With hundreds of children sickened by measles nationwide, top Pennsylvania lawmakers say the state needs to disclose the vaccination rates of all schools to protect the most vulnerable students and warn the public when critical protections fail.
In just five years, the number of children immunized against measles in Pennsylvania has fallen to levels that medical experts say pose risks to students in every corner of the state.
“This issue is too important,” said state Rep. Arvind Venkat, a Democrat from Allegheny County and the only physician in the state legislature. “It is supposed to be public.”
Venkat, along with state Rep. Dan Frankel, of Squirrel Hill, the Democratic chair of the House health committee, says the state needs to make the rates accessible to the public — a practice that’s been followed for years by many other states.
Both lawmakers say they will look for ways that the Pennsylvania Department of Health, which already collects the data from more than 4,500 schools, can share those numbers with parents.
The move by the lawmakers follows a Post-Gazette investigation last month that found the vaccination rates in hundreds of schools — public and private — have plummeted to levels not seen in years without any effort by the state to disclose the data to the public.
Read More
In two-thirds of Pittsburgh public schools, the number of kindergarten students vaccinated against measles has dropped below herd immunity, the crucial threshold needed to stem the spread of the disease.
More than a dozen parents interviewed in the Post-Gazette’s investigation said they were unaware of the rates in the schools their children attend and did not know where to get the information, even as hundreds of children were infected with measles in other states.
"That seems like just a fundamental right,” said David Gerritson, whose children attend Pittsburgh Montessori. "Information about whether or not your kids are safe or you are safe should be just like publicly accessible information that's easy to find that anybody can know.”
The effort by the lawmakers comes years after a special state commission in 2016 urged the health department and the Department of Education to make vaccination numbers in school districts "easily accessible" to the public to encourage "the importance of vaccination compliance."
But nothing happened.

From 2020 to the end of last year, the rates for all vaccines — including measles, polio and whooping cough — steadily dropped in schools from Pittsburgh to the eastern counties of the state.
In Philadelphia public schools, one in every four schools is below the threshold of safety.
In response to emailed questions, the state health department said that to provide those numbers on its website, the state would have to reallocate "personnel and staff time" and would require the department to "overhaul" its reporting system.
The agency said that any such action to create a public portal would "divert essential resources" away from department activities.
Dangerous surge
Both Pennsylvania lawmakers calling for more transparency said that with the current spread of measles at levels not experienced in decades — including cases that led to two deaths and scores of hospitalizations in Texas last year — the state can't afford not to respond.
This year alone, 1,800 cases of measles have been reported in three dozen states, from Arizona to North Carolina.
"The issue is too important to be a barrier," said Venkat. "I'm not sure what priorities within the Department of Health would be higher than this issue, given their responsibility to protect the public health."
Already this year, two outbreaks have taken place in Pennsylvania, including an ongoing spate of cases in Lebanon County totaling a dozen people — with three hospitalized — and another in Lancaster County in February with a dozen people sickened.
Two years ago, Pennsylvania led the nation in the number of whooping cough cases, a highly infectious respiratory infection, as the number of vaccinations for that illness dropped, records show.

Venkat, an emergency medical doctor, said one reason for making the rates public would be to better inform parents with immuno-compromised children who are dependent on other students being vaccinated to help stem the spread of diseases.
He also noted that school employees have a stake in knowing whether their environment is dangerous.
"We're unfortunately headed to seeing more outbreaks and unfortunately more illness,” Venkat said. “We're seeing that again, the measles outbreak in South Carolina, the measles outbreak in Texas and New Mexico. I hope it is seeping into the community's consciousness that these diseases still exist.”
State Rep. Michael Schlossberg, D-Lehigh, the House majority whip, told the Post-Gazette that he will support the actions of both lawmakers to ensure the rates in the schools are put on display by the state.
Schlossberg was among a bipartisan group of lawmakers a decade ago who pushed for the special state commission to generate a report, which included the request that all rates be accessible to the public to help enforce the state's vaccine mandate.
At the time, thousands of students in Pennsylvania were admitted to their schools under a provisional period lasting up to eight months before they were required to get the shots.
Following the commission's recommendations, the state health department cut that window to five days.
Schlossberg said he was unaware that the health department never created a public portal to show the rates in schools.
"Should it be done? Absolutely,” he said. The state needs "as much transparency with this data as humanly possible."
Frankel, a longtime Democratic lawmaker from Allegheny County who has led the health committee for three years, said divulging the immunization rates could be carried out without passing new legislation.

The goal is to “make sure the parents have the information they need to protect their kids,” he said.
Though the health department said that creating public access to the rates would be costly, the Post-Gazette managed to develop a database that allows the public to search thousands of schools — public and private — in Pennsylvania using state data obtained through public records requests.
The search engine allows the public to find the rates of nearly all the shots required under the state’s vaccine laws — including the MMR for measles, mumps, and rubella and DTaP for whooping cough.
Several states already provide such information on their health department websites, including Louisiana, North Carolina and Texas.
Stripping protections
Just six years ago, Pennsylvania had one of highest immunization rates in the country — with only a handful of schools under the threshold of herd immunity.
But starting in 2021, the rate began to decline as the pandemic took hold and misinformation campaigns about vaccine safety swept the state and the rest of the country.
By 2023, thousands of families had sought waivers to the vaccines while another trend began to unfold: Superintendents and principals stopped enforcing the mandates.
The Post-Gazette’s investigation found that school leaders allowed nearly 16,000 students into Pennsylvania classrooms last year without the required shots or the exemptions, stripping away vital protections in hundreds of classrooms.
While the state was collecting the data on vaccinations, the public was largely unaware of the trends unfolding in local schools.
By providing the numbers of students who are immunized in the classrooms, the public will be able to grasp the risks at the school and the surrounding community, said researchers at the University of Pittsburgh School of Public Health.
Based on a recent analysis, the current rates in some of the schools in Pittsburgh are alarming and could lead to hundreds of cases of measles across Allegheny County, said Mary Krauland, an assistant professor at the university’s Public Health Dynamics Laboratory.
“These things can really blow up,” she said. “Every unprotected person is a possible case.”
Not only should the information be provided by the state, she said, but “it needs to be done in a user-friendly manner. It needs to be out there.”
In North Carolina, the state health department website provides a searchable database that allows the public to look up the number of kindergarten students who are vaccinated in nearly 1,700 public and private schools.
In Louisiana, the state health website offers even more details, breaking down rates by individual vaccine in every school.
And in Texas, data can be downloaded from the state health department into a spreadsheet that shows the number of students who meet the vaccine requirements in each district and private school.
This level of transparency helps parents make decisions about the safety of their children and sends a message to school leaders who are responsible for enforcing the state’s vaccine mandate, said Schlossberg, the House majority whip.
While legislative changes would be difficult in an era of vast political differences over vaccines, he said the health department could take steps to disclose the data without enacting any law.
“I would like that information to get out there not just for all the parents of immunocompromised kids,” said Schlossberg, “but for parents to be able to address school board members, and say, ‘Look, what are you doing to protect us?’ The more we can change lives on that and get vaccines into people in keeping safe, the better.
Post-Gazette staff writer Hanna Webster contributed to this report.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.