While the effects have not yet fully reached public health entities, officials warn that a prolonged federal shutdown — compounded by Pennsylvania’s budget impasse — could have far-reaching consequences, from straining emergency preparedness and outbreak response to jeopardizing staffing and critical programs across local and state health departments.
“The Allegheny County Health Department (ACHD) remains steadfast in its mission to protect and promote the health of all residents,” spokesperson Ronnie Das said in an email. “While federal shutdowns can create temporary challenges, our dedicated staff continue to ensure that essential public health services, from disease tracking to emergency response, remain active and effective. Our commitment to preparedness, collaboration, and continuity of care allows us to serve Allegheny County residents without interruption.”
The list of ACHD programs that rely on both funding and guidance from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, however, is lengthy.
The county’s Clinical Services Bureau and Public Health Lab receives CDC funding through the Pennsylvania Department of Health, which is essential for operating emergency preparedness, infectious disease programs, immunizations, sexually transmitted disease prevention, diagnostic testing and emergency response programs, Mr. Das said.
Additionally, the ACHD programs related to chronic disease and epidemiology, injury prevention, infectious disease control and opioid surveillance receive both funding and guidance directly from the CDC.
Also of concern: More than a quarter of the ACHD’s staff is “directly supported by grants connected to the federal level.”
Read More
Staffing at the Pennsylvania Department of Health also relies heavily on federal money: PADOH receives approximately 55% of its overall budget from federal funding, which is used to support about 545 full-time state employees, according to a department spokesperson.
For the time being, PADOH is, the spokesperson said in an email, “continuing to provide critical public health services to Pennsylvanians.” Department officials will continue to reassess which services and programs it will continue to fund, depending upon how long the shutdown stretches, as “a significant proportion of the Department's budget comes from federal funds.”
Additionally, in a move to keep funding available for those critical services, the department has “implemented an additional review process for purchasing and hiring new employees, along with placing limits on nonessential travel.”
The federal shutdown represents only part of the problem across the commonwealth, said Kristine Gonnella, executive director of the Pennsylvania Public Health Association, part of the national American Public Health Association.
Public health agencies at the local and state levels are navigating what Ms. Gonnella calls a “trifecta of challenges” as the shutdown compounds the effects of a state budget impasse and deep federal cuts to public health funding in the “One Big Beautiful Bill,” or HR 1.
“It is a little challenging to unravel what specifically is tied up because of the federal government, what are pressures and stresses that are an implication of HR1, and what is happening at the state level.”
The combination, Ms. Gonnella said, has impaired programming.
“You’re sort of paralyzed, because you can’t fully operationalize programming, either because you’re not going to get paid for the work you’re doing, or you don’t know if you’ll have access to those funds, or if the federal government decides to pull them back altogether.”
Even typically resourceful health departments, which often reallocate funds when one source runs dry, are running out of options, she said.
“Public health professionals are scrappy,” Ms. Gonnella said, “but in this particular climate, where we’re talking about federal legislation, a federal shutdown and a state budget impasse — those resources are limited.”
Among the programs hit hardest are those tied to federal and state funding streams, such as SNAP-Ed, the nutrition education arm of the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, which HR 1 “zeroed out” nationwide.
SNAP provides the financial assistance to buy food, while SNAP-Ed teaches people how to shop for, prepare and cook healthy meals and how to be more physically active.
“That’s a huge concern,” Ms. Gonnella said.
SNAP benefits were set to come to a halt, on Saturday, but two federal judges ruled nearly simultaneously on Friday that President Donald Trump’s administration must continue to fund SNAP, the nation’s biggest food aid program, using contingency funds during the government shutdown.
But not knowing how to stretch foodstuffs can add “a snowball impact on the people that are experiencing it.”
Vaccination efforts, public health preparedness and infrastructure modernization projects that rely on federal grants could all be in jeopardy if the shutdown drags on, Ms. Gonnella said.
“Those systems that help track outbreaks, that proactively flag something that could snowball into something larger — those systems are compromised.”
Surveillance of notifiable infectious diseases allows government entities, including the Allegheny County Health Department, to assess disease trends, allocate resources effectively and develop prevention strategies, Mr. Das explained.
Most notifiable conditions are reported through electronic laboratory reporting systems, which are not expected to be affected by a federal government shutdown, he said. This will allow the ACHD to, “continue to access these reports, initiate investigations, provide prevention guidance and monitor outbreaks.”
The unknown, again, is how long the shutdown will continue.
“While certain federal-level activities could delay identification of multi-state outbreaks, our epidemiology team remains in close communication with state and national partners to maintain readiness and response locally,” Mr. Das said. “We continue to track and respond to tuberculosis, STIs, and HIV as usual, though a prolonged shutdown could limit access to CDC expert consultation for complex cases.”
While the Pennsylvania Department of Health maintains its own public health surveillance system and employs its own infectious disease epidemiologists, the CDC serves as a coordinating body for data and information generated by states.
“During the shutdown, this coordination is limited or nonexistent, which can result in gaps in knowledge regarding significant public health issues that may be occurring around the country,” the PADOH spokesperson said.
CDC subject matter expertise and laboratory resources used to help support public health investigations have also been limited for a variety of diseases and conditions, which could result in “delays in the identification of infectious disease and delay public health response activities.”
Continuing as normal
In Allegheny County, services including HIV testing and prevention are continuing as normal. “At this time, there are no impacts of the federal shutdown on ACHD’s HIV or overdose prevention programs. The CDC Office of Grant Services confirmed that we are able to continue drawing funds from our CDC Overdose Data to Action award, allowing this essential public health program to proceed without interruption,” Mr. Das said.
The PADOH did receive instructions from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services regarding surveys that are conducted at health care facilities, such as hospitals and skilled nursing facilities.
“The guidance requires the Department to stop all federal surveys with some exceptions, such as investigations into complaints and facility reports of immediate jeopardy, or actual harm to residents,” the spokesperson said. The state DOH has been authorized to continue “to complete Medicaid-only and state surveys.”
At the same time, the PADOH spokesperson said, HR1 “is expected to lead to millions of people losing health insurance nationwide over the next decade. In Pennsylvania alone, the bill Trump signed into law will cause an estimated 310,000 people to lose their Medicaid coverage.
In an Oct. 2 statement, the American Public Health Association, the oldest and largest organization of public health professionals in the world, urged Congress and the president to work together to reopen the federal government and protect public health.
The nonprofit called for a short-term spending measure that would fully fund critical agencies such as the CDC, FDA and the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, while ensuring that funds allocated for 2025-26 are spent as Congress directed. The group also urged lawmakers to permanently extend the Affordable Care Act’s enhanced premium tax credits, which are set to expire at year’s end.
The American Public Health Association warned that the shutdown has “direct and immediate health impacts,” limiting federal guidance to state and local health departments on programs ranging from food and drug safety to opioid overdose prevention. It also cited risks to federal workers’ job and financial security and raised concerns about potential workforce reductions at key health agencies.
Ms. Gonnella warned that the ripple effects of a continued federal shutdown could also extend to health care coverage and affordability.
HR 1 and other looming policies would end enhanced premium tax credits and make cuts to Medicaid, which Ms. Gonnella warned would, “put a whole other vulnerability onto systems and people.” Those cuts, she said, could drive up costs across the board: “Everybody’s premiums will raise because of that.”
While the Pennsylvania Public Health Association is working to support state and local agencies, Ms. Gonnella said, “It’s a very uncertain time for programming generally. The trifecta is making it a particular challenge.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.