Kayla Calabro feels that rushing back to work after giving birth to her second daughter is one reason she has bonded differently with her. She quit her job to care for her firstborn.
During her second pregnancy, in 2023, the then-28-year-old Bridgeville resident developed preeclampsia, a dangerous condition affecting 5% to 8% of all pregnancies in the U.S. that puts a woman at risk of seizures and organ failure and is a major cause of maternal death, per the World Health Organization. Calabro had gone to the emergency room five times during her term. Her legs were swollen, and she’d gained 70 pounds.
“I could barely breathe, barely walk,” she said. “I was a swollen whale of my prior self.”
A week after giving birth, she took her blood pressure at home, which signaled an emergency: 184 systolic over 125 diastolic pressure, a stroke-level reading. Calabro was rehospitalized — and separated from her newborn — for one week.
Unable to afford additional time off, she returned to work about a month later. She would have welcomed more time with her baby, she said, and to recover from her complicated pregnancy.
She is one of dozens of moms who spoke to Allegheny County lawmakers over the last month regarding a new proposal on paid leave for new parents, with many sharing similar stories about returning to work earlier than they would have liked.
Read More
If passed by County Council, the proposal would mandate 18 weeks — or 4½ months — of fully paid leave for working parents of newborns and new adoptions. The proposal, as it stands, puts the financial onus of covering such leave on Allegheny County businesses, regardless of number of employees.
“Eighteen weeks [of paid leave] would have been lifechanging,” Calabro said. “All I wanted to do was spend time with her. It was really upsetting, and it did really affect my mental health.”
While many employees qualify for leave through the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), those 12 weeks are unpaid. The state has worked on its own paid leave act, but County Executive Sara Innamorato said she didn’t want to wait for the wheels of bureaucracy to churn before Allegheny County families benefited from paid time off with their newborns. The county proposal was announced in May.
Earlier this month, a family medical leave act made its way to a Senate committee. Led by Senate Republican Devlin Robinson of Allegheny County, with a panel of Democratic cosponsors, the bill seeks to establish a statewide paid family medical leave insurance program through the Department of Labor & Industry that employees pay into. The pool also would apply to workers who are injured or taking care of an injured family member.
“As the Pennsylvania workforce changes, work policies must also evolve to serve a growing and diverse population,” reads the bill memo. “Employers should not have to choose between the health of their business and loyalty to their employees. And no employee should have to choose between taking care of a sick child or an aging parent or a job. In Pennsylvania, families should come first.”
Speakers at Allegheny County Board of Health meetings, public comment hearings and County Council committee meetings in recent weeks have pointed to the U.S. being one of the only countries in the world that does not offer some form of paid leave for new parents and to evidence that paid parental leave decreases infant mortality rates and increases breastfeeding and parent well-being.
Public commenting ends July 16 for Allegheny County’s proposal, which is likely to see widespread changes after the community responded in droves with thoughts on many of the details. The Board of Health will meet to discuss the proposal again on Sept. 16. If passed, it would be the only such county-level bill in the state.
A sticking point of the proposal articulated by many business owners has to do with taking on the cost of such a policy — not the concept of families needing time with newborns or new adoptees.
Studies that show the practice of paid leave can improve employee retention and give workers a sense of being valued by their employers. One 2011 report by the Center for Economic and Policy Research, for instance, found that after paid family leave was instated in California, a vast majority of employers reported either positive or neutral outcomes. Businesses with fewer than 100 employees, too, were less likely to report negative outcomes, and 91% of businesses surveyed said they did not believe employees were abusing the program to take time off without valid cause.
At an Allegheny County Council health committee meeting on June 24, Meghan Benedict sat before five committee members in a tiny room in the courthouse to share her own story with preeclampsia, and the different bonds forged with her two children due to circumstances around her pregnancies.
When Benedict, a 46-year-old Pittsburgh native, became pregnant in 2007 at the age of 27, she was working at a temp agency without benefits or insurance. She developed preeclampsia at seven months and was put on bed rest for the duration of her term. Benedict and her husband moved back in with her parents, and they relied on her husband’s income of $11.75 an hour.
After a difficult birth and a bout of postpartum depression, Benedict returned to work after six weeks, while her mother watched her child.
That was much too soon, she told the council.
“No parent should experience what I went through with my daughter, the emotional toll of leaving her behind to work, the danger of returning to work earlier than I should, and the pressure of knowing you wouldn’t be able to provide for your family if you didn’t,” she said.
Benedict’s second pregnancy was “the polar opposite” experience, she said. She had no complications and was able to take nine weeks off, and feels that her bond is stronger with her son because of it.
Without familial support the first time around, Benedict said couldn’t have returned to work at all.
“I don’t know what I would have done. I would have been homeless if I didn't have family,” she said.
Calabro also relied on family to watch her baby when she returned to work. Daycare was too expensive for her and her husband, and Calabro can’t drive because she has narcolepsy. She’s part of a Pittsburgh organization called Brown Mamas that connects moms with pregnancy- and family-related resources, and said she’s seen members of that group struggle without familial or social support.
“I’m very grateful to have had the support of mom, my extended family, my sister and good friends,” she said. “But there are some people who don't have anyone at all. I couldn’t imagine having to go back to work if I did not have the help I have.”
About 1 in 8 Allegheny County residents, or 12.5%, live in poverty, according to 2024 Census data, higher than the federal poverty rate of 10.6%.
The paid leave proposal is an attempt to strengthen maternal health and infant health outcomes for the county’s residents and cut down on costs over time, said Allegheny County Health Department director Iulia Vann — but hundreds of comments have poured in since its introduction that oppose its costs and call it burdensome.
Benedict said she understands why many small businesses have opposed the proposal as written and that it’s unsustainable for them: “I think that [the cost] being put all on the business is people’s hesitation to fully embrace it,” she said.
She likes more of a three-pronged approach, where funding for paid leave comes from the government, employees and businesses so as to not exhaust one pool.
County Council health committee members present on June 24, when Benedict spoke, were interested in the proposal writ large but seemed poised to strike it down as it stands. Major edits by the Allegheny County Health Department are likely.
Michelle Naccarati-Chapkis, Allegheny County Council president, told the Post-Gazette on Tuesday that the council had recently met with the county health department and Innamorato, who gave a presentation about the proposal to help council members understand its details.
"Nobody argues that there’s not a public health benefit with paid parental leave," Naccarati-Chapkis said. "We certainly all see value and benefit with a family perspective. We’ve asked them to share more insights into the economic perspective."
Naccarati-Chapkis added that all comments that have been sent to county council have been shepherded to the health department "to ensure nothing gets overlooked." She anticipates a vote on the final proposal in late fall.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.