As with any product, vitamins have undergone many marketable iterations in the past few decades. Popular in recent years are liquid vitamins, which boast easier consumption and better bioavailability, and intravenous infusions of vitamins such as B12, sometimes packaged as “hangover cures.”

But are these methods actually better than taking a pill?

Here’s what to know about some common vitamin claims.

Popularity of supplements

Vitamins and dietary supplements have enjoyed a steep increase in popularity since the 1970s, when alternative health methods went mainstream. By 2002, dietary supplement sales were valued at $18.7 billion, according to a textbook on supplements published by National Academies Press.

Advertise with us

And by 2024, the market size for liquid vitamins specifically was valued at $28 billion and is expected to grow to $44 billion by 2031, per research and consulting firm Verified Market Research.

These valuations are reflected in the products’ popularity, with 34.8% of children and adolescents and 58.5% of adults reported having used at least one dietary supplement in the past month between 2017 and March 2020, according to a 2023 National Health Statistics Report. The pandemic also spiked the attention of alternative health pathways and increased supplement use for people across the globe, per a study published in Current Developments in Nutrition in 2021.

Liquid vitamins vs. pills and capsules

Are there certain vitamin formulations that are superior to others? Who is taking them and why are important factors, experts say, but by and large, liquid vitamins aren’t vastly better.

“In general, it’s not so much the form but the fit and what you need,” said Caroline Passerrello, assistant professor of nutrition at the University of Pittsburgh School of Health and Rehabilitation Sciences and a spokesperson for the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics. “I really have a conversation with people about why they’re taking it and what else they have going on.”

Caroline Passerrello, instructor in the University of Pittsburgh School of Health and Rehabilitation Sciences (University of Pittsburgh)

There are certain populations where faster absorption of a vitamin, as in a liquid form, may be beneficial or even required, said Passerrello.

Advertise with us

People who have had bariatric surgery or with gastrointestinal conditions like Crohn’s disease or ulcerative colitis often deal with decreased absorption due to an altered digestive system, which can lead to vitamin deficiencies, making them a better fit for liquid vitamin supplements.

And those on GLP-1 drugs, a category that includes Ozempic and Mounjaro, are more prone to dehydration and malnutrition from lower food intake, food aversion and more frequent vomiting.

Liquid vitamins can also be a viable option for people who can’t swallow pills, said Passerrello.

“For bariatric surgery and medical weight loss, there is a reduced amount of absorption. The type of administration really matters,” said Alianna Anselmi, lead dietician at Allegheny Health Network. “An IV or liquid will be absorbed a bit quicker compared to a capsule or tablet.”

But for healthy people with no relevant underlying conditions, this increase in absorption speed isn’t meaningfully different — especially if price is a barrier with a more costly liquid option.

Advertise with us

What about multivitamins?

Is it really necessary to take a multivitamin every day, or are you wasting your money?

Those interviewed said they view multivitamins as a sort of general insurance policy — that is, for the general healthy person, it probably won’t save your life, but taking it likely won’t hurt if it gives you peace of mind.

“I don’t think everyone gets 100% of the recommended daily amount of every vitamin from food alone,” said Anselmi. “It’s nice to cover your bases with generic multi if you don’t have the most diverse or consistent diet or you eat on the go often.”

Certain vitamins are recommended by doctors to certain populations: prenatals for pregnant women, B12 for vegans and calcium for women as they age and enter menopause. Similar to liquid formulations, a multivitamin may be a good option for certain populations, such as older people who have limited diets and thus aren’t getting enough nutrients.

Taking a daily multivitamin may also be attractive to people who want to take just one pill a day.

Advertise with us
For those who shudder at the thought of swallowing pills, liquid formulations can be an alternative. (Shutterstock)

“It takes a lot to become deficient in a vitamin,” said Anselmi. “Certain medical conditions can influence that, but for the normal healthy person at baseline … it might be something to consider depending on your lifestyle, but it’s not super necessary.”

Consider getting checked

Instead of taking pills point-blank, Passerrello said she recommends people contacting their doctor to figure out if they are deficient in any vitamin first. That can be achieved with a blood test.

Passerrello experienced this when she visited her own doctor wanting to learn more.

“We know that many people, especially in Pittsburgh, are not getting enough vitamin D,” she said. “The best thing to do, if possible, is to get your vitamin D levels checked and see where you fall on the spectrum.

“I have a pretty well balanced diet,” she went on. “I thought, you know, I went outside without some sunscreen occasionally, and my vitamin D was well in the deficient zone, so I’ve been supplementing for a while.”

Advertise with us

The IV infusion trend

You may have seen these popping up around town: stores that boast intravenous recoveries at a steep price.

While there are certain physicians who give vitamin and electrolyte cocktails through IV, it’s typically for patients who are very dehydrated. There’s a risk of overdosing, as vitamins administered this way are not going through the checks and balances of the digestive system, which can help break down excess substances.

Fat-soluble vitamins (vitamins A, D, E and K) are easier to overdose on because the body stores them instead of clearing them through the urine, as it does with water-soluble vitamins.

IV infusions are seen more in the hospital setting, “for critically ill patients who really need vitamins,” said Anselmi. “For people at home, it’s really not something you see.”

Check the ingredients list

Before buying a product, it’s worth checking the list of ingredients, said Anselmi and Passerrello.

Advertise with us

“The number one thing is when you’re looking at a supplement that promises all these benefits, look at what’s in it and see if there are other ways to go about it that are more cost effective,” Anselmi said. “I have definitely looked at pills clients have brought me and said, ‘This is basically just biotin and collagen. You could save money by going and buying these individually.’”

The back of the bottle will also have some sort of third-party verification that tells consumers it’s a reputable vitamin. This might be certified organic or a “NSF Certified for Sport” stamp.

“Check the formulation,” recommended Passerrello. “Know your goals. Know what you’re taking.

“That’s more important than how you take it.”