Joanie Isenberg was working in the basement of her Squirrel Hill home in 2023 when an unusual sound caught her attention.
Her two tiny dogs — 14-year-old Moko and her younger brother, Stewie — had been cavorting in the backyard.
Ms. Isenberg, 71, looked up when she heard Stewie yelp in pain.
She couldn’t quite believe what she was seeing: An antlerless deer was attacking the poodle mix that weighed about 14 pounds. He got away and ran to hide in the basement.
Moko, weighing about 8 pounds, wasn’t as fortunate — the deer stomped on the petite poodle repeatedly, almost killing her.
Ms. Isenberg said the deer then turned its attention to her: It charged, but fled before attacking.
She and a friend rushed Moko to a veterinarian, who initially suggested euthanasia as perhaps the best option. Instead, the vets treated Moko for three broken ribs and a punctured lung.
For weeks after the attack, the dog had to be confined to small spaces, and she experienced difficulty eating and drinking for some time. For the rest of her life — she died this year at age 16½ — she suffered separation anxiety.
Ms. Isenberg said she doesn’t know why the deer chose to attack. She hadn’t been feeding them, but can’t say for certain whether neighbors had.
Since the attack, she installed a six-foot double fence — any higher would have required a variance from the city. She hasn’t spotted a deer in her yard since, but she has found some droppings and evidence of nibbled plants.
Sometimes, she’ll ask her neighbors at an apartment complex next door whether they’d mind if she banged pot lids together to scare off deer that congregate on the property.
“And people tease me, but I can absolutely attest to the fact that I'm deer-phobic now,” she said.
Don Wagner, who manages the Penn State University Deer Research Center, said deer that are comfortable around humans or have come to expect to be fed by them are the most likely to attack.
Except in a few instances, workers do not bottle-feed fawns at the center, which houses about 50 deer used for research and education.
Bottle-fed fawns turn into adults that have no fear of humans, a factor that can lead to dangerous encounters, he said.
Bucks, especially, can be unpredictable and have been known to charge at and attempt to gore workers they perceive as threats, competition for a doe’s attention or even as a potential mating partner, he said.
Erica Heide, who oversees Pittsburgh’s deer management program, said that in addition to Ms. Isenberg’s account, she’s heard other anecdotes of people and pets being attacked and sometimes gored.

While a herd of grazing deer in a meadow can be picturesque, don’t try to get closer for a better view, Ms. Heide urged.
“I always say [of] any wildlife, deer included, give them space. Do not interfere with them. Respect their territory and their space and let them move on,” Ms. Heide said.
If deer frequent your property and you’d like to deter their visits, plant deer-resistant species, she said.
The Audubon Society of Western Pennsylvania provides on its website a list of deer-resistant plants that are native to the area.
Fences are another alternative. Both Ms. Heide and Mr. Wagner recommend 10-feet-tall options, if possible.
Both also discourage backyard feeding stations.
It’s not a good idea to build such a reliance on humans, Ms. Heide said. Once humans become a trusted food source, deer “become pushy. Now the deer is pounding on your glass with his antlers. It’s all playing games, till the deer become a little bit too comfortable.”
Once a deer or other animal becomes dangerously comfortable around people, “then we would have to look at euthanizing. We can't relocate deer. It's illegal to do that. So we want to coexist with them, and sometimes the best way to do that is to respect their space, plant things that don't necessarily attract them, and also be considerate that ,even if you like deer, your neighbor might not want deer around.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.