, when she shocked the political establishment by almost beating moderate abortion-rights advocate Barbara Hafer in the Republican gubernatorial primary. And while she's tried to broaden her campaign message over the years, abortion has always been central to her appeal. In 1994, Ms. Luksik ran as a third-party candidate under the Constitutional Party banner, earning 13 percent of the vote, and again in 1998, earning 10 percent of the vote.

This year, though, social issues like abortion are barely registering in surveys -- instead, 2010 is all about the struggling economy and health care, says G. Terry Madonna, director of the Center for Politics and Public Affairs at Franklin and Marshall College, where a mid-March poll had Ms. Luksik registering at about 4 percent, compared with Mr. Toomey's 30 percent.

Advertise with us

"Luksik has to find a way to get to the voters," Mr. Madonna said, noting that in spite of her previous campaigns, "she is not well-known -- and there really isn't that much difference between her and Toomey. To the extent that campaigns are about differences, this matters."

Her candidacy also has divided some anti-abortion activists, who fear Mr. Toomey will have to divert some of his resources to keep her at bay, when that money would be better spent in the general election against the Democratic nominee. LifePac of Southwestern Pennsylvania decided recently not to endorse either candidate, instead planning to hand out leaflets on primary day listing all anti-abortion candidates.

"We know her, we love her, and we've worked with her all these years. But we all wished and hoped that she would not run for that office at this time," said Helen Cindrich, executive director of People Concerned for the Unborn Child in Pittsburgh. "She has no chance of winning. Pat Toomey is a good candidate, and I have no idea what kind of support she has."

Still, there's much to admire about Ms. Luksik, who's warm where Mr. Toomey is cool, says Mr. Bowyer, recalling how Mr. Specter's most effective ads against Mr. Toomey in 2004 involved complaints about constituent service from voters in his district.

"Mr. Toomey is not a people person, he's a money person," Mr. Bowyer said. Peg, on the other hand, is a people person. Toomey knows who his donors are, she knows who her people are. And Pennsylvania is not a stepping stone for a bigger, better deal for her. If she won, I actually think she'd keep on living in Pennsylvania."

Advertise with us

Ms. Luksik says she works in "a different arena" than Mr. Toomey -- not by raising prodigious amounts of money or going on television, but by staying under the radar and working to get voters to the polls on Election Day.

In the political version of the "each one, teach one" tradition of spreading the Gospel, her campaign focuses on asking those who had turned out to see her to spread her message to a friend or neighbor, "whether it's at your adult Bible study group, your kid's school's new lunch room or anywhere else," she said at Wednesday night's meeting. There she was handing out 15 bright yellow folders, asking the attendees to fill out the forms inside with e-mail addresses and other contact information so she could send them her weekly column.

"This gives you the words to talk to your neighbors," she said.

"Oh, and I want the folders back, too," she added, in a laughing nod at her frugality.

Ms. Luksik will debate Mr. Toomey later this month, but it's not clear that even this statewide televised event on PCN -- the C-Span of Pennsylvania -- will be enough to make her the stealth Republican Senate candidate who surprises everyone on May 18.

Advertise with us

"I do campaign differently," she acknowledged. "I go under the radar, right to the people, and what I am hearing, over and over again is, 'respect us and take the time to know your stuff.' And I do. I read the bills, and I will stay as long as it takes to answer questions and explain what's in them. People say, 'Oh, you almost beat Barbara Hafer,' but it didn't just come out of nowhere. I spent a lot of time building the structure, and it took awhile for the polls to pick up on it.

"[GOP leaders] wish I'd go away, but I'm not going away. I'm Irish, and I'm more stubborn than anybody I've ever met."