This story includes discussion of suicide. If you or someone you know needs help, the national suicide and crisis lifeline in the U.S. is available by calling or texting 988.
Shorter days and colder weather can do more than dampen mood.
For some, the shift in daylight triggers a condition known as seasonal affective disorder, or SAD — a subtype of bipolar disorder or depression that follows a seasonal pattern. Roughly 5% of Americans experience the disorder, according to the American Psychiatric Association.
“The difference between seasonal affective disorder and blues — or changes that many folks have with the change of seasons — is really in the impact that it will make in someone's life,” said Erika Saunders, a psychiatrist at Penn State Health. “We look for changes in mood, changes in appetite, sleep, energy levels and outlook on life that impair someone from doing the things that they need to do.”
While the disorder is well-known for emotional changes, experts say it often brings physical symptoms, including excessive sleepiness, overeating, weight gain, carbohydrate cravings and heightened sensitivity to pain. For Pittsburghers, SAD can be even harder to manage during the city’s long, gray winters. Alicia Kaplan, a psychiatrist at Allegheny Health Network, said many of her patients see their symptoms worsen in the colder months, highlighting the importance of recognizing and diagnosing the disorder.
Diagnosing SAD
Saunders said the first thing clinicians look for when diagnosing SAD is a seasonal pattern of mood changes.
“This could be either feeling down, sad, gloomy, or it could be feeling what we call anhedonia, which is not feeling the usual excitement and pleasure that someone would have day to day from their usual activities,” she said.
Additional mental symptoms include slowed movements or speech, feelings of worthlessness or guilt, difficulty concentrating and thoughts of death or suicide, per the APA.
To be diagnosed, symptoms must occur around the same time each year — most often in the fall or winter — and improve in the spring, according to guidelines in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. These patterns must be consistent for at least two years.
While the exact cause of SAD remains unclear, researchers believe that a combination of genetic, environmental and biological factors are at play. Women are more likely than men to report a seasonal decline in mood, according to an APA poll from October 2024, where 45% of women said their mood declines in winter compared with 37% of men. Similarly, people who live farther from the equator — where daylight hours are shorter in winter — are said to be at greater risk.
Saunders also believes there is a genetic component.
“We all have genes that put us at risk for various things, so we think that that contributes somewhat, and we also think that there is some relationship between the geographical distance from the equator,” she said.
Additional general risk factors for depression or bipolar disorder — such as early life trauma, chronic stress or other medical or psychiatric conditions — can also increase susceptibility to SAD, Saunders said.
Kaplan said recognizing suicidal thoughts in SAD is particularly important.
“We have to be careful about increased thoughts of worthlessness, like sad thoughts, hopeless thoughts or more severe thoughts, such as thoughts of death,” she said. “We have to really evaluate each patient separately.”
Pain and the body’s response
For many with SAD, physical and emotional symptoms overlap, especially when it comes to pain.
“The pain and the mood systems are very closely intertwined, because they both involve serotonin and other neurotransmitters,” said Saunders. “People with SAD — just like anyone with major depressive disorder — will have a heightened sensitivity to pain.”
That means those who already experience headaches, joint pain or other chronic conditions may notice their discomfort worsen in the darker months. For those who experience both depression and pain, they are more likely to report severe distress and suicidal thoughts, according to findings published in the Journal of Clinical Psychiatry.
“I've seen a lot of overlap between anxiety and depression and stress-related medical conditions,” said Kaplan. “They get worse with depression and anxiety, with overall symptoms such as functional bowel disorders and autoimmunity disorders that are reactive to stress, such as Crohn's and ulcerative colitis, and rheumatological conditions such as lupus.”
Treating depression can also help relieve pain, as many medications used for depression also help manage physical symptoms. Both Kaplan and Saunders said it is important to address pain and depression together when treating SAD.
“We really use what we call a biopsychosocial approach in medicine,” said Kaplan. “We’re treating the whole patient, not looking at things just from a physical standpoint.”
Sleep and hormones
One of the hallmark symptoms of SAD is a change in sleep patterns — often described as “winter hibernation” — where people may find themselves sleeping longer, but feeling less rested.
“People with seasonal affective disorder will have a disruption to their sleep,” said Saunders. “Typically, this is sleeping significantly more during the fall and winter, and significantly less during the spring and summer.”
The brain’s circadian system regulates sleep, energy, appetite and hormone cycles, and it is highly sensitive to light. With less daylight in the fall and winter months, it causes this sleepiness.
Melatonin — the hormone that signals darkness to the body — is also involved.
“Melatonin itself does not make you sleepy, but it tells the brain that we're approaching the dark time of day and night, and you should be winding down and looking for some place to sleep,” said Saunders. “When someone’s sleep schedule gets off, we want to re-regulate what time of day melatonin is produced.”
Appetite
Changes in appetite are another common feature of SAD.
“People with depression who have increased appetite — especially in seasonal affective disorder — do tend to crave carbs and so-called comfort foods, sugar and that type of thing,” said Saunders.
However, the exact reason for carbohydrate cravings remains unclear.
“I’m not sure that we have a great answer for why,” said Saunders. “We can hypothesize that, from an evolutionary perspective, you're increasing your storage of energy, but we also know that the cravings don't equal the healthy energy that is long lasting in terms of what the body needs”
“It’s part of what’s gone awry in this disorder, and part of what makes it a disorder.”
How to help
There are several strategies to manage SAD, ranging from therapy and medication to lifestyle changes.
First-line treatments often include psychotherapy, bright light therapy and, when necessary, medication, Saunders said.
“First-line treatments can include cognitive behavioral therapy — specifically a type for SAD that will include what we call behavioral activation — which is helping people become more physically active and mentally active at certain times of day to help with that energy issue,” she said.
Bright light therapy can also help regulate circadian rhythms, strengthening the biological rhythms that control hormones and other signaling molecules throughout the body.
However, for some patients, medication is also recommended. SSRIs, such as fluoxetine or sertraline, as well as norepinephrine dopamine reuptake inhibitors like bupropion, are commonly used.
“Bupropion works slightly differently and can have a good profile for seasonal affective disorder, because it tends to, if anything, reduce the need for sleep, and it might suppress appetite a little bit,” said Saunders.
Physical activity is another important tool in managing SAD.
“Exercise is very important for all things, all good things, body and brain,” said Saunders. “Exercise can do wonders for improving energy, and regular exercise at the same time of day can be a help in terms of that circadian rhythm.”
Planning ahead and self-care are also very important, Kaplan said. She also recommended practical strategies, like scheduling social activities, maintaining routines and exercising or spending time outdoors when possible.
“It’s empowering to know you can try to prepare a little bit ahead of time, whether it’s pulling out the light box or seeing your therapist to do cognitive behavioral therapy, which can be helpful, or certain medications,” she said.
Ultimately, both Kaplan and Saunders said that there is no one-size-fits-all approach.
“I always tell people, what works for them is the most important,” said Kaplan. “Some people like to walk or do yoga and some like to listen to music. There's no one right way.”
Ava Dzurenda (ava.dzurenda@gmail.com) is a science writer and exercise physiologist based in White Oak.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.