A new poll projects a mixed message on Sen. Arlen Specter's re-election prospects.

For the first time in months, the veteran incumbent moved to a lead over a potential November challenger, Republican Pat Toomey, in a new survey by Quinnipiac University. But at the same time, the proportion of Pennsylvania voters who said that the senator does not deserve to be re-elected remains dauntingly high.

In the survey of 1,452 Pennsylvania voters, Mr. Specter, now a Democrat, had 49 percent to Mr. Toomey's 42 percent. The former Republican congressman just missed wresting the GOP nomination from Mr. Specter in the 2004 primary. Mr. Specter had a significant lead over Mr. Toomey in the months immediately following his switch to the Democratic Party last April. But in three subsequent Quinnipiac polls, in July, October and November, the two candidates had been locked in a virtual tie.

Mr. Specter's overall plurality rests on big leads among the voters of his new party and among women. Democrats favored his re-election, 82 percent to 11 percent. Republicans, in roughly the same proportions, were in the Toomey column, while a small plurality of independents -- 45 percent to 42 percent, also favored Mr. Toomey. A majority of women supported Mr. Specter -- 52 percent to 36 percent -- while men were more closely divided in favor of the Republican -- 49 percent to 46 percent.

Advertise with us

All of that amounted to some of the most positive public polling results for the senator in months. But at the same time, a persistent majority of the state's voters said he does not deserve to be re-elected. Fifty-two percent said he does not deserve another term; only 38 percent said he does. Mirroring the trial heat findings, big majorities of both Republicans and independents said Mr. Specter did not merit another term. But by a margin of more that 2 to 1, 60 percent to 27 percent, Democratic voters said Mr. Specter deserved re-election, a finding consistent with his continuing advantage over his Democratic challenger, Rep. Joe Sestak, D-Delaware County, who trailed by 53 percent to 29 percent in a primary matchup.

Mr. Specter has traditionally courted labor unions. In his last general election, while still a Republican, he received the endorsement of the state AFL-CIO over a Democratic opponent. His candidacy now appears to be a tougher sell with rank-and-file union members, as 46 percent of voters from union households said he did not deserve another term compared to the 42 percent in favor.

The survey did not test the strength of another Republican Senate candidate, Peg Luksik, a conservative activist form Johnstown.

A year and a half after President Barack Obama carried Pennsylvania by a wide margin, the Democrat's job approval rating in the state was 49 percent positive and 46 percent negative. That's a big drop from last year at this time, but little changed from two previous Quinnipiac surveys over the past six months.

The survey was conducted from Feb. 22 to Feb. 28 and had an overall margin of error of 2.6 percent. For the total Democratic subsample, the margin of error was 3.9 percent.