WASHINGTON -- PMA Group lobbyists thought they were getting a sweetheart deal from Rep. John P. Murtha and other members of his defense appropriations subcommittee in exchange for campaign contributions.
But Mr. Murtha told investigators he had so little knowledge of his fundraising apparatus that he often didn't recognize donors at events, and staff with no knowledge of contributions selected his earmarks -- with the paramount goal to create jobs in his home district.
The U.S. House Ethics Committee found Friday that neither Mr. Murtha nor his colleagues did anything improper, clearing all members involved in a probe that began in June. The members did not consider campaign contributions a factor when requesting earmarks, nor did they solicit contributions in return for earmarks, the committee said in a 305-page report.
The ethics panel, in Mr. Murtha's case, relied primarily on an investigation and recommendation by the Office of Congressional Ethics, an outside body of former members of Congress that recommended no sanctions against Mr. Murtha in November.
The finding provided a measure of postmortem vindication for Mr. Murtha, a Johnstown Democrat, who had vigorously denied wrongdoing since the FBI and Congress began investigating his ties to PMA, which was run by Pittsburgh native Paul Magliocchetti. Mr. Murtha died Feb. 8 of complications related to gall bladder surgery.
Mr. Murtha's district director, Mark Critz, who is running for his former boss' seat in the May 18 special election, was among those interviewed during the investigation, according to the ethics committee's report, though he's not a central figure.
Reps. Norm Dicks, D-Wash., Marcy Kaptur, D-Ohio, James Moran, D-Va., Todd Tihart, R-Kan., Peter Visclosky, D-Ind., and Bill Young, R-Fla., were the other lawmakers targeted in the now-closed investigation. All served on the defense subcommittee, responsible for the flow of billions of dollars for contracts across the country.
PMA closed last year after federal agents searched its offices and Mr. Magliocchetti's home, seeking evidence that he used friends and family to steer donations to members of Congress in violation of campaign finance laws.
During the 2008 and 2010 election cycles, Mr. Murtha took in about $390,000 in contributions from PMA and its clients, according to the ethics report. Mr. Murtha, who had a full-time campaign coordinator, told investigators he never made a personal call for a contribution and fundraising was handled entirely by campaign staff.
"Representative Murtha told the [Office of Congressional Ethics] that he knew some companies thought that contributing to his campaign might increase the likelihood of receiving an earmark, but the reality is that he often did not even recognize the individuals who attend his fundraisers," the report said.
Mr. Murtha told investigators that the earmark process is entirely staff driven and he would merely sign off on a list of 25-30 requests handed to him by staff members who had no knowledge of campaign contributions.
As for Mr. Magliocchetti, Mr. Murtha told investigators that he was "as good as you can find" for a lobbyist. He knew how important economic development in the district was to Mr. Murtha and proposed projects accordingly.
The report also disclosed that after the FBI raids on PMA and Mr. Magliocchetti's home became public last year, staff on the subcommittee and appropriations chairman Rep. David Obey, D-Wis., wanted all PMA-related earmarks taken out of the appropriations bill -- but Mr. Murtha refused.
The committee found "troubling aspects to PMA's conduct." The group threatened to withdraw financial support or encourage companies to pull out of a member's district unless the member reversed policies opposing earmarks, the report said, adding that members in these cases refused to change their positions. The report makes no mention of such an instance with Mr. Murtha.
The committee, composed of 10 House members, has often been criticized for being too lenient toward colleagues.
"Apparently, in the committee's view, no member of Congress ever earmarks as a result of a campaign contribution," Melanie Sloan, executive director of Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, said in a statement.
"Of course, the committee also determined that PMA Group lobbyists and their clients universally believed that the chances of obtaining an earmark were directly related to the amount of campaign contributions they made to members of Congress. But, hey, why let a little inconsistency like that get in the way of clearing members of wrongdoing -- the raison d'etre of the committee."



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.