With the spread of dangerous childhood diseases rising across Pennsylvania, top lawmakers say they want to rein in the legal exemptions that have allowed students to avoid school vaccines and placed hundreds of classrooms at risk.
The legislators say they want parents to seek the guidance of a healthcare provider before getting the waivers, saying families should be informed about the risks before allowing their children to skip the vaccines.
Prompted by the recent surge of measles in Pennsylvania — the largest outbreak in more than three decades — a group of Democratic lawmakers say they want to counter what they called the vast amount of misinformation about the safety of immunization that has bombarded the state for years.
“It’s outrageous,” said Rep. Dan Frankel, D-Squirrel Hill, who will be joined by four colleagues this fall to push legislation that seeks to amend a law that’s been in place for generations.
By directing parents to take such a step, people could “at least get accurate information from their healthcare professionals about the risks,” he said.

The longtime legislator said he expects strong opposition from some lawmakers, but “we’re not looking to punish anyone. Exemptions will always be a part of what Pennsylvania allows.”
Read More
He said the recent outbreak in Lancaster and Lebanon counties that has sickened at least 55 people — including three hospitalizations — should be “a wake-up call” that shows the state is vulnerable to threats that children have not faced in years.
The creation of the plan comes after a Post-Gazette investigation found the number of parents seeking exemptions has nearly doubled over the past six years — a trend that's driving down the threshold of protection in schools needed to stem the spread of diseases, experts say.
In a memo to House members on Wednesday, Frankel cited the Post-Gazette’s reporting, which showed school immunization rates have fallen for the past six years.
The reporters also found that Pennsylvania is among the easiest states in the nation to get an exemption.
With a lone signature, the shots are waived by the state.
At least nine other states, including Michigan and Mississippi, call for more robust requirements, including taking an online seminar on vaccine safety, watching a health video about the risks, or visiting their doctors to get briefed before making the decision.
The current effort to change the law in Pennsylvania marks the second time that legislators have tried to create the parental requirement — a move that drew resistance from other lawmakers and groups opposed to the shots.
During the throes of the COVID-19 pandemic, Democratic lawmakers pushed for the provision in 2021, arguing that reams of misinformation about vaccine safety were flooding social media.
The bill died before a vote.
Russ Diamond, a Republican House member from Lebanon County, said efforts by fellow lawmakers to impose more requirements for exemptions amounts to an overreach that would be met with resistance by several groups.
Diamond, who has long been opposed to the vaccine mandate, said parents already have access to adequate information to make healthcare decisions for their children.
“House Democrats now want to bully [parents] every year,” he said. “They are going back to the COVID nonsense where we can’t let people exercise their freedom.”
Arvind Venkat, D-McCandless, a member of the House health committee and the lone physician in the legislature, said measles is making a comeback after it was eliminated decades ago in the U.S. and poses health risks that can be catastrophic.

Two children died in Texas last year during a surge of cases that led to dozens of hospitalizations.
“It breaks my heart, frankly, that a community in a state that I care for very deeply is now threatened,” said Venkat, who is co-sponsoring the bill.
The legislation would not eliminate Pennsylvania's existing religious and philosophical exemptions.
“Rather, it would ensure that parents revisit this important decision regularly and do so with current, evidence-based medical information,” Frankel’s memo to his colleagues said.
Venkat and Frankel, who is chairman of the House health committee, were joined by three other co-sponsors, Tarik Kahn, D-Philadelphia, Bridget Kosierowski, D-Scranton, and Michael Schlossberg, D-Allentown, in what will be a challenging bill to pass.
While other states have imposed tougher requirements for parents to get exemptions, nearly all of the states pushed for those reforms before the pandemic, when more people began rejecting vaccines.
The number of parents in Pennsylvania choosing to avoid the shots for their children has soared since 2019, reaching nearly 23,000 at the end of the 2025 school year.
"It's a very difficult time to legislate it,” said Frankel, who has served in the House for 14 years.
“It's just truly alarming and unnecessary that we have been in a position where [childhood diseases were] mostly eradicated, and now we're faced with the situation that we see them coming back.”
With the jump in waivers by parents, the need for protections in classrooms has grown, say experts.
Two years ago, Pennsylvania led the nation in pertussis cases — or whooping cough — as the number of children getting those shots dropped dramatically, the data shows.
The outbreak spread to at least 2,381 people, mostly high school students, the highest number in a quarter century.
In the prior school year, nearly 9,400 students from seventh grade and about 3,900 from 12th grade had no record of getting the Tdap vaccine — the shot that wards against the disease, the Post-Gazette found.
In the case of the current measles outbreak in southeastern Pennsylvania, the trend is similar.
Far fewer children have been immunized against the virus over the past six years — and by the last school year, hundreds of students in classrooms across Lancaster and Lebanon counties had not received the shots.
In some schools in Lancaster, less than half the students in kindergarten had been immunized.
Despite the internal battles in the legislature, Frankel said the current outbreak and the surging number of measles cases in other parts of the country have spurred lawmakers to bring back the legislation that he first proposed in 2021.
“The landscape is different from last year — the year before — to what's happening now,” he said.
Todd Wolynn, a longtime Pittsburgh pediatrician who counsels healthcare workers on how to talk about vaccine safety, said the effort to pass such a bill may be difficult.
But the state is now in a position where too many schools have been stripped of herd immunity — the threshold to prevent the disease from spreading.
“We’re going to be seeing more outbreaks,” he said. “Given the large pockets, we’re still looking at high risk. It’s really, really sad. These are kids’ lives.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.