When physicians face mental health challenges, many hesitate to seek help — not because they don’t want to, but because they fear doing so could cost them their careers.

Credentialing applications, which are required by both states and hospitals for a physician to practice, have long included detailed questions about mental health history.

According to a 2022 survey by the nonprofit Physicians Foundation, many doctors say they feel discouraged from seeking mental health care because of questions on licensure, credentialing and insurance applications. While credentialing questionnaires vary from state to state, some have asked if applicants had ever been diagnosed with severe major depression, neurological illness or sleep disorder. Some asked for such medical history dating age 18; a few asked about childhood mental health diagnoses.

For years, those questions have had a chilling effect, said Thomas P. Campbell, an emergency medicine physician and chief wellness officer for Allegheny Health Network, with concerns including job security, licensing and credentialing discouraging clinicians from seeking mental health support.

Advertise with us

But the climate is slowly changing.

To reduce stigma and encourage doctors to seek mental health care, AHN implemented changes to its credentialing process in 2023, Campbell said.

The state followed suit in April 2024, said Matt Heckel, press secretary for the Pennsylvania Department of State.

In May, the Pennsylvania State Boards of Medicine and Osteopathic Medicine were recognized by a national nonprofit focused on advocating for physicians’ mental well-being for removing these types of questions about past mental health conditions from the state credentialing process.

The Dr. Lorna Breen Heroes’ Foundation praised the move as a major step forward, according to its website and its chief medical officer, Stefanie Simmons.

Advertise with us

People have historically hesitated to reach out for help, Campbell said, because they believed that it would jeopardize their ability to get a job, though “in reality, there's been no evidence and proof that answering those questions” affected someone’s ability to get a new job or retain the one they already had. “However, there was definitely evidence and proof that it stopped them from reaching out for help because they believed their impression was that that was going to limit their job capabilities.”

The Breen Heroes’ Foundation was created following the suicide of Manhattan emergency room physician Lorna Breen in April 2020, during the early days of the COVID pandemic. Weeks before her death, at one point Breen had been without sleep for nearly a week because of the unrelenting onslaught of COVID patients, some of whom were dying in waiting rooms and hallways. She told family members that “she was afraid to get help, because she was worried it would end the career that she had spent her entire life working for,” according to the foundation’s website.

(James Hilston/Post-Gazette)

Among doctors — and even medical students — Breen’s fears are common during the credentialing process, which happens initially when physicians begin practicing and is required to be renewed periodically, usually every other year. In most cases, credentialing and recredentialing happen at both the state and health system levels, Campbell explained.

As of May 22, 635 hospitals and care facilities — accounting for about 10% of the approximately 6,100 U.S. hospitals — verified their credentialing applications do not include these mental health questions for nearly 274,000 credentialed health workers, per the foundation’s website. It also lists 32 states whose medical boards have removed such questions from its licensing questionnaires.

West Virginia, Maryland, Delaware and New Jersey were among those listed where the questions remain at the state-licensure level.

Advertise with us

The American Medical Association has praised the effort.

“The American Medical Association (AMA) is proud to work alongside the Dr. Lorna Breen Heroes’ Foundation to help more hospitals and health systems take meaningful action to support the mental health of physicians and other healthcare professionals,”  Bruce A. Scott, AMA president, said in a press release. “Addressing the root causes of burnout and removing barriers to care are essential to maintaining a healthy workforce and strengthening the entire healthcare system.”

Part of the problem is systemic: The nature and norms of being a doctor contribute to the job’s stressful nature, Simmons said.

“You're often working many hours and your sleep is disrupted. You are seeing traumas. You are incurring secondary traumas. You're seeing bad things happen to good people,” Simmons said.

“And so, even though the health care workforce is very resilient, they have an increased risk of some mental health conditions, and then you're saying, ‘If you get treatment, you can't be sure what's going to happen to your licensing or to your job.’ So people choose not to get treated and to just tough it out.”

Advertise with us

And it’s not just stigma — financial considerations weigh heavily too. Simmons noted that many medical professionals graduate with more than $200,000 in student debt. The possibility of being denied a license or a job because of past counseling is understandably terrifying, she said.

There's also a culture of kind of toughing it out in the health care field, she said, which “is worse for patient care because you don't prevent mental health conditions by asking these questions, you just prevent treatment for them.”

The logic behind such questions, at its core, is flawed, Simmons said.

“So the only reason to do that would be if you thought that having a history of a mental health condition was a moral failing, right? And to put that into really sharp relief, we don't ask people if they have a history of a potentially impairing physical condition,” such as if they’ve ever been diagnosed or treated for diabetes, she said.

“We're only asking about one, not the other. So there's a clear differentiation there,” said Simmons. She made the argument that, for example, if a doctor is actively being treated for diabetes, a substance use disorder or a mental disease, all have the potential to impact how well someone performs their job. Having a history of being diagnosed and then successfully treated for those conditions does not carry the same risk, she argued.

Advertise with us

Asking a doctor if they’re currently in counseling versus whether they’ve ever sought it is quite different, Campbell said. “I think patients would say it's much more important that we get people comfortable to reach out for help when they need it, rather than hide and not get the help they need.”

The vagueness of how responses to these questions are used is what makes them appear so threatening, Simmons said. If every doctor received regular mental health counseling, then the question of whether they’d ever sought help would become irrelevant, she said.

Or better yet, those doctors admitting to past mental health challenges could receive additional support to keep the condition at bay. “If you say yes, then there are clear, consistent, supportive processes in place,” such as giving doctors access to additional resources in their job, providing a mentor to check in with and other supports, Simmons suggested.

She proposed that a better question for doctors is: “Are you currently impaired for any reason?” That addresses patient safety while encouraging those who need help to find it.

“We absolutely want patients to be safe,” Simmons said. “We also want health care workers to feel comfortable getting care, which also keeps patients safe.”