It seems counterintuitive — give people a place indoors to use drugs under the supervision of medical professionals and recovery specialists — and fatal overdoses plummet by the thousands. At sites in the U.S. and Canada, these lives saved bear out.
But what about crime rates?
That seems to be more complicated.
Distinct from nonclinical recovery support centers, homeless shelters or harm reduction organizations like Prevention Point Pittsburgh, supervised consumption sites allow visitors to take drugs on-site and can provide the overdose reversal medication naloxone, oxygen and other emergency supports. Also called overdose prevention centers, the sites offer wound care and connections to recovery services. No overdose deaths have been reported from two sites in the U.S., where the practice is not federally legal, nor in Canada, where it is. It’s unclear whether there are more U.S. sites operating under the radar.
The centers aim, beyond preventing fatal overdoses, to drive down rates of HIV and hepatitis C caused by using infected needles and contain related debris.
Heated debates have ensued in states that have tried to open up such sites, because the practice remains federally illegal in the U.S., and some worry they will enable drug use and increase crime in the surrounding area.
A new study from researchers at McGill University in Canada found that the opening of these sites and their effect on crime depended heavily on context, but generally crime decreased over time.
The study comes during a time when harm reduction resources are being curtailed across the country and in Pennsylvania. In 2025, state harm reduction groups lost at least $1.5 million in funding, leading to layoffs and, for the organization Unity Recovery, with sites in Pittsburgh’s South Side and Philadelphia, the cutting of their daytime hours.
President Donald Trump signed an executive order in July urging federal and state governments to end support and funding for these sites; it also stated the administration’s intentions to prohibit open illicit drug use and sleeping outside.
And on Monday, Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. called harm reduction strategies ineffective in a news release about a $100 million investment in addiction and recovery services.
The McGill study looked specifically at safe injection sites in Toronto to examine whether their openings brought a rise in crime. Researchers evaluated police report data over a three-year span and tracked multiple crimes — instances of breaking and entering, assaults, theft and robberies — within a quarter-mile radius over the course of the sites’ opening. They compared these rates to a year before the openings.
Breaking and entering crimes increased 50% on average, and assaults went up at some sites. But others saw dramatic decreases in crime, and crime rates, including for breaking and entering, dropped each month. Results also showed that car and bicycle theft and thefts over $5,000 decreased after the sites opened.

As of September 2024, Canada had 39 supervised consumption sites, and statistics show staff have reversed more than 58,000 overdoses over seven years.
“The results mirror what American studies were showing,” said Dimitra Panagiotoglu, associate professor of health services at McGill University and lead author on the paper, published in November in JAMA Network Open.
A 2023 study examining crime rates around two New York City overdose prevention centers, called OnPoint NYC, found significant decreases in criminal court summons and drug possession arrests, and a 50% reduction in calls for medical emergencies. Similar to the McGill study, property crime reports minorly increased. A majority of OnPoint visitors said they would have used drugs in public or semi-public places were it not for the sites.
But opposition prevails for many cities that attempt to open overdose prevention centers, many citing their illegality. In Philadelphia, the supervised consumption site Safehouse was closed following a ban on the practice in 2023. And in Pittsburgh, conversations about adding such a component to Second Avenue Commons were quickly shot down in 2022. And resistance continues in New York City. Congresswoman Nicole Malliotakis, R-NY, renewed calls to shut down OnPoint’s two sites in recent years.
The Toronto study results did not surprise Jen Shinefeld, cofounder of the Philadelphia-based harm reduction group The Everywhere Project.
“There are an abundance of positives for having these types of services in a community,” she said. “They save lives.”
As far as the belief that syringe service programs or overdose prevention centers increase crime, Everywhere Project staff rejected it.
“You put a new supermarket in and you're going to have an increase in crime,” said Thomas Frey, director of operations for the group.
It’s crucial, though, that these kinds of concerns are taken seriously and not dismissed, say experts, and that community members are brought to the table early in the planning process.
“The Toronto study really suggests that there are strong contextual factors that shape this,” said Paul Joudrey, assistant professor at Pitt and a Pittsburgh-based addiction medicine clinician. “For the population using drugs, there is very little doubt that engagement with these sites reduces harm. This is uncontroversial,” he said. “My view on the community effects are more complicated. I think there probably are tradeoffs.”
Looking deeper at the results finds that the spike in breaking and entering came mostly from one Toronto site that was near a local market and enabled such crimes. Researchers noted that efforts to increase security and other preventive measures reduced this crime type around this facility, and they speculated that the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic — such as the increase in homelessness — may have played a role.
“For working-class and middle-class families, if a mom is walking her kid to school and they walk by a car with a window smashed, people don’t like that. We have to be respectful of those interests,” said Joudrey. “A lot of these things really depend on early engagement with a diverse set of stakeholders.”
That also includes implementing wraparound services, such as transportation and housing, at sites.
“Wraparound services could eliminate a lot of this crime,” said Frey. “When things are far away and have these boundaries up, it creates a lot more trouble. You have to have other resources.”
Still, it takes time to strengthen collaboration with impacted communities and work with neighbors who resist the erection of a site like this in their area. Overdose prevention centers work best when the community is included in decision-making and external services — like heightened security, transportation vouchers and public bathrooms — are implemented, Panagiotoglu said.
“This kind of work is really challenging and fraught,” she said. “Any time we can work to build services with community buy-in first and then maintain the community, that’s the best way of going forward.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.