NEW CASTLE -- As he pulled into the Lawrence County seat on a recent campaign, U.S. Sen. Arlen Specter recalled his first visit, some 40 years ago, to the town variously known as the Hot Dog Capital of America or the Fireworks Capital of the World.
"I was DA and I was interested in running for governor at the time. And the guy who picked me up at the airport was Frank Vitril.
"Frank was a Republican commissioner. He later became a Democratic commissioner," Mr. Specter noted, without any apparent allusion to his own, similar political conversion.
The ostensible point of the story was what a colorful guy Mr. Vitril was, with his collection of antique cars and his foul, funny stories. But the underlying message was how deeply Mr. Specter is steeped in the grass roots of the state he has represented for a record five terms, and the dividends of those years of experience, for him, and, he would argue, for his constituents.
"There's a 67 Club, as you know," he said of the growing list of politicians who boast of having visited all of Pennsylvania's 67 counties. "But I'm a founding member of the 67 Club, and that has really stood me in good stead."
The upside of that familiarity was on display the day before, as he reminded a crowd of steelworkers in West Mifflin about his record of work pressing their industry's cause in cases before the International Trade Commission. Later that morning, he walked into former Pittsburgh Pirates manager Chuck Tanner's restaurant in New Castle, already familiar with some of the Democratic Party and union officials gathered for a breakfast hosted by his campaign.
But that much history imposes a price, too -- thousands of votes and statements and positions, now being dissected by opponents in his new and old parties. In his first elections as a Democrat after more than a dozen as a Republican, the criticism starts with his party switch itself. A long public career will almost inevitably include shifts and inconsistencies. Ask him about some of them, and Mr. Specter can almost always come up with a lawyerly, well-reasoned explanation.
A health care public option? He declared his opposition when he was a Republican. But, he explains, that was when the proposal appeared to be an overreaching government program reminiscent of the Clinton health care initiative he helped defeat in the 1990s. He switched to adamant support for "a robust public option," he says, not because he changed parties, but because Sen. Charles Schumer, D-N.Y., crafted a more moderate version that would have paid its own way on a level playing field with private insurance plans.
The Employee Free Choice Act? Mr. Specter voted against cloture on the measure in the last Congress not because he supported the bill in its entirety but because he wanted to advance the debate on it, he said. When, in what some labor allies saw as a betrayal, he declared his opposition to the measure last year, during his final weeks as a Republican, he issued a detailed statement qualifying his opposition. His support for a compromise, he contends, was presaged by that statement and shouldn't be regarded as a switch.
While Mr. Specter argues that such shifts are more apparent than real, the perception they create fits the pattern of a career in which he has taken turns attracting the praise, and the enmity, of liberals and conservatives.
The milestones are familiar. Conservatives still bristle at his opposition to Supreme Court nominee Robert Bork. Feminists chafe at the memory of his cross-examination of law professor Anita Hill during Justice Clarence Thomas' confirmation hearings. The opponents of abortion rights at the core of his former party's base were chronically irate at his persistent challenge to Republican orthodoxy, underscored during a short-lived presidential campaign in 1995.
"You had the Moral Majority trying to dominate the scene at the time, and I recall being one of nine people speaking in New Hampshire and I was the only one pro-choice," he said.
The embrace of then-President George W. Bush and his Senate colleague Rick Santorum allowed him to survive a GOP Senate challenge from current Senate candidate Pat Toomey in 2004. Within days of his general-election victory, his prized chairman's gavel on the Senate Judiciary Committee was in jeopardy as conservatives reacted to his declaration of independence in considering Bush administration judicial nominees.
Last year, he was adamant that he would not abandon the Republican Party, until poll results convinced him that he could not win a Republican primary.
But at the same time he was playing those roles in national ideological dramas, he never stopped working on the more mundane planes of constituent service and home state projects, investments of time and energy he is counting on to carry him through one more political challenge.
His record tenure for a Pennsylvania senator is also a reminder of his age, 80, which means that if he wins the primary and general, he would be 86 at the end of the next term.
