Pennsylvanians will turn their clocks back one hour this weekend as daylight saving time ends and standard time resumes — a ritual that marks the darker days of late autumn with a familiar mix of relief and fatigue.

While many welcome the “extra” hour of sleep, the shift can still throw off the body’s internal rhythm, said Matthew Lehrer, assistant professor of psychiatry at the University of Pittsburgh and a sleep medicine expert at UPMC.

“People have trouble taking advantage sometimes of the extra hour, because their body's still waking them up,” Mr. Lehrer explained. “Your biological processes, your internal clock, are still synchronized to the environment and to the light-dark cycle.”

The chemical that controls waking — cortisol — is tied to a person’s regular sleep routine and, as a result, its levels will rise “at roughly the same time. Your body doesn’t know you’ve gained an hour, and it takes time to adjust,” he explained.

Advertise with us

While it’s a routine most Americans know well — turning those clocks back late Saturday, in advance of the change that occurs at 2 a.m. the first Sunday in November, then doing the reverse the second Sunday of March — it’s one that plenty of lawmakers over the years have tried to end. And between daylight saving and standard time, the edge for many experts goes to the latter.

The Downtown skyline prior to sunrise (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The “fall back” is generally easier on the body than the “spring forward,” though Mr. Lehrer noted that each comes with its own set of challenges.

“The spring forward comes with more cardiovascular health risks,” he said. “The issues with the ‘fall back’ are more mood related, and that’s kind of a factor of just reduced daylight.”

Less daylight exposure can trigger symptoms of seasonal affective disorder, or SAD, in people who are sensitive to shorter days.

Mr. Lehrer said that, ideally, the change in daylight hours would happen gradually. If the “fall back” could be spread over the course of three to five days, it would minimize effects for more people, especially those who are particularly sensitive to the seasonal shifts.

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania Rep. Russ Diamond, R-Lebanon, has reintroduced a bill that would place the state on permanent standard time — ending the twice-yearly ritual of “springing forward” and “falling back” for good.

“I keep introducing the bill and it keeps kind of going nowhere,” said Mr. Diamond, adding that his effort stems from years of hearing complaints from constituents who feel out of sync after the time change.

“People don’t feel the same. Their kids can’t get used to it. Their pets don’t get used to it. It’s just unnatural, and it really interrupts everybody’s sleep patterns,” he said. “That’s not good, health-wise.”

He pointed to research linking clock changes to spikes in car crashes, heart attacks and workplace accidents.

“Those things happen on different levels, both in the spring and the fall,” Mr. Diamond said.

Advertise with us

Personally, Mr. Diamond admitted he finds the shift harder with age: “It takes me about two weeks to actually get adjusted after, in the spring,” he said. “In the fall, it’s not so hard.”

Under his proposal, the state would remain on the same time it reverts to at 2 a.m. this Sunday — permanent standard time.

He believes that shift could also ease some of the darker effects of the season, literally.

“A lot of people get that seasonal affective disorder, and I think a lot of that comes from the fact that we’re kind of shoved into that late afternoon darkness in the fall from ‘falling back,’” he said. “If we were easing ourselves into that gradually … I think people would be a lot less likely to suffer.”

For those looking to soften the transition this week, Mr. Lehrer suggests small, intentional shifts in daily habits.

Advertise with us

One option is to gradually shift breakfast back a bit later every morning. Delaying light exposure, too, can help: “Maybe open your blinds a little later or change the order of your morning routine,” Mr. Lehrer suggested.

He also recommends delaying the use of bright light by a few minutes each day or slightly pushing back bedtime.

For those who use melatonin as a sleep aid, delay the dose by 10 or 15 minutes in the days leading up to the time shift.

As research mounts on the connection between light exposure and overall well-being, Mr. Lehrer said many in the sleep medicine and circadian research community now support staying on one consistent time year-round.

“The body loves consistency,” he said. “The sleep and circadian research communities are pretty aligned that permanent standard time is the best for health.”

Advertise with us

The National Sleep Foundation (NSF), a nonprofit focused on improving health through sleep education and advocacy, maintains that the human circadian system cannot adapt to the twice-yearly clock changes. These shifts disrupt sleep and misalign biological rhythms with the sun’s natural cycle.

Citing research and global consensus, the NSF — along with other international sleep science organizations — supports eliminating daylight saving time in favor of permanent standard time, which better aligns with human biology and promotes overall health and safety, according to a statement on its website.

While no neighboring states have yet taken similar action, Mr. Diamond believes Pennsylvania could lead the way.

“Pennsylvania is not called the Keystone State for no reason,” he said. “If we do it, I think other states will soon follow along — not only because of our position geographically and all the transportation that runs here, but because there’s a lot of banking interests based in Delaware that have Pennsylvania employees.”

He predicted that if Pennsylvania approves the measure, then “Delaware would be the next to fall, and … New York would follow as well.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Diamond did admit that past attempts to stick with daylight saving time year-round haven’t worked out well.

“We did try permanent daylight savings time in 1974. I remember it,” he said. “I walked to the bus stop in the dark on a country road with no sidewalks, and it was not pleasant.”

Eliminating the time changes, he said, would benefit both public safety and health.

“We would go with the movement to ‘Make America Healthy Again’,” he said, “by not interrupting their sleep patterns twice a year unnecessarily, because there is really no actual benefit from changing clocks. It’s just something we’re in the habit of doing.”

He added, with a laugh, “You can quote me when I say, ‘It’s about time.’”

Advertise with us

Until the biannual time changes are halted, Mr. Lehrer advises people to use this weekend’s clock change as an opportunity to check in on their routines — and maybe catch up on a little rest.

“If you really feel like you need the extra hour of sleep, definitely take advantage of it,” Mr. Lehrer said. “It’s not as significant of an adjustment period as the spring, but still one nonetheless.”