One year ago, a particular Christmas tree caught Danielle Clary’s attention.
It was especially festive, bright with purples, blues, pinks and greens and situated in a sunroom, where its lights and branches were set against the snow or sun on any given winter day.
Chimes frequently stole her attention from it, though. Not church or sleigh bells, but alarms from the machines that kept her 2-month-old daughter, Sailor, alive after a near-SIDS (sudden infant death syndrome) event injured her brain last November.
That tree was near her daughter’s room at UPMC Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh. Sailor passed away in early February, nearly five years after her older sister, Alessia, died at 2 months old from several congenital anomalies.
But those memories are only part of what makes this Christmas difficult for the Clarys.
Due to Sailor's birth, health complications and her passing, and then a new high-risk pregnancy and birth of a baby boy, Harden, Danielle Clary hasn’t worked since September 2024. Despite her husband, Matt, working two jobs, it hasn’t been enough, especially with a Santa-believing 4-year-old girl, Crimsyn, also at home.
Read More
“We’ve been struggling financially for a while now, and everything has gotten so crazy expensive,” Danielle, 30, of Brookline, said. “It costs $100 practically every time you leave your house. I’m pretty stressed about Christmas.”
For parents, that “stress” is often a sinking feeling that less money will mean a less wonderful time for their kids, though experts know that age-appropriate communication is the key to easing that burden.
“People are losing their jobs. People are relying on food banks. It’s all over the news. Kids are probably hearing about it from their friends,” said Erin Troupe, licensed professional counselor and owner of Sprout Center for Emotional Growth and Development in Brentwood. “If your parent loses their job, for instance, it’s a lot, a lot that kids don’t need to shoulder.”
To remove the load, put kids on a developmentally appropriate, need-to-know basis, Troupe advised.
“When kids are really little, you might be able to shield them from some of this,” she said. “The little ones don’t really have a concept of money anyway. Also consider whether the issue is a blip on the radar or a long-term thing,” to decide whether the issue is necessary to discuss, or how to frame it if you do.
When it comes time to manage expectations — holiday or otherwise — words and tone matter.

“When we say only, ‘We can’t afford that,’ they don’t have anything to feel safe about,” said Tanya Banda, a licensed psychologist and owner of Enlightened Psychological Assessment in Mt. Lebanon. “That is where that scarcity mindset can be harmful. There’s no plan. You want to be sure you’re adding that piece of reassurance, that things may be different this year and we’re going to be OK.”
Per Banda, a “script” for this conversation should be clear, without overwhelming kids with adult-level details: Describe the situation and how the plan to budget differently may change holiday activities or gifts but will ensure financial safety. And let them know that mom and dad have it handled.
A useful dialogue could include something like, “‘It’s our job as your parents to worry about the money. It’s not your job to fix it,’” Banda said. “Set that boundary with them.”
Jessica Lynch, 47, of Bethel Park, knows that conversation well.
The mortgage on her home increased by $400 per month this year. She just happened to need a new vehicle, which must be large — and on the expensive side — to accommodate her work as a full-time professional organizer.
And like many, she found herself short of breath when reading grocery store receipts, which is why she had a sit-down with her kids.
“Food prices have definitely kicked our butts, so we’ve been a lot more diligent with meal planning,” she said. “Now, we pick out three meals per week together, so I know they’ll eat them. That way, I’m not spending $23 on ground meat and then throwing half of it away because nobody finished it.”
Because of conversations such as that one, her kids — with the advantage of some age and maturity — knew Christmas would be different this year, and her son has already made it clear he wishes for just one thing.
“There’s a lot of guilt that goes along with that for me,” Lynch said. “I don’t want my son to just have one present to open. So, I think, well, I’ll get him this sweatshirt, too, but sweatshirts are $80.”
The Lynches have a helpful dose of perspective, however. A few years ago, they sold their house, gave away or sold most of their belongings, bought an RV and traveled the country for two years.
It decreased their reliance on “stuff,” but it also reinforced the value of quality time, making it easier for Lynch to anchor holiday expectations to meaningful experiences that happen to be inexpensive or free.
The original “Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer” is a post-Thanksgiving dinner must-watch for their family. They make cookies and ravioli by hand. When the kids were younger, Lynch would wrap all of their Christmas-themed books and allow her kids to open one each night leading up to the big day. And New Year's Eve meant hourly planned activities, leading up to “milk cocktails” — milk poured into glasses with an icing and a sprinkle rim — at midnight.
The environment Lynch created for her kids is in the spirit of what Troupe asks families to construct, especially when money is tight.
For older children, Troupe might recommend a holiday budget for each person, where finding the “best” gifts to fit within it can be both a learning experience and something done together, maybe even in a thrift shop.
“Half of what you find in a thrift shop is brand new! You throw away all that crappy packaging from new items anyway,” she said. “And that’s a fun thing to do together. ‘Look what I found!’ That’s something that can be shared.”
And for anyone who thinks making ravioli and cookies, rolling and cutting cinnamon dough ornaments, or stringing popcorn into garlands, are poor substitutes for lavish presents, science will prove you wrong.
Through observational studies of children and laboratory testing in animals, it is well understood that activities that engage multiple senses improve learning and memory.
“It’s clinically proven. The key part is doing an activity together with sensory elements. I’m smelling it. I’m feeling the popcorn or the dough. I’m spending time with someone important. It checks all the boxes to create a memory,” Troupe said.
As families more intentionally gather to watch a classic holiday movie rather than heading out to spend more holiday cash that they may or may not actually have, serendipitously the lessons in those movies reinforce the resilience holidays with “less” can have on families who choose to work through it together.
As Theodor Seuss Geisel wrote in “The Grinch”: “Maybe Christmas, he thought, doesn’t come from a store. Maybe Christmas, perhaps, means a little bit more.”
It does for Danielle Clary and her family. They may not have the extra money to see Kennywood lights this year, but they’ll tour their neighborhood’s holiday decorations just for fun, not on their way to or from a hospital. There will be Christmas trees, too, with an emphasis on their own this time — a family tree and one for each daughter gone too soon.
And even if Santa offers less this year, they have extended family to support them with both presents and presence.
“If you talk to any adult about what they remember about the holidays when they were a kid, it’s always the experience and not the, ‘Oh, when I was 5, I got a PlayStation,’” Banda said. “It’s doing something with someone you love. There’s attunement. There’s presence. It’s filled with the love these individuals have for each other, and that’s where the magic is.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.