Sunscreens: The chemical names are long, and the ingredient lists can be dizzying.
When choosing a sunscreen for children, it’s natural for parents to be concerned about such chemicals. There are a few meaningful distinctions to keep in mind, say dermatologists.
“In pediatrics, we always said prevention is better than cure,” said Gopal Pai, a retired pediatrician based in Canonsburg who worked in the field for six decades. “This is, to me, like wearing seatbelts in the car, making sure you have a safe car, and wearing a helmet if you’re riding a bike. Sunscreen is basically preventive medicine.”
What to look for in sunscreen
Start with the active ingredients on the back label.
A physical sunscreen, also called a mineral sunscreen, will list zinc, zinc oxide or titanium dioxide as the active ingredient.
Chemical sunscreens will list homosalate, oxybenzone, avobenzone or another type of benzone derivative. These are the chemicals that are blocking the ultraviolet, or UV, rays.
Read More
The SPF, or sun-protective factor, will tell you how strong the sunscreen is. Dermatologists recommend sunscreen with an SPF of at least 30, and to reapply every two hours.
Also check for a time limit, which will be listed under the SPF. Some sunscreens stay effective for 80 minutes, others for only 40.
Physical vs. chemical sunscreens
Babies can start wearing sunscreen at 6 months old, but the kind they wear matters. Dermatologists and oncologists differentiate between physical and chemical sunscreens when deciding what works best for kids.
Physical sunscreens create a barrier to block the sun’s ultraviolet rays from penetrating the skin. These are also called mineral sunscreens because they contain the minerals zinc oxide and titanium dioxide.
“For kids, I recommend the mineral-based sunscreens,” said Kristen Whitney, a doctor of osteopathic medicine and dermatologist at Allegheny Health Network in Cranberry.
The zinc compounds form a shield, so nothing gets absorbed into the skin, she explained.
“They have been around forever and are very safe to use,” she said.
Chemical sunscreens, by contrast, will include the compounds homosalate, avobenzone and/or octisalate. These chemicals get absorbed slightly into the skin and convert the sun’s UV rays to neutralize them.
Are chemical sunscreens bad for you?
While chemical sunscreens have been around for decades, concern around them arose after a study found they can get absorbed into the bloodstream.
The small collection of studies in 2019 and 2020 conducted by the Food and Drug Administration found that the blood plasma of people using four different kinds of chemical sunscreen tested positive for the sunscreen compounds.
That, however, does not necessarily mean they’re harmful.
“There really haven’t been significant studies in the last four to five years following up on that,” said Whitney. “There’s a question mark to them. Even if something gets absorbed, does it do anything?”
The FDA stated in a news release about the study’s findings that the agency was still recommending the use of sunscreen, and that more research was needed.
“Results from our study released today show there is evidence that some sunscreen active ingredients may be absorbed,” said Janet Woodcock, then-director of the FDA Center for Drug Evaluation and Research, in a January 2020 statement.
“However, the fact that an ingredient is absorbed through the skin and into the body does not mean that the ingredient is unsafe, nor does the FDA seeking further information indicate such. Rather, this finding calls for further industry testing to determine the safety and effect of systemic exposure of sunscreen ingredients, especially with chronic use.”
Despite the ambiguity, physicians recommended sticking to mineral sunscreens for kids.
“I still recommend them in certain scenarios, but for kids, I just stay stick to the mineral sunscreen until we get more data,” said Whitney. “We should be extra cautious especially in kids that are growing.”
Lotions vs. sprays vs. sticks
In addition to many different types of sunscreens, there are also a variety of ways to lather it on.
Lotions and sticks are better for kids — although it may be tedious to apply lotion to an on-the-go 3-year-old — because spraying sunscreen can lead to uneven application, and physicians advised against sprays for the risk of inhalation.
“These benzene-containing [sunscreens], you never want to inhale them,” said Pai. “If you’re spraying it and you can smell it, it’s probably toxic. Kids are moving around, laughing and crying. You don’t want to inhale that stuff.”
If kids dislike how pasty a mineral lotion sunscreen looks on the skin, consider a micronized zinc version — the smaller zinc particles make for a more clear application — or moisturize first before applying.
Whitney, who has young kids, said she prefers the sunscreen sticks for face and ears.
“Apply it quickly,” she said. “It’s much easier than a cream or a spray for the face. Get a cream for the legs and butt. It can really save you time.”
Also, if using spray sunscreen, never spray directly onto the face — spray into the hands, then rub in.
Sun-protective clothing
For young kids especially, sun-protective clothing may be a better alternative to sunscreen, as it requires less fuss and doesn’t necessitate reapplication.
Sun-protective clothing will have a “UPF” — ultraviolet protection factor — rating, and items come in a variety of styles and colors. Don’t forget hats and sunglasses too, if the kiddos will wear them.
“For the little-little kids, one of the easiest ways [to protect them] is the sun-protective clothes,” said Whitney. “They’re great. If you can save yourself rubbing in sunscreen over the whole abdomen, they can be great. Usually kids don’t put up a fuss with clothes if you start it early.”
‘The best sunscreen is the one you use’
At the end of the day, it’s better to wear sun protection than not. How many times you are administering sunscreen throughout the day and how much you apply go a long way when considering the risk of the chemicals in the sunscreens themselves, versus the risk of skin cancer.
“It’s like anything in medicine,” said Pai. “Everything in moderation.”
For perspective, in the FDA studies, the participants put sunscreen on 75% of their bodies four times a day for four days — a more rigorous regimen than most people follow.
“The best sunscreen is the one you use and the one you like to use,” said Whitney. “Most people don’t apply enough sunscreen, and they don’t apply it frequently enough. If you’re starting to feel your skin burning, it’s too late.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.