"I have adopted Satchel Paige's view," he volunteers. "If you didn't know your age, how old you were, how old would you think you were? And I choose 37.
"I play squash with men half my age, I visit virtually ever county virtually every year," he said last week. "I went through a couple of bouts with Hodgkin's, didn't miss a vote, presided over the hearings for Chief Justice [John] Roberts and Justice [Samuel] Alito, lost all my hair. You know my story. I kept getting letters about my hair style more than my public policy."
Mr. Specter's energy and work habits are legendary. Still, age affects different people in different and unpredictable ways. To a reporter's question on how he might monitor his own performance in a new term, Mr. Specter expressed confidence in his continuing vitality and said, "I think I'm fit to serve. ... I'm in a highly visible position. People will know if I'm not up to the job."
He cited Penn State football coach Joe Paterno and Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens as example of other figures who continue to perform at a high level at ages when most colleagues have retired.
"He's 90 this month," the senator said of Justice Stevens. "I wrote him a letter, urged him not to [retire] on the ground that if he retires, there's likely to be a filibuster.".
Mr. Specter's had two rounds of cancer treatment, and gone through two successful operations for brain tumors. He received his last chemotherapy for a recurrence of Hodgkin's disease in July 2008. Since then, he said, his checkups have given him clean bills of health.
"I'll tell you a story which is right on your point," he said while responding to questions about his health. Mr. Specter described his friendship with the late Massachusetts Sen. Paul Tsongas and the Democrat's decision not to seek another Senate term in 1984 after being diagnosed with cancer.
"He decided not to run in '84 because he wasn't certain he could serve a full term, and I went to see him and I said, 'Paul, don't be foolish. You don't owe anybody six years, what you owe them is an honest representation as to your health.'
"He didn't run, and he not only lived out the six years, in '92 he ran for president."
Of questions about his health and age, Mr. Specter said, "I'm not sensitive to it. I think the experience is a great asset."
To illustrate, he described how his years of involvement with funding for the National Institutes of Health had led him to champion a provision in the health reform law that is designed to speed the practical implementation of advances in medical research.
"Now that's something I could do because of my experience," he said. "Do you think [Democratic Rep. Joe] Sestak or Toomey would ever have those insights? Do you think Sestak or Toomey could pick up the China trade issue? ... How many times has Sestak visited the locks and dams? What does he know about the inland waterway system?
Turning to foreign policy, he said of his Democratic rival, "What does he know about Syria? I've been to Syria 18 times."
Attesting to his foreign policy credentials, he points to a rogue's gallery of recent history.
"Dealing with the despots of the world -- you know the guys I personally met with along this line? Saddam Hussein, Moammar Gadhafi, Fidel Castro, Yasser Arafat, Hafez al-Assad, Hugo Chavez. So when I talk about negotiations and how to deal with the tyrants of the world -- you don't pick that up before you're 50."
Another dividend of Senate decades is seniority in the pecking order of committee slots. But Mr. Specter's years of climbing were at least temporarily toppled by his decision to cross the Senate aisle. When he announced the move, he said that Sen. Harry Reid, the chamber's Democratic leader, had agreed to honor his seniority as though he had been first elected a Democrat. That didn't happen. Democratic colleagues have allowed him to move up several spots on the Judiciary Committee he once chaired. But his ranking on the powerful Appropriations panel, the front for special funding for state projects, remains unresolved.
"That was the deal I made and he couldn't back it up," he said of Mr. Reid. "I thought the caucus would follow his commitment. There were a number of people who objected. I decided not to make an issue of it at the time, but to establish myself in the caucus, to establish myself as a Democrat. When the time is right, I'm going to take it to the [Democratic] caucus. Reid talks about taking it to the caucus after the election, Well, maybe so, and maybe sooner."
In the meantime, Mr. Specter continues to ride the 67 Club circuit. His years on that track he said, have "built up personal contacts with so many people."
"When I became a Democrat, I'd go into a room with Democratic commissioners. I knew them all."



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.