The Pittsburgh metropolitan area could learn from New York, San Francisco and Philadelphia, finds a new analysis from Johns Hopkins University.

How spread out a metro area is — including the distance from residences to medical centers and grocery stores, its walkability, whether it’s car reliant — can influence the health of its inhabitants. Researchers at Johns Hopkins looked at almost two dozen such variables and rated more than 200 large metropolitan areas for their sprawl.

The Pittsburgh metropolitan region ranked in at 143 out of 233, and its lowest score was for density, both of its population and buildings.

Cities and counties with more sprawl are linked to higher rates of fatal car accidents, more hospitalizations, greater social isolation and increased exposure to Lyme disease, researchers found.

Advertise with us

“Urban sprawl has, at its core, issues of social determinants of health,” said Maureen Lichtveld, dean of the University of Pittsburgh School of Public Health. “It’s for a very specific reason that we always say, ‘Where you live determines your health.’”

The news comes as Mayor Corey O’Connor has been laser-focused on multiple initiatives to beautify the city, fasttrack Pittsburgh’s permitting processes, update transit lines and breathe life into Downtown post-pandemic, partnering with Gov. Josh Shapiro to funnel $600 million into renovations. This has included the refreshed Market Square and $31 million for the creation of Arts Landing, as well as plans for residential renovations in the Golden Triangle.

“Downtown is the economic heart of our whole region and we need to provide it with resources to make growth happen,” O’Connor said in a January news release on a few of the proposed changes. “We are serious about hitting the ground running and taking steps that create a strong and inclusive Downtown where there’s opportunities for small businesses, families, housing and redevelopment.”

Shima Hamidi, associate professor in environmental health and engineering at Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health and lead researcher on the new report, started researching urban sprawl more than two decades ago. The current report updates findings from her previous research, and is based on 2020 population and health data.

To calculate sprawl, researchers gathered data on a region’s street connectivity, density and whether cities had central meeting places. They also considered an area’s mix: Was there a variety of residential, business and recreational spaces, or were neighborhoods segregated, say, to only single-family homes?

Advertise with us

These factors contribute both to a city’s sprawl and the health of its inhabitants in a few ways. Streets with more room for pedestrians, bikes, buses and cars — instead of cars alone — increase walkability, connectedness and the chance for physical activity, while decreasing pedestrian deaths. Specifically, people who lived in more sprawling areas were 2.2 times more likely to get into a fatal car accident compared to compact areas, and 6.5 times more likely to get hit by a car as a pedestrian.

Hamidi and her colleagues also found that more compact cities with more mixed-use land led to fewer hospitalization rates.

“More sprawling counties have significantly higher rates of hospitalizations from [chronic obstructive pulmonary disease] and heart attack,” said Hamidi. “Why? Because in more sprawling areas, people don't have good access to health care. … So it's more likely they don't visit a doctor until it becomes more serious, and they need to be hospitalized.”

Compact cities are also intrinsically more walkable, increasing the opportunity for physical activity, which is heart protective, as well as for more social connection, which has been shown to protect physical health.

And emissions from more car dependency in sprawling areas ratchets up extreme heat and weather events, she said, which can exacerbate preexisting heart and lung conditions and contribute to higher rates of hospitalizations.

Advertise with us

The Pittsburgh metro area scored best on having central meeting places throughout the region for people to congregate.

Hamidi and her team examined these large metro areas as well as sprawl at the county level — and Allegheny County did better than the metro area as a whole, ranking 269 out of 995. The county mirrored the pattern of the larger metro area; that is, it scored best for centering and worst for density.

“I was so saddened to see we were kind of in the middle of the road,” said Margaret Larkins-Pettigrew, a Pittsburgh-based physician, chair of OB-GYN at Drexel University School of Medicine and member of the Allegheny County Health Department’s Board of Health.

“Growing up in Pittsburgh, I always had a feeling that we were a growing city that was becoming much more inclusive over the years,” she said. “It’s a difficult thing to swallow to think that we have not been intentional about how we are building our city to address all the issues we currently have around social isolation, poverty, and environmental safety.”

Pittsburgh has worked to beautify and update the city to attract new residents, but could focus more on enriching the lives of current residents, said Larkins-Pettigrew.

Advertise with us

She pointed to the division of the Hill District in the 1950s to build the Civic Arena, and the neighborhood-based segregation that has persisted in Pittsburgh since. There is room for that to change now that longtime contracts on the land have expired, the Post-Gazette reported in November.

“You don’t see investment in walkability in poor communities, where we need it most,” said Lichtveld. “There is a limited amount of walkable space and limited investment in grocery stores where you can buy healthy food. So you cannot complain about the high rate of obesity in those communities.”

Opportunities for growth exist, say city planning experts, both for increasing the region’s compactness by building more structures, and for updating existing infrastructure and zoning laws to maximize land use, efficiency and resident quality of life.

Pittsburgh’s hilly and river-laden geography acts as a natural barrier that both prevents sprawl but can limit progress toward compactness in certain ways.

This geography “resulted in a pattern of complete neighborhoods that are anchored by commercial streets, connected to parks and open space, and often along transit lines,” said Ivette Mongalo-Winston, Pittsburgh’s director of city planning, in an email.

Advertise with us

“Typically, there was a variety of housing types, from single-family to attached units and multifamily buildings, so that residents could stay in a neighborhood through all of the life stages,” she said. “Over time, some zoning restrictions have made it harder to build these types of neighborhoods that have everything you need in walking distance.”

Single-use zoning still dominates most municipalities in our region, agreed Sabina Deitrick, associate professor of urban affairs and planning at the University of Pittsburgh School of Public and International Affairs, and a former member of Pittsburgh’s Planning Commission.

In short, cohabitating comes at a cost. It’s not as simple as building new structures — change must occur on the policy level, and people have to agree on living in a neighborhood that is mixed use, with more housing, grocery stores and shopping centers around them.

In the Hopkins report, Hamidi was surprised to discover that more compact cities ended up being more affordable than sprawling ones, because higher housing costs were offset by less money spent on transportation and energy, like utility bills.

“People think that if they move to the suburbs they’ll have a better life,” said Larkins-Pettigrew. “But they have less access to transportation and health care, and more social isolation. We have not embraced those challenges intentionally yet.”

Advertise with us

Moving from sprawl to compactness also takes a good bit of time. Despite the report’s data being from 2020, likely not much has changed in six years, said Deitrick, because city planning projects take ample time and money and require leadership.

“You don’t undo 150 years of development in two years,” she said. “You’re talking about new development, new construction, new density, adding inclusionary zoning, et cetera, across dozens and dozens and dozens of planning commissions across Allegheny County alone.”

Especially because of Pittsburgh’s topography, sprawl problems begin and end at the municipal level, said Deitrick, and those municipalities all have their own planning commissions.

That Allegheny County’s score was better than metropolitan area at-large may mean the region is making progress, said Larkins-Pettigrew.

“Hopefully, governmentally we are making plans to grow as a city where we are taking care of everybody and paying attention to population health,” she said.