The holidays have a way of nudging families into the same room — sharing meals, stories and traditions that tie generations together.

Those big gatherings are an ideal opportunity to talk about something else families share: health history.

Conversations about sickness and disease can feel daunting, emotional or even morbid. But experts stress that approaching them sensitively — and gathering even just a few key details — can help doctors tailor screenings, spot hereditary risks early and potentially prevent serious illness.

“It’s really important through the generations that they have these conversations, open dialog, because it really may come into play down the road,” said Jaime Mullin, a medical oncologist at UPMC Hillman Cancer Center. “Particularly, things like colon cancer, breast cancer, obviously, are key drivers of early mortality,” for the patients she sees at her oncology practice.

Advertise with us

Why family history matters

When it comes to cancer or heart problems, doctors say early or unusual diagnoses of close family members can be important clues to catch these diseases in their earlier and more curable stages.

Mullin explained that when a patient has a family history of cancer occurring before age 50, genetic testing and early screening can be valuable tools to catch the disease early.

But many people don’t know the details of relatives’ illnesses, especially if a family member died young.

“Sometimes children are young, and then they grow up, and then they’re not at all familiar with what kind of cancer their parent or aunt or uncle had when they passed away.”

Cardiologists see similar gaps.

Advertise with us

“One of the things that I think is really important is understanding that this is a piece of everybody's own full personal health,” said Katie Berlacher, a cardiologist at the UPMC Heart and Vascular Institute and an associate professor at Pitt’s School of Medicine.

Genetics are just “one piece of our risk,” she said, which combine with lifestyle and environment to shape a person’s overall health outlook. But a detailed family history can help physicians “put all of those other pieces together.”

In cardiology, that might mean the difference between standard screening versus more proactive measures.

“If you have a family history of heart disease at a very young age, that will change the timing and the things that I order,” versus another patient without that same genetic connection, she explained.

What genetics can, and cannot, predict

For some, learning about personal risk feels overwhelming, with genetics mistakenly viewed as destiny.

Advertise with us

That’s not so in most cases, Berlacher said.

“We know that heart disease is, at this point, about 70% preventable based on medications and behaviors. So, just because you might have genes that work against you doesn't mean that it's a death sentence or that it necessarily will happen. Genes are just one part of it.”

Her message: Knowledge is not a burden, it’s leverage.

“The goal of this conversation is not to paralyze people or to make them sad,” she said. Instead, the knowledge “empowers them and us to optimize their care.”

How far back and wide to look

The medical histories of your great-great-grandmother or distant cousin don’t necessarily need to be unearthed.

Advertise with us

Instead, Mullin and Berlacher suggested starting with first- and second-degree relatives: parents, siblings, children, grandparents, aunts and uncles.

In oncology, first-degree blood relatives are considered much more significant than second or third, Mullin said.

But patterns matter too: “If five out of six aunts had breast cancer … that’s something very important to know.”

Cardiology follows a similar rule of thumb.

“I can't think of the last time that I used a second cousin's family risk” to modify a treatment plan, Berlacher said. But “first and second generation is very, very helpful.”

Advertise with us

Decoding our DNA

Genetic testing can be a powerful medical tool. But doctors caution that at-home DNA kits don’t always provide the clarity people expect.

The two physicians agreed that DNA kits are everywhere this time of year — but they caution against overinterpreting them.

“People will bring Jaime [Mullin] and I long lists of genes that they were tested for,” Berlacher said. Without a more nuanced and personalized medical context, she said, those generalized reports can be difficult to interpret.

Medical genetic testing, she emphasized, is targeted — ordered for specific reasons and paired with counseling.

Mullin described the process: Patients with concerning familial risks are referred to a genetic counselor, who will conduct an extensive review of the patient’s family history. From there, the medical team will order a detailed genetic panel with instructions to look for a specific malignancy. Alternatively, the team will decide to map the patient’s entire genome, which would “come back with a huge number of mutations. Some are important, some are not.”

Advertise with us

Biggest red flags

While neither doctor offered a definitive checklist, both pointed to patterns in family history that should prompt closer attention and, in some cases, earlier or more intensive screening.

In cardiology, warning signs include a close family history of inherited cholesterol conditions, abnormal heart rhythms, hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (an inherited heart condition where the heart muscle thickens and stiffens) or early-onset heart disease. Heart attacks, stent or bypass surgery before age 40 are considered particularly concerning.

In oncology, red flags include breast and colon cancer diagnosed before age 50, clusters of the same cancer on one side of the family, early cancers with unclear primary origins and recurrent cancers across generations.

In addition to cancer and heart health, the Mayo Clinic also suggests several additional conditions to inquire about: autism, birth defects, diabetes, infertility, kidney disease, learning or intellectual disabilities, mental illness, stroke, skin conditions, vision or hearing loss at a young age or with no apparent cause, and very tall or very short stature, compared to the rest of the family.

Having a conversation, with care

Still, nobody wants to cloud a festive gathering with anxiety. The doctors recommend gentle, curious, low-pressure approaches.

Advertise with us

“No one wants to be a Debbie Downer,” Mullin said. But sparks for conversation can be simple: “Hey, you know, my friend ‘So and So’ was looking into these tests. Have you had this done recently?”

You can also ask what relatives remember about older family members — especially those who passed young or when medical terminology was limited. Even rough details may help doctors build a clearer picture.

Talking about health history may not be as fun as swapping heirloom family recipes, but it’s a gift with lasting value, Mullin said.

As Berlacher put it: “Jaime and I would love to mitigate and decrease risk as much as possible. And for us to figure out how to best do that, we just have to know all of the information.”